Chapter 21:

Ontological Empire

How to Gaslight YHWH


【POV: Yuria】

My eyes were pinned to the monitor, fingers flicking the mouse across the Obsidian Canvas to visualize the logic behind Phenomenalism. Nodes labeled [Sense-Data], [Physical Objects], and [Existence is Perceivability] were linked by a tangled web of arrows.

The club's Vault was a piece of organized chaos. With sync working perfectly, the four of us can just jump in and mess with each other's notes. I was scanning the diagram when I spotted some new additions by Mari and Tetsuya... Meinongianism?

「Yo, you two.」 I swiveled my chair. 「You just toss this Meinong stuff into the Vault? Since when did you get so interested in "non-existent objects"?」

Mari was perched on the table clutching a tiny screwdriver. She was fully absorbed in a small Galgal—an intricate mechanical construct of nested silver rings.

「Because it's cool, okay?」 Mari replied. 「Meinong argued that even non-existent things like "golden mountains" or "round squares" still have their own properties and deserve to be treated as objects of study. I think the theory is dope as hell, but for some reason, it's always been snubbed and forgotten in philosophical history.」

「You can thank Russell for that.」 Riku chimed in. He was sitting across from Tetsuya at the chessboard.

Tetsuya's voice remained as steady as ever. 「Russell likely fell into a strawman trap when critiquing Meinong. He intentionally twisted Meinong's framework into a contradictory heap to make it a target, whereas Meinong was actually attempting to separate "Subsistence" from "Existence".」

「Go for it, Tetsu! Fight for Meinong's honor!」 Mari cheered while her screwdriver started digging into the Galgal's inner workings. 「I hate nothing more than using logical formulas to stomp on whimsical ideas...」

CRACK!

The Galgal burst open under Mari's tinkering. A flurry of silver rings and gears scattered all over the table. The circles spun wildly before collapsing with a rhythmic clatter-clatter.

「Congratulations, Shushō. You just executed your own pet.」 I let out a sigh and pivoted back to my Canvas. Those angels are truly unfortunate to have a boss like Mari. Though, I didn't suppose Galgalim was capable of feeling a thing.

「Sharp move.」 Tetsuya admitted, his voice tinged with resignation. 「I was too busy calculating my Queen-side posture to notice that corner.」

「It's called tactical vision.」 Riku puffed out his chest, stretching until his back went pop.

While the two boys were dissecting their game, Mari remained hunched over the table playing with the remains of the Galgal. She looped a few tiny silver rings around her fingers like rings and used her screwdriver to flick the gears, sending them spinning. 「Don't you see? Russell, and then Quine... they basically collaborated to build an Ontological Empire.」

She lifted a silver ring, letting the club room light shine through it.

「And the core doctrine of that tyrannical empire? Pure racism against the denizens of Meinong's Jungle! Simply because they don't "exist" in this three-dimensional space, they're robbed of their right to "be" even in theory!」

I could tell from her voice that a lecture was incoming. Having Tetsuya as a co-contributor to her notes had clearly boosted her fervor.

「Those academics are obsessed with Occam's Razor. Always preaching about simplicity, about not postulating entities beyond necessity...」 She folded her arms, looking extremely displeased. 「What's the point? The edge of Occam's Razor is worthless if it shaves off 99.9999% of the world's potential! "Necessity"? Who gets to decide what's "necessary"?」

One hand had just torn an angel apart. The other was flailing around, demanding human rights (or "object rights"?) for things that don't exist.

Riku stopped mid-stretch upon hearing Mari's outburst. He pushed up his glasses. 「Speak Japanese, please... You mean to tell me that anything I write or think up is granted a citizenship passport in this cosmos?」

He poked at his own disheveled head. 「Like, what... a milk tea dragon?!」

Riku slammed his hand on the chessboard, making the wooden pieces clatter. 「But how can you use the flimsy imagination as evidence that "everything exists"?」

Mari's smirk grew wider. 「Listen closely, Riku. Does language exist? It does. Does imagination exist? Unquestionably. It follows that every object of thought must occupy some space within the fabric of existence. You're making the mistake of a rigid binary: either a physical object here, or absolutely nothing.」

She circled the table, leaning back against the edge like a badass character in a movie. 「You like to get all deep, preaching that humans are but specks of dust in the cosmos. Fine, I'm not disputing that. Humans are insignificant.」

Mari pointed a finger directly at Riku. 「However—are humans a part of reality? YES. Try to deny that and I'll smack the teeth out of your mouth. Every thought, delusion, or word your brain spits out is forged from the atoms of this universe.」

Mari hammered home each word, her voice cold and firm. 「Humans and their mess of thoughts are insignificant, but they are not outside of reality. The moment you dreamed up that milk tea dragon, the idea of it was officially granted entry into a region of reality, you dummy!」

I gave my mouse a soft flick, dragging a new card onto the Canvas and quickly labeling it: "The Ontological Empire & Civil Rights for Milk Tea Dragons".

Mari's logic was heading into the danger zone—the land of paradoxes that threatens to shatter the very foundations of logic.

「Wait a second, Mari.」 I swiveled my chair around completely. 「If "round squares" exist, then formal logic is dead on arrival. Something can't be A and not-A at the same time!」

Mari remained unfazed. 「Calm down, Heresy. The inhabitants of Meinong's Jungle aren't exactly a lawless horde of barbarians.」

She stepped closer, fixing her eyes on mine.

「The error Russell fell into—and you're falling for it too—is the silent assumption that "true" requires physical manifestation. To Meinong, "true" is just "true". A round square has the properties of being both "square" and "round"—that is a fact about it, even if it doesn't exist in our space. Stop stapling "existence" onto a purely logical "true".」

「Fine...」 I tapped out a new note in Obsidian. 「Added: [Russell's Fallacy].」 She's lucky my brain is fried earlier because of Phenomenalism. Any other day and I'd settle the score with her. Just you wait, Shushō.

・・・

With a final tap of the keys, I concluded a truly taxing club meeting. The Canvas in Obsidian was now a spiderweb of [Meinongianism], [Non-existent objects], and a long list of "screw you" notes directed at Russell.

Mari sat perched on the table wearing a triumphant smirk, like a Prime Minister who had just passed a social welfare policy for the denizens of Meinong's Jungle.

Tetsuya silently packed the last of the chess pieces into their wooden box. 「So, in effect... are humans attempting (perhaps unknowingly) to carry out an... ontological self-erasure?」

Hmm... That has a nice ring to it, doesn't it? I instantly created a new Note in the Vault, typing the phrase with more than a little excitement. [Ontological Self-Erasure].

「Bingo!」 Mari snapped her fingers. 「Tetsu, that's a killer name! Keep it in there, Yuria. I'm definitely going to use that term to troll some online professors later.」

「Got it, got it.」 I hit [Ctrl + S] and flipped the laptop shut. Standing up to stretch, the satisfying crack of my spine after two hours of sitting still felt like pure bliss. 「That's a wrap for today. The milk tea dragon in my head is starting to demand physical existence.」

「Me too! Let's go, Tetsu!」 Mari wasted no time, diving in to grab Tetsuya by the arm.

〈Mari's Note for Mortals〉

Alright, so Meinongianism has been covered pretty clearly, and we'll be coming back to it later, so let's skip the small talk for now, shall we?

Don't dismiss it as nonsense, though. It actually mirrors what coders do all the time: Object Definition. No theory is inherently useless; you just need to find a use for it, clear? Anyone who wants to debate that can expect a punch to the face!

What's more interesting is the Principle of Explosion that Yuria mentioned. This isn't just about people bickering.
If you let a single contradiction slip into a logical system, the entire structure collapses, allowing you to prove any absurdity—like the Sun revolving around a banana, or Mari being the cutest girl ever (actually, that one is an self-evident truth...)

Time for some nerd symbols:
• P is true.
• ¬P (not P) is also true.
• Because P is true, the proposition "P or Q" (P ∨ Q) must be true (with Q being anything you choose, for example: "You pooped your pants yesterday").
• We already have ¬P as true. And from Step 1, "P ∨ Q" is true. In a true "OR" pair: if one side is false, the other side must be true. Since P is negated by ¬P...
• Conclusion: Q is true.

BAM! The system exploded. Therefore, you definitely pooped your pants yesterday. www.

Darth Anakris
icon-reaction-1
Gemini Daydream
icon-reaction-4
OmegaC
badge-small-bronze
Author: