Chapter 21:

Truth and Choice

The Odd Lamp


He wanted to say more.

He wanted to hear her again.

Her hands were still warm on his face. The air still held her scent… but it was faint now.

He couldn’t do it.

Henrik grabbed the Man in White by the collar of his suit. Grip tightened, knuckles straining as his vision blurred with tears.

“I—I don’t care… Bri—BRING THEM BACK.”

The Man in White didn’t react. Didn’t resist. He only tilted his head slightly, lowering the brim of the fedora.

“Even though you said it yourself?” he asked.

Henrik tried to respond, but only a ragged breath escaped.

None of it was real.

He held the collar tighter for half a second longer, then let go, pushing the man back a step.

He needed answers before deciding on what to do—what to think.

“Who…” Henrik swallowed. “What were they?”

The Man in White straightened his suit and adjusted its collar, unfazed by Henrik’s outburst

“Three of the four tendencies.”

“…What does that even mean?”

He waved at the space around them as if it meant something.

“We are what make up this place. Its structure… its behavior. Its feelings.”

“We?”

“We share the same space,” the man said simply. “Yes, with different functions. Different convictions. But in the end—it is still only us. One and the same.”

Henrik looked around again, slower this time.

“…And what is this place?”

The Man in White didn’t answer immediately.

“You could call it a mind, perhaps,” he said finally. “Or maybe it’s something greater. I do not insist on the name. I have no way of truly knowing, I can only show you the flaws in them.”

“The four tendencies…” Henrik recalled.

“Correct. Mirth, Curiosity, Comfort.”

A pause.

“…and Truth.”

“There is the thing that waits beyond all of it. It does not laugh. It does not wonder. It does not soothe. It remains exactly where it has always been, patient and still, while the others take their turns. And when they are finished, it is still there… until the moment comes when it can no longer be ignored.”

Truth did not blank from existence.

“You… You’re still here.”

Truth gave a small shrug.

“One cannot simply ignore me after I have been found.”

Henrik looked down at the emptiness beneath him. There was no floor, yet he stood on something solid.

There was no air, yet he breathed.

“Comfort and Mirth…” he said quietly. “They were trying to stop me from seeing you?”

Truth tilted his head slightly.

“Stop is not the correct phrase.”

“…Then what were they doing?”

“Completing their role.”

“Were they… bad?”

Truth shook his head once.

“Not at all. They performed their function precisely as intended. As all of us do. There is no black and white—no right and wrong. Only expression. Each tendency acts according to what it is.”

“Comfort and Mirth…” Henrik repeated. “All the good things?”

“Food,” Truth said. “Homeliness. Order. Love. Discipline. Humor. Joy. Reason. The things one appreciates—savors. The things that make it tolerable.”

A slight pause.

“The little things in life.”

Henrik didn’t respond immediately. His hands hung at his sides now, empty.

“So the medicine...”

Truth nodded. “Indeed, that was an aspect of Comfort—Reason. A way of bringing you comfort, a placebo to justify what was happening to this place.”

That big restaurant…

Henrik still did not trust him, but what else was there to even trust at this point?

“Curiosity and you…”

“One invokes thoughts, the other waits at the end of them.”

What were they trying to show him?

“Why were you trying to—to break this place? Why? Couldn’t you just let it be—”

“You would rather live in a tale?” Truth did not soften the words, but there was no cruelty in them either. “Would you?”

Henrik winced at the reply.

“I—It’s not that…” He rubbed his head, looking around as if the answer might be sitting somewhere in the space itself. “It’s… complicated. I just—”

Truth raised a hand, cutting him off.

Then he turned and pointed to the figure in the chair.

Henrik had forgotten about him… and the table with something colorful trembling atop it.

The two of them walked toward the scene. The man in the chair… his details weren’t clear, but something about him sat too close to familiarity.

Truth gestured at the tower of blocks in front of him, then to the man in the chair.

“You may be wondering where you fit in all of this… it’s up to you now.”

“Me? What am I—”

“But there is one more part that stands between all the others. It listens to the laughter, the questions, the reassurances, the warnings.

After the laughter fades, after the questions tire themselves out, after comfort has said all it can say, after it has been shown what is true.

It hears every voice and still must decide which one to follow. It is not wisdom, nor courage, nor certainty. More often, it is simply the act of moving anyway.

Every mind arrives there eventually, at the point where it must decide what it can live with.

It is Choice.”

Henrik staggered forward and grabbed the edge of the table, steadying himself.

The voice behind the words sounded different—not like Truth. It didn’t resonate in the space around him, only in his head.

It seemed these words were only for him.

“I… I think I understand now.”

Truth pointed at the tower of blocks. It quivered and swayed. A gentle blow would have been enough to set it crumbling.

“If you understand all there is to know, then do what you must.”

Henrik could rebuild the tower, stabilize it—restore the world he had lived in for so long.

…Or he could break it.

Henrik glanced at the figure across him. It remained still, like it always had, but a sound came from it too.

Something sad.

“What is that?” Henrik asked. “Is he a tendency too?”

Truth shook his head. “I am not sure myself, but it was something we had to conquer.”

“If I had to guess… it may be Preservation.”

“Preservation?”

Truth bent his fedora low. “Truth destroys the illusion, Preservation tries to keep it standing.”

Denial. Longing for something that didn’t exist. That’s what it was.

And in this moment it changed once more. The pale colors hardened, the edges became clear, the face took shape.

Henrik found himself looking at a man with his face.

“If you step outside this, there may not be anything left to return to.”

Henrik stiffened. Preservation did not meet his glance, instead it kept its eyes on the table… and its tower of blocks.

Choose.

Henrik had longed for autonomy, a free will. To not be forced into some play he could not comprehend.

He had it now. He had a choice.

Haruto, Sam… Maria.

He could have them all back. Rebuild it from scratch—maybe even better this time. Something that didn’t break, something that would never fail.

And he could live like that for as long as he wanted… permanently.

“I could fix this place… I could make it so the tower would never fall. Make it so nothing would ever be wrong with it.”

Truth did not reply. His posture did not change.

Preservation did not reply. His posture did not change.

After a long silence, both of them spoke at the same time.

“Yes.”

Henrik stayed still for a moment, letting it settle properly. A world that corrected itself, people that didn’t drift, moments that didn’t rot or slip when he wasn’t looking. No gaps, no inconsistencies, no missing edges.

Everything would make sense, just like he wanted.

It would be perfect.

It sounded like control. It sounded like safety.

…But it also sounded wrong.

Because the part of him that had always looked at outlines and drafts before anything else kept catching the same detail.

Nothing here would carry stress. Nothing would be allowed to show where it failed.

Henrik didn’t know many things, but this wasn’t one of them.

Nothing would accumulate damage. Nothing would hold weight long enough to reveal where it was weak. Not just the structures—but the people inside them.

For some reason, he knew this wasn’t how it was supposed to be. Something inside him was telling him so.

There would always be cracks in the concrete.

But this place would not remember anything. It would have no cracks.

And Henrik couldn’t bring himself to accept that.

His jaw tightened slightly.

“I can’t…” he said quietly, almost to himself at first.

Then again, firmer this time.

“I can’t… stay in something that won’t let anything break.”

His choice felt final in a very ordinary way.

Haruto, Sam, Maria. None of them were real in the way he had once believed, but what they represented were.

And Henrik felt like they would be proud with what he decided.

He reached out, grabbed a block, and pulled it free.

Reds, yellows, blues flew up into the space—then down. Henrik felt each block as it struck the table and ground around it.

He heard every one, the details each carried, the small things, the big ones.

All of it.

Preservation watched as each one finally stopped rolling and settled into place. He did not say a word, but stood up and reached out a hand.

Henrik grasped it firmly.

“You have made a choice.”

Henrik blinked—and there was a door in front of him. Plain wood, a golden-yellow handle. His hand was already wrapped around it.

Preservation was nowhere to be seen.

“I…” Henrik frowned slightly. “Is this it?”

Truth stepped forward and opened the door.

Behind the door was a void of nothing, pitch black against the white of everything else. Darker than anything Henrik had ever seen.

Truth looked at it for a moment before turning to Henrik.

“This is the outcome of your choice.”

Henrik carefully stepped up to the edge of the door, peering inside.

“What’s over there?”

Truth tilted his head, also gazing into the dark with non-existent eyes.

“I do not know.”

“Aren’t you Truth? I thought you knew everything?”

“What you sought has been given. My role is complete. You have made a choice. Now take it.”

What he sought…

Would things make sense now?

“Uhh… I-I guess this is goodbye?” Henrik placed a hand on Truth’s shoulder and gave it a couple of awkward pats.

Truth looked at the hand, then back at him. “We are one and the same. There is no goodbye required. I will always—”

“Yeah. Yeah, okay.”

No point getting sentimental with “Truth” of all things.

It was time to see if this choice mattered at all.

Henrik stepped forward… and dropped into the door.

No wind. No sound.

Just a fall into nothing surrounded by pitch black.

Then, in the distance, something began to take shape. Narrow and grey, with yellow stripes along its sides—and it was approaching fast.

Too fast.

It was right in front of him.

“Wait… wo—WOAH—”

Henrik threw his arms up, shielding his face, eyes squeezed shut. He stayed like that for a few seconds before slowly peeking through.

The surface was inches above him. He was suspended right over it.

He blinked. Exhaled slowly.

That was close.

—Then his head hit the ground.