Chapter 12:

Counterfeit Smile

Between the Lines


Danny's birthday party had been on the calendar for weeks, a fact Mike reminded Caspian of no fewer than four times over the course of the preceding Friday, each reminder slightly more theatrical than the last, culminating in a hand-drawn flyer taped to Caspian's locker that read, in Mike's chaotic all-caps handwriting, MANDATORY FUN, SATURDAY, 7 PM, BRING SNACKS OR DON'T BOTHER SHOWING UP (JOKING) (MOSTLY).Caspian almost didn't go.He stood in front of his closet for a long time Saturday evening, jeans and a plain shirt already picked out and laid across his bed, and felt the specific, heavy resistance of a body that did not want to leave the room it was in, a resistance that had nothing to do with tiredness in the ordinary sense and everything to do with the accumulated weight of the last two weeks, the pulling away, the fog thickening at the edges of everything.He went anyway. He told himself it was because Mike would notice if he didn't, would ask about it, would worry more than he already clearly was, and some small, stubborn part of Caspian still wanted to spare him that, even now, even as the effort of getting dressed and walking three blocks to Danny's house felt disproportionately, absurdly large.The party was loud in the specific, chaotic way house parties full of seventeen-year-olds always were, music too loud for the size of the living room, someone's older sibling's speaker system pushed past what it was built for, a cluster of people in the kitchen arguing cheerfully about a card game, the whole house lit with string lights someone had wound around the porch railing and, inexplicably, the ceiling fan.Caspian found Mike almost immediately, holding court near the snack table, mid-story, gesturing with a chip like it was a prop essential to the plot. "Caspian! You came! I was starting to think you'd abandoned me to survive this alone." He threw an arm around him, warm and easy, and for a moment, folded into the noise and the light and Mike's arm around his shoulders, Caspian felt something like relief, something almost like being carried along by a current instead of fighting to stay above it.The feeling didn't last. It rarely did anymore.He moved through the party the way he'd learned to move through most social situations lately, present enough to avoid comment, distant enough to conserve whatever was left in the tank. He said hello to people. He laughed at jokes on cue, the timing practiced now, automatic, a reflex more than a response. He accepted a drink he didn't really want and held it mostly untouched, using it as a prop, something to occupy his hands so nobody would ask why they were empty.Around nine, Danny gathered everyone in the living room for the ritual of the birthday toast, a tradition that had started as a joke sophomore year and calcified, the way jokes do, into something everyone took seriously now, a round of people saying something nice, or something funny, or, in Mike's case, both, layered with enough sincerity underneath the bit that half the room ended up laughing and the other half looked briefly, unexpectedly moved."Caspian," Danny said, turning to him with the easy expectation of someone who'd known him since freshman year, "you gotta say something. Come on."The room's attention swung toward him, warm, expectant, entirely unaware of what it was asking. He felt the old machinery kick in, fast, automatic, the mask sliding into place before he'd even consciously reached for it. "Danny," he said, raising his cup, letting a small, easy grin settle onto his face like it belonged there, "you're the only person I know who can make a birthday party feel like a fire hazard and a hug at the same time. Happy birthday, man. Don't grow up too fast, none of us are ready."It landed. People laughed, genuinely, someone clapped Danny on the shoulder, the toast rolled on to the next person, and Caspian lowered his cup and felt, underneath the applause, a wave of something close to nausea, close to disgust, though not quite either one, a feeling without a name he liked, watching how easily the room had accepted the performance, how convincing it had been, how far the words had traveled from anything actually happening behind his ribs.He excused himself not long after, slipping out to the back porch under the pretense of getting air, and stood there for a while in the cold, string lights buzzing faintly overhead, the noise of the party muffled through the sliding door behind him, close enough to hear, far enough to feel like a different world entirely.He didn't cry. He just stood there, breath fogging in the cold air, hands gripping the porch railing hard enough that his knuckles went pale, and felt, for a long, quiet moment, the full weight of how tired he was of being convincing. Of how much energy the toast had cost him, the easy grin, the timed laugh lines, the whole architecture of seeming fine in front of a room full of people who liked him, who would have, if he'd let them, actually wanted to know how he was.The door slid open behind him. He didn't turn around, already knowing, from the particular rhythm of the footsteps, who it was."Hey," Mike said, coming to stand beside him at the railing, not crowding him, just there, close enough to matter. "You disappeared.""Needed air.""Yeah." Mike was quiet for a moment, looking out at the dark backyard, the porch light catching the edge of his face. "That was a good toast, by the way. Real crowd-pleaser.""Thanks.""Didn't sound like you, though."Caspian's hands tightened on the railing again, an old reflex. "What do you mean.""I don't know. It sounded like a toast someone gives at a party. It didn't sound like, I don't know, you actually being here." Mike said it carefully, without accusation, just laying the observation down between them and letting it sit, the way he'd learned to over the last few weeks, patient in a way that cost him more than Caspian fully understood yet. "I'm not trying to start anything. I just noticed."Caspian didn't answer right away. The music thumped faintly through the door behind them, the string lights buzzed, somewhere down the street a car alarm went off and cut out again. "I don't really know how to be here differently right now," he said finally, the closest thing to the truth he'd managed to say out loud in days, small and quiet against the vast, unspoken shape of everything underneath it.Mike nodded slowly, like he'd been expecting something close to that answer and had decided, in advance, not to push past it. "Okay," he said. "You don't have to. Just, whenever you're ready to actually tell me what's going on, I'm right here. Not going anywhere. Even if it takes a while."They stood at the railing a while longer, not talking, the cold settling into Caspian's hands, the party noise a distant, muffled hum behind the glass. He didn't say anything else that night. But the offer sat there between them, quiet and unclaimed, and some small, exhausted part of him filed it away, carefully, the way you'd keep a spare key somewhere safe, not needing it yet, but grateful, in some dim and distant way, to know exactly where it was.

Smoothie
Author: