Chapter 6:
LILIANE
The meeting room at Sunburst Records had the brightness of professionalism rather than comfort. Fluorescent lights, a polished table long enough to seat twelve, and whiteboards flanking a large LCD screen that shows revenue charts on one side and a fan heatmap on the other. It was the kind of room where numbers were meant to feel inevitable.
Benio stood at the screen, clicking through slides with an analytical precision. Hinata, Yurine, and Inaba sat around the table with notebooks open and cups of coffee and tea steaming in front of them.
Marina was absent—her Melodia Music Center shift ran through the morning. But she had left notes, which Benio had incorporated into the deck.
Their manager, Akira Kuroda, sat at the end of the table with a tablet and professionalism.
Benio then advanced to the slide:
Q3 Revenue Breakdown
"Since May 2023 and into March 2025, our merchandise sales had increased by 62%." Her voice was measured and factual.
"Our hoodie sales and limited vinyl run are moving consistently post-anime tie-in. Streaming royalties from Heaven's Cry are still topping across every platform."
Two years ago, that single had done something none of them had fully predicted. Crafted specifically for the opening of Heaven's Fall Season 1. An alternative symphonic metal banger with Hinata's voice moving from ethereal to something ferocious, orchestral strings blending with chunky distorted riffs over a double-kick groove.
It had reached further than Mythical Maze had.
It hooked anime viewers who had never heard distorted bass before in their lives. Casual listeners who came back and forth. And metalheads who had been waiting for something like it.
More press coverage. Interview requests. Festival slots. Venue capacities that had previously felt aspirational becoming logistical concerns.
"But we need to think bigger," Akira interjected. She moved to another slide. "Our CEO is pushing for overseas gigs. The anime opening gave us greater recognition in a market we have not yet cultivated previously."
Inaba raised her hand and somewhat objected. "Overseas gig? It sounds nice on paper, but jet lag might kill us mid-journey."
She shook her head slowly, imagining it. "I mean—our Heaven's Cry tour two years ago was a torture. That's why we need to be very careful about this decision."
"Make sense." Akira nodded solemnly. "Instead, we will focus on the market with the strongest existing fanbase and minimal travel strain."
Benio moved to another slide with pins clustered across East and Southeast Asia.
International Fan Heatmap.
"Taiwan and South Korea both have dedicated communities: cover bands, translation groups, and active fan channels. But Thailand is the loudest. The fanbase feuds, petitions, and fan art flooded their internet domain."
The room absorbed this. Hinata leaned back in her chair. The overseas conversation was interesting and all, but she was aware of the logistical problem they will face.
"Unfortunately... I have to agree with Ina-san for this one." A beat. "I mean... The Zepp Osaka two years ago was a pain in the ass. Seems like we made a rushed decision due to our exhaustion at that time."
The room knew what she meant. Benio's face remained sharp; she also knew that Hinata meant it as an experience.
"Speaking of which, Murasaki-san." Benio clicks to a new blank slide titled simply Album 2. "Since the development was a greenlight, what are you proposing?"
Hinata stood. The chair scraped behind her. She moved to the screen with anticipation and a sliver of dread. The gap between what was in her head and what could be communicated in a meeting room had never felt wider.
She opened her first slide.
Three concept art images filled the screen, each commissioned from three different artists and each representing a direction she had been considering.
First: A dystopian, clinical scene—a woman suspended inside a human incubation chamber, her body threaded with wires and needles, a respirator mask over her face. The figure was none other than Furias herself. A self-portrait inside a simulation she could not wake from. The work belonged to a sci-fi illustrator named Gamoon, whose line quality sat at the intersection of science fiction and medical horror.
Second: A dark fantasy painted in an abstract setting—mass crucifixion above the lake of blood, a blood-eclipsed moon suspended over a blackened sky. The work that belonged to Krilliotan is dense and apocalyptic, the kind of image that requires time to look at.
Third: A misty forest at night, cracked mirrors at its center, and a distorted, lanky figure reflected in the fragments—clutching what appeared to be the broken neck of a Telecaster-shaped guitar. A contribution from Mikomikochin, built in the unsettling visual language of Trevor Henderson's liminal horror like something glimpsed in the corner of your eye.
"I want to be honest about where this album is coming from before I talk about what it sounds like," Hinata started. "So—the Budokan show last December. Most of you were there. And you know how the story ended."
The room nodded.
She pointed at Yurine, who let out a small uncomfortable smile. "It starts with Furias backstabbing Calculus. As Calculus was getting too close with Vanitas, jealousy had consumed her."
"That set everything in motion. Vanitas, Nemesis, and Pulsaris conspired against Furias. They crucified her on the burned cross. Thus, Furias died for what she had done."
"But Vanitas betrayed them all. She backstabbed Pulsaris. And when Nemesis caught her—it was already too late. One swift stab in her chest, Nemesis was gone too."
"Vanitas had lost herself. She burned herself alive. The last one standing, and she chose not to stand anymore."
"Five deities. Five deaths. The maze consumed everyone inside it."
"The second album picks up from there. It's not a continuation but an aftermath. How miscommunication is taken to its absolute consequence. When the people who built something suddenly destroy it from the inside."
She let it sit for a moment.
She moved to the next slide: the comparison. Mythical Maze on the left. Untitled second album on the right.
"Mythical Maze was theatrical. We built a mythology, and we performed it. I want the second one to be rawer than that. Heavier. And more honest to ourselves. The foundation has remained the same, but I want to push it into places we haven't explored more."
"Harder element, industrial textures, ambient noises."
"I'm talking about..." a beat. "Djent."
The room nodded. She looked at Benio, whose face remained unfazed. Although Hinata personally knew, her eyes behind the glass were showing a slight disapproval.
Moving on to the next slide, she played the demo. It was titled In Memoriam of Asako Fujimura, and it ran for just two minutes.
It opened with a groove that felt almost inviting. Chunky distorted riffs in Drop F locked into Inaba's pattern, the bass sitting low and distorted underneath. Then Hinata's voice arrived, soft in the verses, a vulnerability she did not often let into recordings. The chorus was a different instrument entirely: guttural and full-throated. And then Marina's backing vocal appeared—a ghostly, ethereal layer threading under her guttural scream.
The room was quiet when it ended. Inaba set her tea down with care. Yurine was looking at her hands.
Asako Fujimura, the former lead vocalist of Gardenoir—a gothic rock band whose Victorian aesthetic had predated Harmoniac's theatrical ambitions and whose sound was the first things that directed Hinata's desired sound.
But two years ago, Asako had died of a brain tumor.
Hinata had been there.
Witnessing the deterioration in real time, to understand what it meant when someone who taught you something irreplaceable was no longer in the world.
The second album had always been pointing toward this. She understood that she hadn't been able to articulate before she heard the demo back.
Benio adjusted her glass, head lowered. "I have one question. Why should we make our second album sound like that?"
Hinata's voice was becoming quieter. "Fujimura-san told me once. Make the audience feel like they're involved on the stage instead of just watching it."
She looked at the demo title on the screen. "This album is me stopping managing the distance between us and the audiences."
Benio adjusted her glasses. "I understand the artistic reasoning. But I want to ask a structural question." Her voice was measured.
Hinata nodded, giving Benio way to continue. "When you say to be more honest to ourselves, what does that mean for the audience we have already built?"
Hinata was about to respond, but Benio continued anyway. "I'm not asking rhetorically. I'm asking this because I need to know whether you have thought about this specifically."
A pause. "First of all, do you know what the age demography of our current listener base is?"
Hinata slightly hesitated. "Mostly 18 to 24. But some older hardcore listeners—"
"That means 59% of the demography," Benio shot back. "But that's not a rough majority yet. That's nearly two-thirds of everyone who's listening to us. And before recognizing Harmoniac and before Heaven's Cry hit the chart—what were they listening to in the first place?”
Hinata remained silent. The room had gone still during Benio's statistical deployment.
"J-Pop, Lo-Fi hip hop, and short-form content optimized for thirty-second attention spans. They came to us through an anime opening, which means the first thing they'd recognize was Heaven's Cry—our most accessible record, built specifically for those who had never encountered this genre before. That's not an accident. That's how we built the fanbase we currently have."
She pulled up a secondary breakdown on her tablet and set it flat on the table where Hinata could see it.
"The listeners who actively seek out hardcore slam—" Benio tapped the tablet's screen. "—they do exist in our fanbase, but not the majority. Approximately 3% to 6%. They have been with us since before the anime deal, and they're not going anywhere. But they're not the main foundation of our fanbase. Not even close."
She looked up. "If you build the second album for that 3 to 6%, you are alienating 94% of our fanbase. Sure, some of them will follow, but most of them will not. And the ones who follow will not replace the ones who leave, because hardcore listeners don't stream the way casuals do. The number does not lie."
Hinata had been listening. Her frustration slowly builds up, not because she was losing an argument, but because her arguments were being correctly summarized and then incorrectly concluded.
"You're describing who our audience was," Benio continued. "Not who it can become. Those aren't different things when the second album drops in an environment where your streaming numbers determine whether labels continue investing."
"Artistic aspiration doesn't exist in a vacuum. If Sunburst pulls support because the record underperforms, we lose the platform we need to make the music you're describing." Benio finished.
"Then we're already compromised." Hinata stood still, remaining headstrong as ever. "Before this conversation, before this room, before the green light—if our goal of making music were to be marketable so the label keeps funding it, then we're not even making music at all. We're literally using the same old cookie cutter with no substance at all!"
"Also," Hinata raised one finger. "Do you think our audiences could stay with us in the next five years if we show no improvement whatsoever? Huh?"
Benio regarded her for a moment. "That's a coherent position. But it's also the position that'll end careers."
"Fujimura-san's career ended, of course." Hinata cut her short. "She died. But what she left behind still matters. It still reached people. It reached me, and I'm standing in this room because of it. If the choice is between making something that survives comfortably and making something that's actually honest—I already know which one Fujimura-san would've chosen. And so do I."
"I'm not saying to remove the accessibility entirely." She continued, her voice steadier now. "I'm saying we can't keep calibrating every creative decision against the casual, friendly ceiling. Heaven's Cry worked because it was genuine."
She then pointed at Benio. "Lamb to Slaughter on Furias's EP—you said it to yourself—was our least listened-to track. Do you know what our underground fanbase says about that song? 'That's the most Harmoniac thing we have ever recorded!' That sounds like we stopped asking for permission."
"But it also lost us listeners!" Benio asserted. But her voice shifted slightly. "We are aware that losing listeners has a cost, and that's not abstract. It affects what we're able to do next."
"Then let the cost be real!" Hinata stood determined. "Let us find out who stays when we stop making it easier to stay. Because those who stay after that are our actual audience. Not those anime watchers, nor algorithm addicts. But the one we build by being exactly what we are."
Benio stood to change the weight of the room. Her towering frame was looming over Hinata. "Heaven's Cry is our most listened-to record because it's the most accessible thing we have produced. Lamb to Slaughter is our least listened to because it's the least accessible. That's not a coincidence. That's the relationship between difficulty and audience, and it's not negotiable through idealism."
The room becomes quiet. Yurine is looking at the table. Inaba clenched her tea cup and wasn't moving.
"I want the second album to be extraordinary, of course. But I also don't want it to destroy the infrastructure that lets us make the third one."
Neither of them spoke. This was between Hinata and Benio, and inserting a joke or a softening gesture right now would be catching themselves in the crossfire.
Akira Kuroda had been listening from the beginning. She set her tablet down. "Pardon for the intrusion. Can I say something?"
No one objected.
"You are both right," Akira interjected. "That's the problem with this argument. You're both right about different things, but you're each treating the other's right thing as though it's wrong."
"Murasaki-san." Her eyes darted at Hinata. "The artistic case you're making is real, and it's important that this band isn't always making the safer version of your music."
Hinata slowly lowered her head.
"Suzukaze-san." She eyed Benio. "The structural case you're making is also real, but pretending artistic value doesn't matter doesn't make them matter less."
Benio's eyes softened.
She eyed them. "What I'm hearing isn't a disagreement about whether to make this album honest. I think you both want that." A pause. "What I'm hearing is a disagreement about how much to trust the audience you have. Murasaki-san things they'll follow if you lead. Suzukaze-san thinks that assumption hasn't been tested at this level of risk."
"Now here's what I think." A pause. "Being hated for being fully honest is better than being liked for being careful. That might sound clichéd, but it's practically proven. If this record alienates part of your audience because it's exactly what you needed to make, the audience that stays will be more committed, vocal, and durable than the one you're protecting right now."
"Labels understand that. Sunburst understood it when they greenlit Mythical Maze. They'll understand it here too if the work justifies the risk."
"Murasaki-san." She looked at Hinata. "Readjust the concept without compromising the core of your idea. No need to make it safer, just make it clearer."
"Suzukaze-san." She looked at Benio. "I need you to accept that some of the risk here is necessary. That's what the second album has to be."
Benio remained silent for a moment. Then she adjusted her glasses, gave Hinata a brief sharp glance, and returned to her seat.
Hinata returned to her slide. The presentation continued.
She had said what she needed to say. She had meant it.
But she wasn't entirely sure the inside and the outside were still different places.
Please sign in to leave a comment.