Chapter 11:

The Doll and the Mære

Lilith in Dreamland


The colosseum was a massive marble elliptical structure with tiered spectator seats, all of which were filled to the brim. The onlookers’ chatter collectively created such a roar that it seemed as if the spectacle had already begun. At the head of the stadium was a protected, elevated area perfectly situated for maximum visibility. The distance from the other spectators and the lavish red decor within the gated box were telltale signs that that was where the Red Queen herself would watch from. However, on this day it was empty, as the Red Queen was down below, feet on the crimson-colored dirt, eagerly expecting his adversary’s arrival.

At ground level sat three cages, small cells containing Sir Albus, Fiddle Dumb, and Fiddle Dee. They were chained, restrained from movement, and gagged so none could even offer Lilith an encouraging word. They visibly acknowledged each other with their eyes; it had been a long time since they could be in each other’s presence. The last remaining vestiges of the White Queen’s reign. The only thing they could do now was to wait for their fate to be sealed. Whatever the outcome, they all sat up straight, determined to undermine Cheshire’s desire for them. They understood that this was merely another way to torment them: to remain unable to help as Lilith faced possible failure on her own. Their silent determination was overlooked.

Ruber nervously attended to his queen, steadily fanning consistent cool winds to offset potential sweaty discomfort the blood-red armor might inflict. Cheshire lounged under an awning, protected from eyes that wished to gaze a bit too long. There was only one thing on Cheshire’s mind—how sporting he wished to be towards Lilith. Would he completely decimate her and instantly crush that hopeful glimmer still flickering behind her eyes, or would he cultivate that hope for a more devastating final blow? The thought brought a devilish grin to his face, and just as he was leaning towards a more playful match, Lilith’s head sheepishly popped out from the challenger’s door. Although she was still obscured by the door’s frame, Mad Dotter was plain to see, and that was enough to elicit excitement.

Lilith stood wide-eyed, holding Mad Dotter’s reins at her side. The colosseum was immensely larger than she had imagined, and her hands became sweaty all at once. All those eyes shifting her way. The ball was nothing in comparison, and her breathing labored. Even Mad Dotter took notice and began nuzzling her cheek with his grumpy-looking face. Her shaking hand reached up to stroke his side, but his attempt to ease her apprehension wasn’t helping.

“T,thank you, Mad Dotter…I’m trying. I am so grateful that you’re here, but I’m still so frightened.” Her eyes closed as she tried to calm her breathing, but to no avail. She buried her face into the betta’s flowing fins. Lil, snap out of it. This is the last chance. She thought about Sir Albus and the Fiddle brothers, how they were so encouraging even though their plights were more miserable than hers. Oh, where are they?

Remembering Cheshire had said something about them watching, she opened her eyes and searched the seats, expecting them to be somewhere above, but Mad Dotter steered her line of sight to the ground level. She gasped to herself when she realized her friends were imprisoned within those cages. Her brow furrowed as she thought of how they must feel: alone, terrified, degraded. Her quick breathing slowed, her fear slowly overtaken by a strange calm.

She looked all the way to the opposing side of the arena, where Cheshire was watching her from. With Mad Dotter’s reins in one hand, and her other hand clenched over her heart, she stepped out from the shadows for all to see. And, as expected, the sight of her caused quite a reaction. Exposing her armor in all its pink glory, with pure white accents, a unified gasp overtook the spectators. Just as she had shocked the masked ball guests, she had done so again.

Although constrained by their harnesses, Sir Albus and the Fiddles could only smile proudly as Lilith walked with her head held high. It felt as though the White Queen was with them. Their apprehension suspended for a moment as they saw she had Mad Dotter by her side, a friendly face that they had not glimpsed in so long. One they thought had already succumbed to the Red Queen’s abyss. Even though Mad Dotter could not speak, he was still there, in her corner.

Cheshire’s eyes widened at the sight of her; each trial she surpassed his expectations. “Oho ho ho, do you even realize how every choice you’ve made will only drag you deeper into the chasm of despair, Little Lilith? Yes, enjoy your last fleeting moments of hope.” Cheshire spoke his thoughts out loud, emboldening Ruber to express his own thoughts.

“Your Majesty, she will undoubtedly understand her place once this farce is over.” Ruber added, quite pleased with himself; however, it was ill-received. Cheshire’s grin turned flat as his curt scrutiny briefly turned to Ruber.

“Know your place, Ruber. You are merely a triviality created to further antagonize that white rabbit. Once he is gone, you will no longer hold the same appeal, so bite your tongue.”

Ruber’s head bowed as his hands shook. If there was one thing he was envious about regarding Sir Albus, it was that Sir Albus had an unfathomable fortitude to oppose the current rule of Dreamland. Ruber, like most, attributed Albus’s tenacity to the fact that beings created by White Queen Alise’s very hands were eternal and could never be destroyed. Unlike him; it was the only thing that separated them, they were similar in every other aspect. Where else could such courage come from? Knowing the Red Queen’s ever fickle nature, it was only a matter of time before Ruber’s existence would cease.

Cheshire’s attention fell back onto Lilith, who seemed to be in need of some assistance, as she had no one in her corner to convey the next steps.

“Ruber,” Cheshire’s eye slid to observe him jolt. “Go instruct Lilith on what to do next. And call Walrus to attend to her jousting needs.” Just as Ruber was about to scurry over, Cheshire added, “Say nothing unnecessary.”

With his mouth locked shut Ruber nodded his head multiple times and hurried over to Lilith. As Lilith saw Ruber rushing toward her, she steeled herself, not knowing what to expect from him.

Out of breath, he huffed, “It, it is time.” He took a few more gulps of air and then regained his composure. “You have been well-versed in the rules?” He waited for her to acknowledge, and once she nodded her head, he continued. “Very well, where is that fool Walrus?” Ruber scuttled past her and peeked his head through the door. “Walrus, by the Red Queen’s command, you are summoned!”

“Eh?” Walrus replied from the deep corridor. “Me?”

Ruber nodded vehemently.

“Well, I s’ppose.” Walrus waddled out into the stadium ground and rested his flipper on his hip. “What is thy command?” He replied nonchalantly.

Ruber scoffed, “Simply attend the basic needs of a challenger, nothing else.” He stressed, “No unnecessary prattle.” Ruber quickly looked back towards the Red Queen, “I must return to my post, so do as commanded.” With that Ruber scurried off into the distance, back whence he came.

Walrus looked down toward Lilith, who stared up at him, unsure of what to do. Walrus sighed, “Well, time to mount up.”

Lilith’s stomach turned; while she may have found a strange calm within herself, she was on the verge of breaking back into a panic attack. Mad Dotter nudged her arm, as if to say, “It’s time to go. Let’s do it.” Never having ridden anything before, Lilith placed her foot into the saddle’s stirrup, but took a few deep breaths before hoisting herself upward. Once she felt her stomach was more settled, she lifted herself up and over, securing her seat on the saddle. As soon as she had situated herself, Mad Dotter burst with excitement and thrust forward towards the crowd. He jumped and pranced for all of them to see while Lilith held on for dear life, doing everything in her power to stay upright.

Mad Dotter’s prideful display soon ended, and he flounced back to where Walrus was standing with Lilith’s lance.

“Told yah, he’s a wild one.”

Lilith’s hand was glued to her helmet, keeping it in place after Mad Dotter’s antics. Worried that it would twist and shift around as much during the match, Walrus anticipated her internal question.

“If you are only going straight, and not flopping around so carelessly, your helm should stay put.”

Gulping loudly, she held onto Mad Dotter’s reins with both hands and looked at Walrus with a lost expression. He merely sighed and lifted her lance. Gazing at it, she balled her fists, then held out her right hand.

He shook his head, “Palm up, thumb on the right side.” He turned her hand to match his instruction, then placed the lance’s base into her palm. After she had a firm, proper grip, he let go, allowing her to hold the full weight of the lance. Lilith had expected it to feel heavier, but was relieved with its manageability. While it was awkward keeping the length of it steady, it wasn’t physically taxing. She attributed that good fortune to Dreamland magic. Taking a deep breath, she looked across the way just as Ruber led Cheshire’s mount to their starting point.

She gasped at the sight of the terrifying creature; it had a long, eel-like body with an oversized head that harbored sharp teeth lining its exaggerated, protruding lower jaw. Its deep black body patterned with deep red stripes along the top; starting from the head and leading to its blood red tail. Its haunting visage, coupled with its hollow eyes and eerie swaying motion, sent a shiver up Lilith’s spine.

Walrus, noticing the slight horror plastered on her face, enlightened her. “That there is the Red Queen’s prized mount, the dreaded Red-Tailed Dragonfish. Don’t let its current resting phase fool you; it’s faster than you might expect.”

Lilith bit the inside of her lip as she looked at Mad Dotter, who seemed undeterred by the nightmarish fish across the way.

Cheshire strode up to the Dragonfish and effortlessly hoisted himself onto the saddle. Then he held his hand out, waiting for Ruber to place a blood-red lance into it. Lance in hand, Cheshire smirked and nodded to Lilith, signalling he was prepared to begin. There was little ceremony involved—no announcements, no fanfare; just two contestants awaiting the first move. The murmurs of the crowd hushed, and the remaining White Queen’s brigade held their breath as Cheshire and Lilith stared each other down from opposite ends of the arena. Cheshire oozed with confidence as he sat perfectly poised upon his deep-sea monstrosity, and Lilith, who was willing with every fiber of her being to stay atop Mad Dotter.

Eager to display his beautiful prowess, Mad Dotter dashed forward, catching Lilith off guard, forcibly thrusting her into the first match. Her legs tightened against his sides as she regained a semblance of balance. Cheshire’s head rolled back in glee as he spurred his mount into a powerful surge forward, easily locking into position as Lilith was still trying to aim her bobbing lance. As quickly as it began, it ended. Lilith flew backward through the air and landed on the dirt with a loud THUD. The wind had been knocked out of her, and she grabbed at her chest as she wheezed and coughed. Dazed, she began looking around with blurry vision, but couldn’t focus on any shape until she heard someone in the distance distinctly say, “Unseating challenger, five hearts, shattering lance, four hearts. The Red Queen scores nine hearts.”

As the crowd roared, Lilith’s sight focused to see a nine of hearts card take position on the Red Queen’s scoreboard. Swallowing hard, she rolled over, still regaining her faculties. What…happened? Was the only thought she could muster; her head felt as if a brass gong reverberated between her ears. She remembered the gruesome Dragonfish slithering at full speed, like a red streak, and Cheshire’s grinning face as he closed in, but after that it quickly went black. She could only recall a loud crack and getting winded. Bringing her hand to her temple, she finally, fully registered that she’d been knocked to the ground. Panicking, she reached for her helmet and was relieved to feel it still on her head.

Mad Dotter brushed up against her side, urging her to get up and continue. Shakily she stood, using him to steady her ascent, and couldn’t help but feel slightly distressed over her once pure white suit now covered in a thick layer of red dust and dirt. It looked as though she had been wounded, and although her chest was still in much pain from Cheshire’s lance, she remained intact. With a few more deep breaths, she steeled herself once again and mounted Mad Dotter and waited at the starting point.

The two challengers said nothing to each other, but Lilith could imagine what types of things he was thinking based on the perverse smile etched across his smug face. He thinks nothing of my abilities…she rubbed at her breastplate, as though it could penetrate through and massage her aching flesh. This is good, right? She held her red-splashed hand out in front of her and was surprised to see it wasn’t shaking in the slightest. All the anxiety, the nervousness, the fear had been knocked away. She had failed the first round, and that brought an eerie calm. She had taken a heavy blow, and while it stung, she knew she could take another. Once Cheshire’s second lance broke, they would be pitted against each other with swords and daggers. That was a scenario she had more faith in; at least she could depend on her own two feet. As long as her helmet remained attached to her head, she had a chance. Her mind cleared. I have to make him mad enough to want to crush his second lance upon me.

Lilith cleared her throat, then yelled out, “Cheshire!” The stadium fell silent as they awaited her next words. Resolutely she continued, “You may cover me in red, but I am still me.”

A chill of excitement ran up Cheshire’s spine; she was truly an opponent worth breaking. His low chortles spilled, and, unable to contain his glee, he shook with a hearty, unnerving guffaw. Only after his laughter subsided did he reach his hand for Ruber to place another lance in his palm.

Walrus waddled up to Mad Dotter, holding another lance out to her. While she hadn’t broken the first one, it was customary to switch between matches. Lilith carefully grabbed onto the wooden base, and winced as the weight fell on her.

Walrus cocked his head, “Will you be okay to ride?”

Still in pain from the first blow, Lilith nodded. She had no choice but to continue. Using her knee to steady the lance, she patted Mad Dotter’s side. “No matter what happens, thank you so much for being my mount, Mad Dotter.” He flared his fins and gills, ready for the next charge. Knowing that holding back wouldn’t make a difference, Lilith gave the word, “Let’s go!” Mad Dotter charged forward full throttle, his beautiful flowing fins swimming fiercely down his lane. And again, Cheshire’s dragonfish shot like an arrow, speeding at incredible force. Still a little dazed from her last hit, Lilith perceived things moving in slower motion, and this time she saw the match from beginning to end. Keeping her eyes open, constantly attempting to steady her lance, she witnessed the satisfied look in Cheshire’s eye as he expertly aimed his lance at her chest.

Even if she had wanted to, she would have been unable to evade the strike. KWOOOOSH Cheshire’s lance shattered against her as her own lance fell to the ground. The pain somehow hurt less as her body was forced back, but to everyone’s surprise, even Lilith’s herself, she remained in her saddle. Mad Dotter swam back to Walrus, who helped Lilith down from the saddle. The announcer called out, “Lance shattered, four hearts go to the Red Queen.” A four of hearts card stood by the other cards to tally up the points so far.

Lilith sighed at her scoreboard, but tried not to let it affect her. She knew it was going to be an uphill battle.

“Hurts like the dickens, eh Girly?”

Lilith was startled by Walrus’s sudden comment, but simply nodded as she sat in a chair designated just for her. She breathed in and out steadily, trying to nurse the pain through stretching. Walrus stood beside her as the combat arena warped and changed before them.

“Looks like you’ll be on foot for your final ‘bout.”

Lilith nodded in compliance. Her lack of anxiety was curious, but he continued.

“You’ll be fighting with a sword now, though perhaps you knew already?” The way he spoke sounded as if he suspected her motives, and she merely cocked a brow in response. Walrus chuckled, “None of my business, that’s fer’sure.” He waddled away to retrieve a proper sword for her to use, and Lilith breathed out slowly. She didn’t trust Walrus—she didn’t trust anyone who wasn’t a friend to Alise.

The new arena finished forming; it differed completely from the jousting setup, which was a long track separated in the middle for the opposition to ride on either side of the divider. This was much simpler; it was a generously large, round ring, situated a few feet above the ground level. Lilith noted the raised ring was covered in the same red dirt.

Once the area was complete, Cheshire wasted no time in entering the fresh space. He silently stood triumphantly, like a grand statue of a war hero, only with a devious grin across his face. The announcer’s voice boomed over the area. “The rules are: landing hits results in points, but the match will not be over until either an opponent yields, or lands out of the ring.”

Lilith’s eyes narrowed, zeroing in on Cheshire. She was positive he had created those rules just for her. She would never get him to yield, and what better way to defeat your enemy than to have them yield?

Walrus waddled to her side, carrying several swords. “These would match your size.”

Lilith did not know how to choose a sword, but she held a few in her hand and settled on one that felt the most manageable. “And a dagger?”

Walrus’s brow cocked. “You want a dagger too?”

She nodded, “Just in case…”

Walrus nodded and turned to fetch some.

Lilith loosened her body with a sword in hand. Like the lance, it wasn’t as heavy as she had expected. Though her chest still throbbed and she winced with certain movements. I can’t think about the pain…I can’t let it affect me. She rubbed at her armor unconsciously. Walrus soon returned and held out a small selection of daggers, and after holding one or two in her hand, she chose one . Sheathing the dagger at her side, she gripped the sword’s handle and stood, walking to the ring. She checked her helmet and quickly glanced at Sir Albus, who was the only other in the know. Climbing the stairs, she walked onto the arena’s platform and faced Cheshire.

This was it. The finale. Lilith took a deep breath as Cheshire smugly smirked. Keep her helmet on, don’t get hit, don’t get knocked off the platform, and never yield. She ran through the checklist in her mind.

“Are you ready, Little Lilith?” Cheshire cooed.

Lilith placed both hands on her sword, gripping tightly. Carefully watching him, she nodded. No sooner had she nodded than Cheshire sprinted toward her. He’s fast! She inhaled sharply as she jumped away from him before he had gotten too close. She thought she could maintain distance between them until she could find an opening, but things were happening faster than she expected.

Relentlessly Cheshire trailed her until Lilith realized she was getting dangerously close to the edge. If she didn’t hold her ground now, it might be all for naught. Clenching her sword, Lilith prepared for Cheshire’s strike, and one solid hit sent her blade veering to the side. So strong…Lilith kept hold of her blade and put all her strength into holding her ground.

“Ohhoho, how adooorable, the doll is playing the knight.”

Lilith’s brow furrowed. Even though she understood Cheshire was purposefully trying to get under her skin, she still didn’t enjoy being called a “doll”.

She shifted her weight and slid away unharmed. Readying her blade once more, she stepped away from the edge of the arena toward the center. Amused at her attempts to keep away from him, he quickly lurched forward, “The more you run, the longer you draw out the inevitable.”

His sword CLANGED against hers, but instead of stopping there, he swiped it to the side and slashed at her again, too quickly for her to dodge or deflect. His sword slashed at the heart of her breastplate. He had gotten yet another point on her. It was just salt in the wound, and Lilith readied herself again. One after one Cheshire hacked and slashed, assaulting Lilith with a barrage of attacks that scuffed and scarred her pink armor. The multiple gashes clustering together, filling with red dirt, made her armor look bloodied. Paying it no mind, she tried to deflect or parry at least one attack, but no matter how hard she tried, she could land no hit. Finally Cheshire knocked the sword from her hand and sent it flying feet away.

Undeterred, Lilith unsheathed her dagger, which brought a new chuckle to Cheshire’s lips. If I could grab hold of him, maybe I can push him off the side…or…if I’m very smart about this, I might trap him. She was close to the edge; Cheshire’s flurry of attacks had nudged her backward. However, if she could go around him, she might get him close enough. He could see the cogs of her mind working and calculated where her plan might flow. Rushing around him and closing in, Lilith lunged with her dagger at the ready. Acting as if she were about to slash him, she waited for him to lift his sword to block, but she locked her arm with his and used her momentum to drive him backward. Having lost his balance, Cheshire nearly toppled over, but having expected her to attempt a maneuver, he could bounce back and hold his ground before she could see him to the edge.

“Tsk, tsk, you’ll have to do better than that, Little Lilith.” He smacked the dagger away. “It’s time to end this.” With that, Cheshire knocked her off balance, and with a swift, lunging uppercut sent Lilith toppling to the ground. CLANG, CLINK, CLUCK. Lilith looked to the sound’s origin to see her own helmet rolling in the dirt. Her hand instinctively reached up, in case it had been a trick, but she felt her soft hair instead of the hard metal helm. Her shoulders fell, almost resigned to defeat.

Cheshire hovered over her, gloating with his entire being, “Do you think I didn’t know what your scheme was? It was a noble attempt, no doubt something plotted by your rabbit friend, but in the end, this was the best you could do.” He leaned into her, whispering, “After all, you’re merely a frightened little puppet. Your very existence is meant to be used and controlled, so what can you expect to do on your own? Did you truly believe you could become your own master?” He rose and placed the tip of his sword at her neck, “Yield to me.”

Lilith’s eyes shut tightly; there was some truth to what he said, things that she had run from all her life. Her brow furrowed as she looked up at him. “You’re right about one thing: I’m scared of being what I am…like it diminishes me…but…but you overlooked something crucial.”

Cheshire’s brow rose as his head cocked to the side, wondering what she was referring to, but before she said another word, he felt his body constrict with surprising force.

“Tsk,” he hissed as Lilith’s magical strings wrapped around him; however, his reaction was too quick, and he wriggled out of her string’s grasp. “I see; I did overlook those.”

Undeterred, Lilith rose to her feet, swinging her wooden control at her side like a lasso. “I may hate being a puppet, but I’m still magical, and whether I like it or not, through this magic my weakness can become strength.” Throwing her cross at him sent it careening through the air, and just as he evaded impact, the power emanating from the control zeroed in on him, chasing after him as he dodged to and fro. Lilith held fast to her strings, whipping them around her like heavy, long ropes, driving Cheshire to the edges of the arena. Biting her lip in concentration, she thrashed and flicked her strings to match his movements, but he outmaneuvered her attempts to catch him at every turn.

Though he seemed to be on the run at first, he slowly gained the upper hand. His cat-like reflexes, coupled with an uncanny ability to sense magical auras, enabled him to eventually predict her intended movements. Until finally Lilith’s strings had become so long and overextended they began knotting and interfering with each other. Still, Lilith used all her might to force the strings to follow her command, but in the end, they had literally tied themselves into a stalemate. Utterly exhausted and unable to untangle the long strings, she looked around and, seeing her fallen sword only a few steps away, lunged for it. Cheshire blocked her path, resting the blade of his sword on her shoulder.

Breathing heavily, he wiped his brow, musing, “You actually made me sweat. Brava.” Still witnessing defiance in her eyes, he smirked, “Yes, this is how I will remember you once you’ve broken.” Aiming for total defeat, he lifted his sword for a final blow, bearing it down upon her, but in her last-ditch effort, Lilith grabbed onto her string and held it between her and Cheshire. His blade swooped down with all his might, and as the blade hit the glowing, magical strings, the sword itself sliced into two pieces. Caught off guard, Lilith activated her trap, snagging his feet in a noose hidden underneath the dirt.

“There’s something you don’t know about my strings.” She said, hoping to distract him, “They can’t be cut; in fact, theycut.” She whipped and twirled her strings about, untangling them all at once. “And I only know this because I’ve tried to cut them off with every sharp thing under the sun.” It was working; he was flustered. Lilith willed the last of her trap into action as her string wrapped around the dagger she had dropped in the distance. With a quick jerk, the dagger flew at Cheshire’s back, and if not for Lilith’s intense focus, it might have hit. Unable to evade, Cheshire contorted his body to knock the dagger off course at the last moment. Then he staggered back into balance, turning around toward Lilith. His eyes widened, and his smirk became a creepy grin, the look on her face as she barreled toward him; solemn, serene, single-minded. She swiped her sword down across his shiny red breastplate, scratching it from shoulder to stomach. She panted as she uttered a single word, “Point.”

The sword fell from Cheshire’s hand as Lilith’s magic waned, and the enchanted aura of her strings diminished. He teetered backward in disbelief. She had scored a point on him, and it had been well deserved. While he was loath to let her go, he was bound by contract. For a moment he cracked and lashed out in frustration, “Yes…yes…I suppose I overlooked something important. However, do not think you have won against me, Little, Lilith. I do not lose against you, but the magic within you. And that magic, while you use it freely, is not yours.” His mind reeled into his own train of thought, “Defeated by a doll who has yet to realize what she even is. Disappointing…” His voice contorted into a deep grumbling, menacing. “The one who made you is powerful indeed, quite the peer. I was happy to steal away his toy, but it appears his magic prevailed…. This time.”

Lilith remained silent as Cheshire spewed harsh words, words that may have been true. Lilith didn’t remember where she was from or who created her, or even for what purpose. But at this moment, none of that mattered. She looked toward Sir Albus and the Fiddles, “Release them now.”

Growling under his breath, Cheshire slid his hand down his armor; the gash was undeniable. “Very well,” he snapped as he waved his hand through the air. With that small flourish, the binds and cages dissipated, and Sir Albus and the Fiddles embraced each other tightly. They then rushed towards Lilith, but Cheshire, unable to bear a happy ending for them, sliced his hand through the air, creating an instantaneous chasm separating Lilith from them.

“Congratulations, Lilith, your friends are freed. You have saved them from an eternity of loneliness, but they are still under my reign.” It seemed he had recovered his composure as his armor transformed into yet another grand spectacle fitting of the Red Queen. “Now that their safety is secured, what about you? You scored a point, yes, but you must now find where Alise slumbers.”

Lilith was confident in her deduction, so she stood as straight as possible, but looked to her friends first. The Fiddle brothers and Mad Dotter weren’t privy to the details of their current circumstance, but Sir Albus knew almost everything. Visibly worried about her upcoming conjecture, he gazed at her, and she at him; only after she nodded in assurance did he allow himself to breathe. Her sights fell on Cheshire again. “Very well, you've won the match, meaning my perimeter has been set in stone,” inspecting Cheshire’s reaction, she began closing the gap between them. “I know where Alise is.”

“OHhohoho, dooo you?” He chortled, bemused. “Be careful, Little Lilith, you have one chance. Get it right and you’re free, get it wrong and you’re mine.”

Lilith walked right up to Cheshire and leaned in, whispering into his ear as she pointed at him. “She’s here.”

Cheshire mockingly pointed at himself in a flamboyant manner. “I beg your finest pardon?”

Lilith grabbed Cheshire’s hand and forcefully removed his glove, facing his fingernails towards him. She was already confident about what he was looking at. “Your appearance is perfect, your hair, your gowns, almost everything; your vanity betrays you. Why not also create perfectly manicured fingernails? Why would you have sloppy, imperfect nails that don’t even match in color?” Cheshire’s expression began growing dark as he ripped his hand away from her, but she relentlessly continued. “It’s because you have to, isn’t it? You aren’t a perfect, opposite doppelgänger of Alise’s, you areAlise…or rather, you share one body.” Lilith pointed to Cheshire’s eye patch, “Alise wears her patch on the opposite eye, and I’ll bet my freedom that if I switch that patch to the other eye, I’ll have my friend back!”

Sir Albus and the Fiddles nearly fainted at Lilith’s deduction, and the entire audience, who had been quietly listening, gasped and rioted. Cheshire grimaced, and the world turned topsy-turvy to match his mood. As the colosseum dismantled into the air, the distant wails from the attendees filled the space as they too were sucked into oblivion. The ground crumbled around them, and Dee clumsily fell into a growing chasm, but Dumb held fast to him, keeping him from falling.

“No!” Lilith realized she could do nothing to help them as they all tried desperately to stay on solid ground, “Stop, don’t harm them, you gave your word!” Cheshire’s grin had become dangerous, as though there was no playfulness behind it. She backed away from him, but still managed, “We have a contract!”

A large burst of purple aura boomed outward from Alise’s body, forming a large cat shadow. The shadow had a sharp, vicious grin, and as it spoke, so did Alise. “Spend no more energy worrying about them; they will continue as they have been. You, however, have a choice to make.”

Lilith couldn’t help but look to her friends as they fell into the darkness, out of view. “You must keep your word.”

Cheshire smiled wickedly, paying little attention to her current plea. “He’s after you…”

Lilith’s face contorted, but he continued before she responded.

“The faceless man, the shadow that haunts your mind…I sense his presence.”

Her brow furrowed in anger, she would not let him bully her; she’d had enough. “Be quiet!” She yelled, “You’re just using my fears against me, trying to keep me here until Alise wakes up. I won’t fall for it, you know nothing!”

The space around them rumbled every time Cheshire let out a low gurgling cackle.

“Fu fu fu fu fu fu fu, I know nothing?” His smile took up the sky, endless, impossibly large. “I know more than you think.” As his mouth spoke, the sky opened up into a stygian abyss. “The man you run from is not a man at all, and he will not rest until he has you.”

Lilith tried to stand firm, but his words sliced through her; she felt they were true.

“I could protect you from him, for a time.” The enormous mouth in the sky swallowed her up, and she fell into the darkness, unable to tell up from down. “As long as you are in Dreamland, he cannot reach you.”

There was no hesitation in her resolve. “I’ll take my chances. At least in the real world, I have control.”

His laughter boomed louder, and she could feel her own body vibrate. “Control? Controoooooooollll? Control is an illusion. If you believe you have control, then you have much to learn.”

“Show me out, you promised. You gave your word.”

“...yes, I did…” Cheshire fell silent for a moment, then added, “Play with me again, some other time, Lilith.” After his last goodbye, the thunderous sound of his finger’s SNAP shook the darkness that enveloped her.

Lilith woke up flailing her arms in the air and, realizing she recognized her room, stopped altogether. Sitting up, she felt her chest; it wasn’t in pain. Then she looked at her hands; they were clean. She was safe in her own bed, wearing her own nightgown, and on the table beside her bed was the very tea that had put her in such a state. But was this truly real, or was she still in Dreamland? Throwing off her covers, she ran out her door barefoot, haphazardly grabbing her control. Down the hall she barreled, half expecting Cheshire to pop into view at any moment. Breathing hard, she stopped at Alise’s room, opened the door, and quietly slipped in. Rushing to Alise’s sleeping self, Lilith shook and shook until she got a response.

“Alise, Alise, wake up.” Lilith begged.

Dazed and groggy, Alise’s eye fluttered open. “Lilith? What time is it? Are you okay?”

Lilith brought her own face closer to Alise’s so she could check which eye was ‘open’. Noticing her right eye was covered, she sighed in relief. Releasing all her tension, Lilith replied, “No…I mean, yes. It’s you, right?”

Still groggy, Alise inquired. “Did you have another nightmare? The tea didn’t work?”

Lilith awkwardly chuckled. “I-it did.”

Alise moved to the far side of her bed. “If you’re scared, you can sleep here.” Alise lifted the covers, inviting Lilith into the warmth of her bed. Lilith, not sure if that would actually help, stood silently as she contemplated what to do.

“Um, okay.”

She climbed into Alise’s bed and pulled the covers over her nose. Alise settled quickly and fell back into a sound sleep, but Lilith, unable to shake the pit in her stomach, turned to watch Alise slumber. Unable to decide if her dream had even been real, Lilith slowly began nodding off, and just as she was about to fall asleep, a familiar playful voice teased.

“You’re a brave one, aren’t you?”

Her eyes opened quickly to Cheshire’s glowing, smiling eye glaring back at her, but before she could respond, everything went black. Lilith jarred awake. The sun streamed in through the curtains, and she realized she wasn’t in her own room. Her brow furrowed in confusion as she rose from the bed to see Alise brushing her hair at her vanity.

“Finally awake, Lil?” Alise used the reflection in the mirror to see Lilith rise.

Lilith sat stunned, as if something was amiss, but no matter how hard she thought, she couldn’t put her finger on it.

Noticing Lilith’s utter confusion, Alise turned to her in concern, “Are you feeling alright?”

Lilith was at a loss; she really couldn’t remember anything after she fell asleep in her bed. “How did I get here?”

Alise laughed, “You must have sleepwalked! I remember you waking me up in the middle of the night and climbing into my bed after, so you must have slept pretty well.” She turned back to her vanity to put her hair in pigtails. “I guess the tea worked after all.”

Lilith smiled, “I guess so, it’s been so long since I’ve felt so refreshed!” She took a full breath and let it out as she stretched her limbs outward. Excitedly, she hopped out of Alise’s bed and forced Alise to scooch over so they could manage their hair together. As Lilith let her hair down, she caught her reflection and stopped for a moment. Alise, noticing her expression, raised a brow.

“Are you sure you’re alright?”

Lilith stared at herself harder, and then smiled. “Yeah, I really am. For some reason, I feel…stronger.” She turned to Alise, “I feel like I’m more confident somehow. Is that weird?”

Alise laughed, “See what a good night’s sleep can do?”

Lilith turned back to her own reflection. “Yeah, you’re right. I’m going to drink it every night!”