Chapter 3:

Welcome to the Bear Cave

Our Ordinary College Days Aren’t Ordinary


A lot can change in a week.

Seven days ago, Mishka and I had been two freshmen wandering around campus because one of us couldn’t read a map.

“The map rotated.”

I looked up from where I was standing in the middle of our living room.

Mishka stood on the other side of the room with his arms crossed.

“What?”

“You were thinking about the map,” he said.

I stared at him. “How could you possibly know that?”

“Your face.”

“My face doesn’t have a map expression.”

“It does.”

“Screw you.”

“Love you too.”

I shook my head and looked around our apartment.

To our credit, we’d made progress.

Most of the boxes were gone.

Not unpacked, necessarily. But gone.

Some had migrated into our bedrooms. Others had been shoved into closets. At least one was sitting behind the couch because neither of us remembered what was inside it, and neither of us felt like finding out.

But the living room?

Progress.

We had chairs now.

Folding chairs, but chairs.

Our television was no longer sitting on the floor, either.

It was sitting on a folding table.

Again.

Progress.

Then there was the couch, our one legitimate piece of living-room furniture. It wasn’t particularly big. Mishka and I could sit on it together as long as neither of us valued personal space.

Five people?

Not happening.

I stared at the room for another few seconds.

“We’re screwed.”

Mishka glanced around. “Why?”

I pointed at everything.

“Look at this.”

“I am.”

“Three girls are coming here tonight.”

“Correct.”

“They’re going to think we’re idiots.”

Mishka stared at me.

“They already know we’re idiots.”

I paused.

“That’s actually a good point.”

“Thank you.”

“But they don’t know we’re this kind of idiots.”

“What kind?”

I pointed toward the television.

Mishka followed my finger. “What?”

“That’s a folding table.”

“Yes.”

“Our television is sitting on a folding table.”

“Also yes.”

“Their television has an actual stand.”

Mishka shrugged. “Ours has a stand.”

I slowly turned toward him.

“That’s a folding table.”

“And the television is standing on it.”

I stared at him.

Mishka stared back.

“You’re the reason I’m worried.”

He smiled. “You worry too much.”

“I just don’t want them walking in here and thinking we don’t have our crap together.”

“We don’t.”

“They don’t need to know that.”

“Grizzly, they watched us get lost on the first day.”

“That was you.”

“They watched us get lost.”

“Because of you.”

“History remembers the group.”

I sighed.

Mishka was impossible.

I looked around again.

“Their apartment has decorations.”

“So?”

“They have pictures.”

“We have pictures.”

I frowned. “Where?”

Mishka pointed toward the refrigerator.

I followed his finger.

A pizza coupon was held to the door with a magnet.

There was, technically, a picture of pizza on it.

I slowly turned back toward him.

“That’s a coupon.”

“There’s a picture.”

“That isn’t decoration.”

“Subjective.”

“We need something.”

“Like what?”

I thought about it.

“Plants?”

Mishka frowned. “Plants?”

“Adults have plants.”

“Why?”

I shrugged. “I don’t know. They just do.”

“Can you keep a plant alive?”

“No.”

“Can I?”

I considered the frying-pan incident from last week.

“No.”

“Then we’re not getting a plant.”

“Fine.”

I thought again.

“Candles?”

Mishka stared at me. “You want to light candles before three girls come over?”

I pictured it.

“No.”

“Good.”

“That would look weird.”

“Very.”

“Throw pillows?”

“We barely have a couch.”

“We need something!”

“We have folding chairs.”

“STOP SAYING THAT LIKE IT’S AN ACCOMPLISHMENT!”

Mishka started laughing.

I looked at the couch, then the folding chairs, then the couch again.

“Wait.”

Mishka’s laughter faded. “What?”

“Where’s everyone sitting?”

He pointed around the room. “Couch. Chairs.”

“That’s four.”

“The couch fits two.”

“That’s still four.”

Mishka counted.

Then stopped.

“Oh.”

“Exactly.”

He looked at the couch.

“Three girls could fit.”

“They’re human beings, not luggage.”

“Good point.”

“We’re hosts. We can’t make them all sit on folding chairs.”

“Why not?”

“Because we’re trying to look like we have our crap together!”

“We’re back to that?”

“Yes!”

Mishka pulled out his phone.

I narrowed my eyes. “What are you doing?”

“Checking how much chairs cost.”

“A real chair?”

“Yes.”

Finally.

Growth.

Mishka stared at his phone for a moment before his expression changed.

“How long until they get here?”

I checked the clock.

“Three hours.”

He put his phone away.

“Folding chairs.”

I nodded.

“Folding chairs.”

Operation: Functional Adults

For the next two hours, we cleaned.

Actually cleaned.

Mishka vacuumed while I cleaned the bathroom because apparently losing one wrestling match meant I was sentenced to bathroom duty for the foreseeable future.

Mishka found that extremely funny.

I didn’t.

We wiped down the kitchen, picked up clothes, took out the trash, and even organized the folding chairs.

Then came the boxes.

Mishka watched me pick one up.

“Where are you taking that?”

“Your room.”

“No.”

I kept walking.

“Grizzly.”

“The girls aren’t going into your room.”

“Put it in yours.”

“Mine’s full.”

Mishka stopped. “Full of what?”

I pushed the box through his doorway.

“Don’t worry about it.”

“Those are your boxes!”

“Thank you for your sacrifice.”

“Grizzly!”

I closed his door.

Problem solved.

Eventually, we stood in the living room admiring our work.

The apartment was clean.

Still poorly furnished.

But clean.

Mishka crossed his arms. “Looks good.”

“Looks adult.”

“Definitely.”

“We’ve got our crap together.”

“Absolutely.”

Creeeeak.

We both looked toward the folding table.

The television hadn’t moved.

The table had simply made a noise.

Neither of us breathed.

Finally, I pointed at it.

“Don’t touch the TV.”

“Wasn’t planning on it.”

A knock came from the door.

We froze.

Another knock followed.

Then Avery’s voice came through the door.

“Are you two alive?”

“Maybe the TV fell on them,” Sophie added.

Elena responded immediately. “Why would the TV fall on them?”

“Have you seen what it’s sitting on?”

I slowly looked at Mishka.

“How does she know?”

“You told them.”

“Oh.”

“Idiot.”

“Screw you.”

I opened the door.

Avery stood in front with a backpack hanging from one shoulder, her light-brown hair partially pulled up like usual. Sophie stood behind her, her silver wolf cut framing her face, and Elena waited beside her with long black hair falling neatly past her shoulders.

Avery stepped inside.

Then stopped.

Sophie came in behind her, followed by Elena.

Silence.

Mishka and I waited.

Avery’s eyes traveled across the room.

The folding chairs.

The couch.

The television.

Finally, she looked at us.

“Wow.”

Mishka immediately frowned. “Why did you say it like that?”

Avery blinked innocently. “Like what?”

“Like you expected worse.”

She looked around again.

“I did.”

“Screw you.”

Sophie pointed toward the television.

“The TV’s off the floor!”

I closed my eyes.

“Can everyone please stop talking about our television?”

Elena looked around the apartment. “You cleaned.”

“No,” Mishka said.

“Yes,” I said at the exact same time.

Mishka turned toward me.

“Why would you admit that?”

“Because we did.”

Avery grinned. “You cleaned for us?”

“We clean all the time,” Mishka said.

Elena looked at the folding chairs.

Then the folding table.

Then Mishka.

“Of course.”

I frowned. “Why did that sound sarcastic?”

“Because it was.”

Sophie dropped her backpack onto the floor and sat down beside it.

I stared at her.

“You’re sitting on the floor.”

“Yep.”

“We have chairs.”

Sophie glanced at the folding chairs, then back at me.

“I’m good.”

Mishka immediately pointed at her.

“SEE?!”

“That doesn’t help our case!”

Avery laughed while Elena grabbed one of the folding chairs and sat down.

“You two worried way too much about this,” Elena said.

Mishka looked at me.

I looked at him.

Neither of us said anything.

We absolutely had.

Study Night

Somehow, everyone found a place.

Elena took one folding chair. Mishka took the other. Avery claimed one side of the couch, and I took the other.

Sophie remained on the floor despite multiple objections.

Books came out.

Laptops opened.

Notebooks appeared.

And for the first twenty minutes, nothing happened.

By nothing, I mean something incredible happened.

We studied.

Actually studied.

Nobody yelled. Nobody argued. Nobody threw anything.

Sophie hadn’t mentioned bears once.

Mishka hadn’t blamed the university for anything.

Avery wasn’t distracting anybody.

Elena wasn’t threatening us.

I looked around the room.

Maybe we really were becoming adults.

“This is impossible.”

I looked over.

Mishka was staring at his laptop.

Never mind.

Elena glanced toward him. “What?”

Mishka turned the laptop around.

“Explain something to me.”

“What?”

“When did numbers get letters?”

Silence.

Elena blinked. “Algebra?”

“Terrible decision.”

“Mishka.”

“Numbers worked perfectly fine. One. Two. Three. Then somebody decided we needed x.”

Sophie looked up from the floor.

“Don’t forget y.”

Mishka pointed at her. “Exactly! Now there’s two of them!”

I nodded.

“He’s got a point.”

Elena looked between us.

“No, he doesn’t.”

Mishka stared at the problem again. “This makes no sense.”

Elena stood and walked over to him.

“Move.”

“Where?”

“Over.”

Mishka shifted his chair enough for Elena to crouch beside him and look over his work.

After a minute, she frowned.

“You’re memorizing the steps.”

“That’s how learning works.”

“No. You’re trying to remember what the professor did instead of understanding why he did it.”

Mishka looked offended.

“I understood.”

Elena pointed to one of the steps. “Why did he do this?”

Silence.

“Exactly.”

She took his pencil and started explaining the problem differently.

Slowly.

One piece at a time.

Mishka listened.

Actually listened.

Eventually, his expression changed.

“Wait.”

Elena stopped.

Mishka looked at the page.

Then at Elena.

Then back at the page.

“That’s it?”

“That’s it.”

“Why didn’t the professor say it like that?”

“He did.”

Mishka’s excitement disappeared.

“You were doing so well.”

A few minutes later, Sophie groaned and lowered her forehead onto her notebook.

“I’m dropping out.”

Avery looked over from the couch.

“It’s been a week.”

“Good. Less paperwork.”

“You’re not dropping out.”

“Tell my family I tried.”

“You’re sitting three feet away.”

“Tell them anyway.”

Avery got off the couch and sat beside her.

“What are you stuck on?”

“Everything.”

“Helpful.”

Sophie lifted her head and showed Avery a notebook filled with terms she needed to remember.

“I understand it when I’m reading it,” Sophie explained. “Then I close the book and my brain decides none of it ever happened.”

“Okay. Give me the list.”

Sophie handed it over.

Avery looked through the terms before she started rearranging them.

Sophie leaned closer. “What are you doing?”

“Making it easier.”

“How?”

Avery glanced at her. “Your brain likes weird stuff.”

“That sounded insulting.”

“It was affectionate.”

Avery took the first letters from several terms and wrote a completely ridiculous sentence beneath them.

Sophie stared at it.

Mishka leaned over from his chair.

“What does that have to do with anything?”

“Nothing,” Avery said.

Sophie continued staring.

Then her eyes widened.

“Oh.”

Avery smiled. “There it is.”

Sophie repeated the ridiculous sentence.

Then the terms.

Again.

Then again.

She looked up.

“I remember them.”

Mishka stared at her. “That shouldn’t work.”

Avery shrugged. “Doesn’t matter.”

Sophie pointed at Avery.

“You’re a genius.”

“I know.”

Mishka looked over.

“Wait.”

Avery turned toward him. “What?”

“You’re smart?”

Silence.

The room stopped.

Avery slowly stood.

Mishka’s eyes widened.

“That came out wrong.”

“Say it again.”

“I didn’t mean—”

“SAY IT AGAIN, LITTLE BEAR.”

Mishka started backing away.

“Grizzly.”

I returned my attention to my notebook.

“No.”

“We’re brothers!”

“Not anymore.”

Avery chased him around the couch while Sophie started laughing.

Elena rubbed her forehead.

Eventually, Avery returned to her seat.

Mishka remained on the opposite side of the room.

Smart choice.

Unfortunately, I wasn’t doing much better.

I wasn’t confused.

That would’ve been easier.

My problem was that I understood everything and still felt like I didn’t understand it enough.

Eventually, Elena noticed my notebook.

She turned one page.

Then another.

“Grizzly.”

I looked up. “What?”

“Why did you make a diagram?”

“It helps.”

“This is a vocabulary term.”

“Exactly.”

Elena pointed at the page. “You have arrows.”

“The arrows establish relationships.”

“There are boxes.”

“Categories.”

“You color-coded it.”

“Priority.”

Elena stared at me.

I stared back.

“You could’ve written the definition,” she said.

“That feels irresponsible.”

Avery leaned over from beside us.

“You’ve spent fifteen minutes learning something that should’ve taken thirty seconds.”

“But I’ll never forget it.”

“That isn’t the point.”

“Sounds like something someone without a diagram would say.”

From across the room, Mishka pointed at me.

“Thank you!”

Elena looked toward him.

“You’re not helping.”

“I’m supporting my brother.”

“You abandoned me five minutes ago,” I reminded him.

“You abandoned me first.”

“Because you insulted Avery.”

“That was an accident!”

Avery looked up.

“I haven’t forgotten.”

Mishka immediately returned to his math.

Eventually, he started tapping his pencil against the desk.

Tap.

Tap-tap.

Tap.

Elena looked over.

“What are you doing?”

“Studying.”

“You’re making a beat.”

“Exactly.”

Then Mishka started singing.

I kept working.

I’d seen this before.

Elena had not.

She slowly looked at me.

“Is he okay?”

“Unfortunately.”

Mishka continued, turning the formula into a song.

Not a particularly good song.

But a song.

Sophie started tapping along from the floor.

Then Avery joined her.

Elena looked horrified.

“Stop encouraging him.”

“It’s catchy,” Sophie said.

“It’s terrible.”

Mishka added another line.

Avery joined in.

Elena stared at her.

“Not you too.”

Five minutes later, Elena had returned to helping Mishka.

She stopped at one of the formulas.

Paused.

Then, very quietly, she sang Mishka’s line under her breath.

Everyone froze.

Elena stopped.

Mishka slowly smiled.

“Don’t.”

“You sang it.”

“I did not.”

“You absolutely did.”

“I was remembering the formula.”

“Using my song.”

Elena pointed her pencil at him.

“One more word and I’m breaking that pencil.”

Mishka smiled.

“My art speaks for itself.”

Sophie wasn’t any better.

At some point, she started inventing increasingly ridiculous sentences to remember sequences.

Nobody understood how they helped.

Not even Avery, and she’d started the whole thing.

I looked at one of Sophie’s flash cards.

“What does a penguin renting a motorcycle have to do with your class?”

“Nothing.”

“Then why—”

“I remember it.”

I stopped.

Fair.

By the end of the first hour, the apartment had become an academic circus.

My notes looked like engineering plans.

Mishka had apparently recorded half an album.

Sophie had created sentences that would’ve concerned a psychologist.

And somehow…

It worked.

Mishka was solving problems.

Sophie remembered her terms.

I understood my material.

I looked toward Avery and Elena.

“Huh.”

Avery looked up. “What?”

“This actually worked.”

Elena stared at me.

“That was the point.”

“I know. I just didn’t expect it to.”

“Why?”

I looked around the room.

Sophie was sitting on the floor surrounded by flash cards.

Mishka sat backward on a folding chair, quietly singing to himself.

Avery’s notes covered half the couch.

Our television was still sitting on a folding table.

I looked back at Elena.

“Have you met us?”

She considered that.

“Fair.”

One Week In

Eventually, books started closing.

Not completely.

We were taking a break.

At least, that’s what Elena called it.

Mishka called it freedom.

Avery leaned back against the couch.

“So.”

I looked up. “So?”

“One week.”

“That’s usually how long those take.”

Avery threw a pillow at me.

I caught it.

“You know what I mean.”

Sophie stretched out on the floor.

“First week of college.”

Mishka nodded. “Feels longer.”

Elena looked toward him. “Bad longer?”

He thought about it.

“Different longer.”

That quieted everyone slightly.

For the first time that night, nobody immediately made a joke.

Avery looked toward the ceiling.

“It definitely doesn’t feel like high school.”

“Nope,” I said.

Sophie rolled onto her side. “In high school, somebody always told you where you were supposed to be.”

Elena nodded.

“And when something was due.”

“And when to eat,” Mishka added.

I looked at him.

“You need someone to tell you when to eat?”

“No. But it was convenient.”

Avery laughed.

Sophie looked around at the rest of us.

“Do you guys miss home?”

That question sat there for a second.

“Sometimes,” I admitted.

Mishka nodded. “Same.”

Avery pulled her knees up.

“Me too.”

Elena gave a small smile.

“I think that’s normal.”

“Everything’s just different,” Sophie said.

Nobody disagreed.

Different city.

Different people.

Different classes.

Different responsibilities.

Different homes.

I looked around our barely furnished apartment.

Then at the four people sitting inside it.

“I think we’ve gotten pretty lucky, though.”

Avery looked at me. “How?”

“People.”

Sophie lifted her head.

“People?”

“Yeah.”

I shrugged.

“Moving somewhere new would’ve sucked if Mishka and I didn’t meet you three.”

The room became quiet again.

Avery smiled.

Sophie did too.

Elena looked down at her drink for a moment.

Beside me, Mishka nodded.

“He’s right.”

I turned toward him.

“Did you just agree with me?”

“Don’t ruin it.”

“Sorry.”

Mishka looked toward the girls.

“Seriously. We’re glad we met you guys.”

Avery’s expression softened.

“We’re glad we met you too.”

It was nice.

A genuinely nice moment.

Which meant naturally I ruined it.

“And Claire’s been really cool too.”

Silence.

I didn’t notice immediately.

Mishka nodded. “Yeah. Claire’s awesome.”

The silence somehow became louder.

Sophie slowly sat up.

“Who’s Claire?”

I looked at her.

“Girl from our class.”

Avery’s eyebrows rose.

“Our?”

“Mine and Mishka’s.”

“You have another class together?”

“Yeah.”

Elena looked up from her drink.

“And Claire is…?”

Mishka shrugged.

“Claire.”

Sophie stared at him.

“Helpful.”

“Thanks.”

Avery looked at me.

“So she’s your friend?”

“Yeah.”

“Since when?”

I looked at Mishka.

“Monday?”

“Tuesday,” he said.

“Monday.”

Mishka frowned. “Was it?”

“Yeah.”

“Huh.”

Avery stared at us.

“You don’t even know when you met her.”

“Why would we?”

Something in her expression changed.

I wasn’t sure why.

Sophie crossed her arms.

“What does she look like?”

Mishka frowned. “Why?”

“I’m curious.”

“About what?”

“Her.”

“Why?”

Sophie stared at him.

“Can you stop asking why?”

Mishka tilted his head.

“Why?”

Sophie grabbed the pillow beside her.

“Don’t.”

Elena sighed.

“They’re allowed to have other friends.”

Avery looked at her.

“I know.”

Sophie nodded quickly.

“Obviously.”

“Good.”

Silence.

Then Elena looked at me.

“What’s her major?”

Avery slowly turned toward her.

Elena noticed.

“What?”

Avery smiled.

“Nothing.”

“That’s a normal question.”

“Sure.”

“It is.”

Sophie smiled too.

“Of course.”

Elena frowned.

“Stop looking at me like that.”

Mishka leaned back in his chair.

“She helped us find our classroom Monday.”

Avery’s head snapped toward him.

“Again?”

I frowned. “What?”

“Another girl had to help you find a building?”

“That one was Grizzly,” Mishka said.

I looked at him.

“Screw you.”

“Truth matters.”

Mishka looked back at the girls.

“She brought us coffee yesterday too.”

Silence.

Sophie blinked.

“She brings you coffee?”

“She was already getting one,” Mishka explained.

“For both of you?” Avery asked.

“Yeah.”

Elena looked over.

“What kind?”

Everyone turned toward her.

Elena blinked.

“What? I’m asking what they drink.”

Avery leaned forward.

“Does she sit with you?”

“Sometimes,” I said.

“Sometimes?”

“Yeah.”

“Why?”

I frowned.

“Because we’re friends?”

Avery crossed her arms.

“I just don’t understand why you need another girl friend.”

Silence.

Avery froze.

Her face immediately changed.

“Not—”

She held her hands apart as if she could physically separate the words.

“Not girlfriend. Girl. Friend. Two words.”

Sophie pointed at her.

“You said it weird.”

“I DID NOT.”

Mishka looked completely confused.

“Are we only allowed three?”

“That’s not the point!” Avery said.

“What’s the point?”

Avery opened her mouth.

Nothing came out.

Elena rubbed her forehead.

“We’re being ridiculous.”

Sophie nodded.

“I know.”

Avery frowned.

“I’m not.”

Elena looked at her.

“You just asked why they need another female friend.”

“I didn’t say they weren’t allowed.”

“You heavily implied it.”

“Well…”

Avery looked at Mishka and me.

“We found them first.”

Mishka stared at her.

“Found us?”

Sophie nodded.

“Technically.”

“We’re not stray dogs.”

Avery pointed at him.

“You were lost.”

I immediately started laughing.

Mishka sat forward.

“That was the map.”

“Oh my gosh,” Elena muttered.

“Not this again.”

I wasn’t entirely sure what had just happened.

Apparently, Mishka and I making another friend had violated some unwritten rule nobody had bothered explaining to us.

College friendships were complicated.

I’d need a diagram.

Thankfully, Mishka’s stomach interrupted the conversation before I had to make one.

It growled loudly.

Everyone looked at him.

Sophie blinked.

“Was that you?”

Mishka put a hand over his stomach.

“We’ve been studying for three hours.”

Avery checked the clock.

“It’s nine-thirty?!”

Elena immediately sat straighter.

“We have class tomorrow.”

Sophie dropped backward onto the floor.

“I’m sleeping here.”

“No, you’re not,” Elena said.

“I’ve already decided.”

“You live ten minutes away.”

“That’s far.”

“It isn’t.”

I checked the kitchen.

There wasn’t enough food for five people.

“Pizza?”

Five minutes later, pizza was on the way.

The Bear Cave

The books eventually closed completely.

Pizza boxes replaced them.

Nobody sat where they had started.

Avery was cross-legged on the floor.

Sophie had finally taken a folding chair.

Elena and Mishka were arguing about whether his study song had actually helped.

“It worked,” Mishka insisted.

“It was annoying,” Elena replied.

“Those things aren’t mutually exclusive.”

“I hate that sentence.”

“Because it’s correct.”

I sat on the couch eating another slice.

The apartment was a mess again.

Books.

Backpacks.

Empty cans.

Flash cards.

Pens.

We’d spent hours making the place look presentable.

Now it looked worse than before.

And strangely…

I didn’t care.

Eventually, Elena checked the time.

“We need to go.”

Sophie groaned while Avery stood and started gathering her things.

“Successful first Study Night,” Avery declared.

“We actually got more done than I expected,” Elena admitted.

Mishka leaned back in his chair.

“That’s because of my song.”

Elena stared at him.

“Your song cost us twenty minutes.”

“And you’ll remember it forever.”

Elena opened her mouth.

Then stopped.

Mishka smiled.

“Exactly.”

“I hate that you’re right.”

Sophie grabbed her backpack.

“Same time next week?”

“Your place,” I said.

Avery nodded.

“Definitely. I don’t think the Bear Cave could survive another week.”

Silence.

Mishka slowly looked around.

“The what?”

Avery smiled.

“Bear Cave.”

Sophie immediately nodded.

“Oh, that’s staying.”

“Absolutely not,” I said.

Elena walked toward the door.

“Goodnight, Bears.”

Mishka pointed after her.

“DON’T ENCOURAGE THEM.”

The door closed.

Silence.

Mishka and I looked at each other.

Then at the apartment.

A pizza box sat on the folding table.

Empty cans were scattered around.

Books covered almost every available surface.

One folding chair had somehow ended up beside the kitchen.

Sophie had left a pen on the floor.

Mishka put his hands on his hips.

“Well.”

“Yep.”

“I think we nailed that.”

I looked around again.

“Absolutely nailed it.”

Mishka dropped onto the couch.

“They barely made fun of the furniture.”

“Sophie called our apartment a cave.”

“That’s branding.”

I thought about it.

“Bear Cave does sound pretty good.”

“Thank you.”

“We’re not calling it that.”

“Coward.”

I dropped into the folding chair.

“Study Night actually worked.”

Mishka nodded.

“Elena saved my life.”

“Academically.”

“Same thing.”

I laughed.

“Avery’s smarter than you thought.”

Mishka looked offended.

“I never said she wasn’t smart.”

“You literally asked her, ‘You’re smart?’”

“That came out wrong.”

“Very wrong.”

“Screw you.”

I laughed again.

Mishka leaned back.

“Sophie’s memory thing is insane.”

“Your songs are insane.”

“My songs are art.”

“Your songs are a crime.”

He threw a pillow at me.

I caught it.

For a second, neither of us said anything.

Then I looked around the apartment again.

“That was fun.”

Mishka nodded.

“Yeah.”

“We should keep doing this.”

“Definitely.”

I smiled.

“Think they had fun?”

Mishka shrugged.

“Obviously.”

“Yeah.”

We looked at each other.

“We nailed it,” I said.

Mishka held out his fist.

“Nailed it.”

I bumped it.

Meanwhile…

The girls walked into their apartment.

Shoes came off.

Bags hit the floor.

Avery headed toward the kitchen.

Sophie dropped onto the couch.

Elena started putting her things away.

Nobody spoke.

Five seconds.

Ten.

Then Avery stopped.

“Okay.”

Sophie immediately sat up.

“I know.”

Elena closed her eyes.

“No.”

Avery turned toward her.

“I haven’t said anything.”

“I know what you’re going to say.”

Sophie hugged one of the couch pillows.

“I want to say it too.”

Elena sighed.

“They’re allowed to have other friends.”

Avery crossed her arms.

“I know.”

“Then we’re done.”

“We’re not done.”

“Avery.”

“Why do they need another girl friend?”

Sophie pointed at her.

“Exactly.”

Elena stared at both of them.

“Because people are allowed to have more than three friends who happen to be girls.”

“Obviously,” Avery said.

“Then what’s the problem?”

Silence.

Avery looked at Sophie.

Sophie looked at Avery.

Neither answered.

Finally, Sophie frowned.

“It’s just weird.”

Elena raised an eyebrow.

“Why?”

“Because.”

“Excellent argument.”

“Thank you.”

“That was sarcasm.”

“Still counts.”

Avery dropped onto the couch beside Sophie.

“We’ve been hanging out with them all week.”

“Correct,” Elena said.

“We have Study Night.”

“Correct.”

“We eat lunch together.”

“Also correct.”

Avery threw her hands up.

“So why do they need another one?”

Elena blinked.

“Another what?”

“Girl!”

Sophie nodded.

“They already have three.”

Elena stared at both of them.

“You two sound insane.”

Avery narrowed her eyes.

“You asked what kind of coffee Claire brought them.”

Elena froze.

Sophie slowly looked toward her.

“You did.”

“That was a normal question.”

“Was it?” Avery asked.

“Yes.”

“Why did you care?”

Elena opened her mouth.

Nothing came out.

“I was making conversation.”

Avery smiled.

“Sure.”

“Stop.”

Sophie rested her chin on the pillow.

“I just thought we were their friends.”

Elena’s expression softened.

“We are.”

“I know.”

Avery looked down.

“I don’t know. It was nice being…”

She stopped.

Sophie looked at her.

“Their first friends here?”

Avery looked over.

“Yeah.”

Sophie nodded.

“That’s what I mean.”

Elena sat down beside them.

“They’re not replacing us.”

“I know,” Avery said.

“Obviously,” Sophie added.

Silence.

Then Elena spoke.

“…She does sound really nice, though.”

Avery and Sophie immediately looked at her.

Elena frowned.

“What?”

Avery narrowed her eyes.

“Whose side are you on?”

“There are no sides!”

“That’s exactly what someone on her side would say.”

“I haven’t even met her!”

Sophie thought for a moment.

“What was her name again?”

“Claire,” Elena answered immediately.

Silence.

Avery slowly turned toward her.

Sophie did the same.

Elena froze.

“Oh, shut up.”

As far as Mishka and I were concerned, our first official Study Night had been a complete success.

We got work done.

We learned a few things.

Nobody failed anything.

Nobody broke anything.

And apparently our apartment had a name now.

Not bad.

What Mishka and I didn’t know was that, a few buildings away, three girls were holding what could only be described as an emergency meeting about our social lives.

Maybe it was better that we didn’t know.

We probably wouldn’t have understood it anyway.

After all, we’d only known them for a little over a week.

We were just friends.

And right now?

That was more than enough.

Author: