Chapter 4:

Not Expected

The Halloween Murder Mystery


Bella was just a normal 17-year-old high school student, living her life without much excitement. Her days were filled with school assignments, after-school clubs, and the occasional outing with friends. Halloween was always one of her favorite holidays, a time for candy, costumes, and haunted houses. But this year felt different—darker.
On Halloween night, with a light mist hanging in the air, she decided to take a walk around the city, her thoughts light and carefree, enjoying the festive decorations adorning the houses. Children roamed the streets, laughter echoing in the cool night air, and the scent of caramel apples wafted from a nearby stall. Bella savored the moment, momentarily forgetting her mundane worries.
But as she strolled through the dimly lit streets, admiring the flickering jack-o’-lanterns, her world was abruptly turned upside down. A van pulled up beside her, its darkened windows concealing its occupants. Before she could react, a strong arm grabbed her from behind, yanking her into the van. Everything after that became a blur—her muffled screams, the adrenaline coursing through her veins, the darkness swallowing her whole.
She had no recollection of the time between when she was taken and the moment she woke up in a strange mansion. The air was thick with an unsettling silence, broken only by the distant creaking of old wood. Confused and disoriented, Bella blinked against the dim light.
"Where am I?" Bella asked herself, her voice trembling in the eerie silence. "How did I get here?" Panic began to gnaw at her insides, a dark and creeping feeling she couldn’t shake. But before she could fully process her situation, a voice echoed through the mansion’s speakers, cold and detached, instructing everyone to follow a blood-red path on the floor.
“What the hell?” she muttered, her heart racing as confusion swirled in her mind. Glancing around, she saw most of the group—about 15 out of the 20 people—begin to follow the trail, their faces pale and haunted. Fear clutched at her throat, but the instinct to survive pushed her feet forward, and she hesitantly joined them, each step heavier than the last.
The path led them to a dimly lit bedroom on the first floor. The tension was palpable as they crowded inside, an air of desperation hanging over them. Bella’s heart raced, her senses heightened. Everything felt surreal. Suddenly, a scream pierced the silence as one of the others opened a closet, revealing a dead body stuffed inside.
Her stomach churned violently, and panic surged through her veins. She couldn’t take it anymore. Bella bolted from the room, her mind racing as she sought a place to hide, to escape the madness that was enveloping her. The sounds of chaos followed her, muffled and distant, but the sense of danger was everywhere.
As the chaos quieted down, the voice from the speakers returned, calmly explaining the rules of this twisted game they had been thrown into. Bella barely processed the words, but she understood one thing: they were in danger, and someone among them was a murderer.
With her heart pounding in her chest, Bella stumbled into the kitchen, a desperate need for safety overwhelming her. She grabbed a knife—her only means of defense—its cold steel feeling reassuring in her trembling hands. Then she hurried up to a bedroom on the second floor, seeking refuge. Sitting on the bed, her grip tight around the knife’s handle, she waited, trying to block out the dread creeping into her thoughts. Maybe someone would figure out who the culprit was, and they could all go home. She had to believe that.
But her moment of solitude was shattered when two men burst into the room, their faces wild with panic. They had seen the bodies, heard the voice—they assumed she was the culprit. “What do you want?” she shouted, backing away against the wall.
Without warning, they lunged at her in desperation. Bella acted on instinct, swinging the knife in self-defense. The struggle was chaotic and violent. Panic surged through her as she fought for her life, adrenaline fueling her movements. In the midst of the chaos, she felt the blade connect, the reality of her actions crashing over her like a wave. In the blink of an eye, she had killed both of them.
Her hands trembled as she looked at the bloodstains on her clothes and the lifeless bodies sprawled on the floor. “What have I done?” she whispered, the words choking her. She had just killed two people, and the weight of that reality settled heavily in her chest.Frantic thoughts spiraled through her mind, and she knew she couldn’t just leave the bodies there. Bella dragged them, one by one, through the dimly lit house, hiding them in closets to avoid being caught. The house felt like a maze, shadows shifting and looming, amplifying her fear. Her breathing was shallow, her heart still racing, and the knife felt like a burden in her hand. She was scared, and now, she was a killer.After cleaning herself up as best as she could, she returned to the bedroom where she had hidden earlier, trying to calm down and think clearly. Her thoughts raced like wild horses, memories of her life before this horror flickering in her mind. That’s when Aoi entered the room—a fellow captive with sharp, observant eyes. We know what happened next.

°°°

As I sprinted upstairs toward the source of the scream, my heart pounded in my chest. The mansion’s eerie atmosphere seemed to close in around me, each step echoing in the stillness. Upon reaching the scene, I found Naima crouched beside a dead male body sprawled on the floor, another girl standing behind her, frozen with fear.

“What happened here?” I demanded, my voice sharper than I intended.
Without looking up from the body, Naima replied, “I was searching for people to interrogate when this body suddenly fell out of the closet.” Her tone was calm, analytical, though the situation was anything but. The girl standing behind Naima suddenly collapsed, fainting from the shock.
“Mark, help her,” Naima instructed, still focused on the corpse.
“O-Okay,” I stammered, rushing over to check on the girl. My hands trembled slightly as I tried to bring her back to consciousness, whispering reassuring words that felt hollow in my own ears.
“This isn’t the work of the original culprit,” Naima said, her words cutting through my focus like a knife. I looked up, confused.
“What do you mean?” I asked, trying to grasp the implications of her statement.
Naima pointed at the body, her finger trembling slightly. “He has stab wounds all over. This wasn’t a slow, calculated death. Whoever did this wanted him gone quickly.”
Before I could process her words, the speakers crackled to life again. That sickeningly cheerful voice filled the room, echoing around us with malicious glee.
“We have found another dead body!” the voice chimed. “But that’s not all—there are three more, in addition to this one! Four deaths total. Good luck with the rest of your night!” The voice faded away, leaving an eerie silence in its wake, as if the very walls of the mansion held their breath.
My blood ran cold. Three more bodies? Without thinking, I abandoned the girl I was checking on and bolted down the stairs, my heart racing with fear and desperation. Ango. I had to see if he was okay.
I burst into the bathroom, relief washing over me as I saw him still there, but his demeanor had shifted. This time, he was curled up inside the bathtub, hugging his knees to his chest, an image of sheer vulnerability.
“Thank God you’re okay,” I exhaled, my breath shaky.
Ango suddenly got up and threw his arms around me, his body trembling as tears streamed down his face. “You’re okay!” he sobbed. “I was so scared.”
I hugged him back, my voice soft, trying to soothe the panic in his eyes. “Don’t worry, we’re fine. We’ll get through this.” But just as I was comforting him, a sound from outside the bathroom stopped me cold.
“Shush, be quiet,” I whispered, gently pushing Ango off me.
“No, please don’t—” a voice cried out from the hallway, full of panic and despair.
“Looks like he’s not the culprit either,” came a cold, detached female voice from outside.
“Let’s move on, then,” a male voice responded, their footsteps fading into the distance.
Ango and I stayed perfectly still, listening to their footsteps fade into the distance, our hearts pounding in unison. The tension was thick, a suffocating dread wrapping around us. After a few tense moments, I slowly opened the bathroom door. The sight that greeted me was chilling: another dead body lay on the floor just outside, lifeless and still, a reminder that we were trapped in a nightmare with no escape.
To be continued...