Chapter 51:

Chapter 51: Beautiful Lie

My Romantic Comedy in the Heartbreak Society Is More Complicated Than I Expected — Especially Around Her


I’ve finally come to a realization—the truth was never truly hidden. I was simply too much of a coward to look it in the eye.

It’s ironic, really. For the longest time, I believed that the most agonizing part of love was the act of parting ways. I was wrong. What’s truly insidious is when a lie is wrapped in such exquisite beauty that you find yourself on the verge of believing it to be reality.

The following day, I arrived at the restaurant like any other morning. Donning my apron. Exhaling a heavy sigh. The routine remained stagnant, but my thoughts were in a state of flux. During a brief lull, I sat down and opened a book.

“Indicators of Deception: A Comprehensive Guide.”

Yes, I’m aware of how I look—like a detective profiling a high-stakes criminal—when in reality, I’m just trying to navigate the messy labyrinth of human emotions.

"Junior, what exactly are you studying?"

The voice belonged to Kagari Suzune—the petite head chef with a chaotic mane of red hair and eyes as piercing as a winter chill. She peered over my shoulder.

"Oh, this... just a study on the anatomy of a lie."

"Hmm?" She narrowed her eyes, her gaze sharp enough to slice through bone. "And who, pray tell, is making a fool out of you?"

I closed the book with a soft thud. "I’m not sure. Perhaps I’m just curious."

Or perhaps I already know the answer, but my heart is still negotiating its own surrender.

The kitchen roared to life as the shift began. It was a cacophony of clashing steel, hissing flames, and the rhythmic percussion of pans—an orchestra played at a tempo far too frantic for anyone to actually enjoy. Orders flooded the station without mercy. Kagari orchestrated the chaos with her usual, brutal efficiency.

"Junior! One soup, now!" "Heard!"

My hands operated on autopilot, moving with mechanical precision. But my mind? It was elsewhere entirely. Kurosaki Yuki… Why did every piece of the puzzle fit so perfectly that it felt like an insult?

Ting. The door chime rang.

"Welcome to Kagami Restaurant!"

I looked up. There she was. A woman with ashen-silver hair and eyes the color of stagnant crimson. Kurosaki Yuki. My heart throbbed—a dull, aching alarm that had been ignored for too long and was finally screaming for attention.

She sat down, her presence a study in stillness. Too quiet. Too composed.

"Your order, miss?" the waiter asked. "The Cream Soup and the Kagami Burger Patty, please."

I watched her from the shadows of the kitchen. My movements remained steady, but my focus had shifted entirely to the table in the corner. When the food was delivered, the final confirmation revealed itself.

The way she gripped the spoon. The deliberate double-swirl. The brief pause before the first taste.

My hands froze. No more doubts. "There it is," I whispered to the steam.

She ate with a casual grace, savoring each bite, blissfully unaware—or so it seemed—of the eyes dissecting her every move. "This is delicious..."

I stepped out of the kitchen and approached her.

"Eeh—Kengo-kun? What are you doing here?" She looked startled, a perfect imitation of surprise.

"I work here. And you?" "Oh… I was just hungry. This happens to be my favorite spot."

I stared at her, searching for a crack in the porcelain. "I see. How is the food?" "Wonderful!" She offered a bright, practiced smile. "Did you prepare this?" "I did." "Kengo, you’re incredible. With a talent like this, you could go far in the culinary world."

I shook my head. "I have no desire for that."

She went silent. A normal person would have laughed it off or asked why. But she remained unnervingly calm. Her emotional regulation was too polished, a protective layer of lacquer that didn't belong on a stranger.

"Kurosaki-san… do you have a moment this afternoon?" "Eeh? Why the sudden request?"

No genuine shock. No shift in her breathing. It was exactly as the book described: the calculated response of someone hiding a world of secrets.

By afternoon, the restaurant had fallen into a lull. She was still there, anchored to the window seat. I walked over and sat across from her.

"So… what was it you wanted to discuss?" she asked.

I discarded the pleasantries and went straight for the jugular. "Who are you, really?"

She hesitated, a flicker of something crossing her face. "W-what are you talking about?" Deflection. Defensive posturing. The script was playing out exactly as expected.

"Tell me the truth," I said, my voice low and unrelenting. A few remaining customers glanced our way, but I didn't care. "Tell me who you are."

She didn't answer. Her hands began to fidget, a restless dance of fingers against the tabletop. Checklist item number two: involuntary physical cues.

"I really don't follow..."

I exhaled a jagged breath. "Must I be the one to tear down the curtain? ...Mitsuzu-san."

The world went silent. A spoon clattered against the plate—a small, tinny sound that echoed like a gunshot in the quiet room.

"Kengo… how long have you—" "Or should I call you… Kurosaki Yuki?"

The mask didn't just crack; it shattered.

"I’ve been suspicious from the very beginning," I said. "And it wasn't because you were bad at playing the part. It was because you haven't truly changed at all."

I leaned in, refusing to let her look away. "You still swirl your spoon twice. You still observe food with that cold, clinical detachment. And your writing... it’s unmistakable. Short, sharp sentences that always end in a verdict."

She bit her lip, her silence serving as a confession.

"Coming in quietly. Sitting in the corner. Watching. Those aren't coincidences, Mitsuzu. Those are the ingrained habits of the woman I once knew. Whether you call yourself Yuki or anything else... I know exactly who is sitting in front of me. You are Mitsuzu Kurumi."

Her shoulders began to tremble. "...Enough." It was a broken whisper. The high-and-mighty critic was gone, replaced by a girl drowning in her own choices. "I suppose... I can't keep this up anymore."

She lifted her gaze, her eyes brimming with unshed tears. "I am... Mitsuzu Kurumi."

The lie was dead. Only she remained.

"Why?" the question felt heavy on my tongue.

She managed a small, agonizing laugh. "You really haven't changed, Kengo. Always demanding the core of the matter." She wiped a stray tear. "I did this because I couldn't find the exit. I couldn't move past you."

My chest tightened, a familiar pressure returning.

"I tried to live as a stranger. I tried to bury myself in the persona of 'Kurosaki Yuki'..." She clenched her fists until her knuckles turned white. "But every time I put pen to paper, every time I tasted something new... I found myself using you as the only metric that mattered."

Silence stretched between us, thick and suffocating.

"I’m pathetic, aren't I?" I offered no comfort. "The truth is... I still love you, Kengo. I never stopped."

It was a raw, unvarnished truth. I closed my eyes, feeling the weight of her words. Why now, of all times?

"Mitsuzu," I said, my voice devoid of malice but filled with a tired clarity. "Loving someone shouldn't require you to erase yourself. Love isn't about haunting the halls of the past; it’s about having the courage to stand in the light of the present."

She looked as though I had struck her.

"If you spend your life hiding behind a mask, the person you claim to love isn't even loving you anymore. They're loving a ghost. A memory." I took a steadying breath. "You lost me... the very second you decided to hide."

The words landed with the finality of a gavel. She sat there, broken and silent, before finally nodding.

"Thank you... At the very least, I don't have to lie to you anymore."

I didn't respond. Some truths are so heavy that they sink all conversation. I stood up and walked away. I didn't look back, and she didn't call out. A distance began to re-establish itself—wider than before, yet somehow more honest.

It was a cold comfort, but for the first time in a long while, it felt like something real.

Sakura Mazaki
icon-reaction-1
Ryuji Kamito
icon-reaction-1
Andy-Go
icon-reaction-1
Kuzonoha
icon-reaction-1
Tommy-Maxwell
icon-reaction-1
Kartheek
icon-reaction-1
mitsuha75
icon-reaction-1
Sabira Naoya
icon-reaction-1
MyAnimeList iconMyAnimeList icon