Chapter 10:
The Detective Loves Snacks
It didn’t take much to get Yua here; I simply sent her a message stating there was a new mystery for her to solve and she arrived within a few minutes, practically running.
“Hello, everyone!” she greeted us. “I hear there was a case of possible theft, or disappearance? I’ll be happy to lend my assistance!”
Hitomi looked a bit awkward as she said, “Yes, well, uh, my ribbon’s gone, so we thought you might be able to get to the bottom of this…”
“Oh, I’m always glad to help a repeat customer,” Yua said, her eyes twinkling.
This phrasing made me furrow my brows and look at Hitomi. Did this mean my childhood friend had already used Yua’s services before? Interesting.
“Do I really need to stay here? I have things to do…” grumbled Itou.
“Sounding awfully suspicious there, buddy,” said Sagara, directly a fierce gaze at him along with a raised fist. “Got something to hide?”
“N-no, I don’t! You already had us all empty our pockets, anyway!”
Right—we didn’t just wait for Yua to come, but on Sagara’s suggestion, we all had to prove that the ribbon wasn’t on us. Similarly, we all showed our bags and even Itou’s guitar case, just in case (pun unintended).
“I admit I also heard the rumors about you,” said Hirasaka. “This might be interesting.”
“Will this be good enough, Shiomi-san?” asked Hitomi, presenting a small pack of koala-shaped cookies.
Yua nodded energetically. “Perfectly fine! Now, let’s get down to business.” She looked extremely happy at being put to a job like that—I already knew she liked this sort of thing, but it was amusing. “Can you explain the circumstances? You’re an actual witness here, Amari-kun, so how about you go first?”
“Sure, I guess.”
I proceeded to recount everything that went a few minutes ago, in as much detail as I could remember.
“I see, I see,” said Yua, nodding. “So only the four of you could’ve done that during the arm wrestling match, hmm?”
“Isn’t it just two?” noted Sagara.
“Two, you say?”
“Yeah. After all, Amari and I were busy having our manly match, you see—” He flexed one arm with a clenched fist, “so we had no opportunity.”
“Oh, he’s right,” I realized, and looked to the side—to the other suspects, which were Itou and Hirasaka, obviously.
“Why does it always happen to me?” the boy whined.
Suddenly, Yua approached him, making him flinch as she scanned his face. He was starting to sweat.
“Say… you look kind of familiar.” And then she snapped a finger. “Oh, I remember now! You’re the guy who tried confessing to a girl from a higher grade, only to get—”
The boy’s face reddened. “Ahhh! Don’t even remind me of that!”
“Oh?” asked Sagara. “Meaning, he’s had a past offense? That really is suspicious.”
“It’s not an offense! It wasn’t my fault!”
Yua smirked. “Yeah, he simply had some bad luck. One of my better cases, though. —Anyway, Sagara-kun, you’re not exactly right, you realize?”
“I’m not?” asked the bleach-haired boy.
“When you’re in this for as long as I am, you don’t take these things for granted. All it takes is a small sleight of hand and even you or Amari-kun might’ve taken it, then used the arm-wrestling match as cover.”
“Hmm… I dunno if it’s possible, though,” noted Hirasaka. “At the very least I was watching them the entire time. I don’t think they were able to make any suspicious moves… heck, even Sagara, who was the closest to Hitomi-chan’s desk, couldn’t reach it so easily. He’d need to reach behind him, and he made no such movement.”
“What about you two, then?” Yua turned to Itou and to Hitomi herself.
Hitomi shook her head. “It wasn’t like I was watching over them all the time… but I don’t think either had the opportunity.”
“I did watch the match, but if something happened before that, I have no idea,” said Itou.
This latter remark caused Yua to perk up. “Hmm… I believe Amari mentioned something about you trying to pass by the desk before the match.”
“Yes…?”
“Aha!” jumped Sagara with a raised fist. “So that’s when you took the ribbon, eh? Does touching a girl’s accessories get you excited, hmm?”
The boy looked completely devastated. “Wha… I didn’t do anything like this! Come on, Sagara-san!”
“Well, Itou-kun’s probably right,” said Yua. “Don’t forget that he had no free hands anyway according to your own testimonies, right?”
“Oh, yeah,” I mumbled. One was in a cast, the other was holding his guitar case. In that case (pun unintended again), he literally and physically couldn’t do something like that.
Did that leave us with only one feasible answer?
Hirasaka saw everyone’s gazes focusing on her. Despite this, she just smiled.
“Seriously? You think it’s me? Why would I do that, though?”
“There can be any number of reasons. I’ve seen some rather convoluted motives… hidden ones, or those even the culprit wasn’t aware of, until they got taken by the urge to commit the crime,” noted the small detective.
Hirasaka just shrugged. “I can’t prove anything, but it wasn’t me. If you can reason it out any further, go ahead.”
“Say…” I took this opportunity to speak. “Is there any way to establish the exact timeline where the ribbon was taken?”
Hitomi placed a finger on her lips, thinking. “Sagara-kun wanted me to referee, so I put the ribbon on my desk… and then there was the match. That’d be a few minutes, I guess.”
“Aha, so Sagara-kun’s invitation was the last you’ve seen of the ribbon,” said Yua, nodding. “What about any of the others?”
I shook my head. I only focused on my match with Sagara, so I didn’t glance toward Hitomi’s desk at all.
Itou raised his hand. “I, uh, saw it.”
“Oh? So you admit you’re the thief?” said Sagara. I thought it was pretty clear from his tone that he was just teasing Itou again, but the boy himself didn’t get the memo.
“Wha… that’s not what I said!”
“Calm down. When was this?” asked Yua.
“Well, when I tried to pass by the desk… I did notice there was a ribbon on it,” he explained. “So that means that it was there for at least a little after Yokoo-san left it there, anyway.”
“And then you watched our match, right?” asked Sagara.
“Yes.”
“As expected, it’s a very tight timeline. Hmm…” Yua said, sinking into deep thought.
Meanwhile, my own eyes strayed toward the so-called scene of the crime. We already considered the possibility that the ribbon simply fell to the floor or something, but couldn’t find it.
I did think of a new possibility, however.
“Say, was the window closed back then?” I said, raising a finger.
“The window?” asked Hitomi.
“Ah,” said Yua, “you mean that our culprit may have been just a naughty gust of wind?”
I nodded. That was definitely a possible explanation for a way that required no human culprit.
It constantly bothered me that no one had any motive to do something like that as well as the fact that they couldn’t do it.
However, my explanation was apparently still insufficient.
“It was cold today, right? I’m pretty sure the windows were closed all along,” said Hirasaka.
“I also remember that,” said Hitomi. Her voice sounded weak—was she perhaps depressed that the investigation wasn’t going so well?
Yua looked between us. Although her eyes were sparkling, her expression was very serious.
“A ribbon vanished despite the fact that none of the suspects could have possibly approached it, let alone taken it… meaning, an impossible crime,” she claimed. “But I’ll definitely tear it wide open!”
Please sign in to leave a comment.