Chapter 11:
The Detective Loves Snacks
Despite Yua’s confident declaration, however, it didn’t seem like she had the answer yet. Accordingly, everyone there seemed to grow impatient.
“…Can I leave now?” asked Itou, the eyes behind his glasses narrowed.
“Not until we get to the bottom of this,” Sagara rejected him, raising his fist. “Again, stop acting like you have something to hide.”
“But I didn’t—ugh… you literally searched me already!”
This sentence made Yua jump. “You already mentioned something like that, but… how thorough was that search, exactly?”
“What do you mean?” asked Hitomi. “We, uh, asked them to empty their pockets and checked their bags, too.”
“My guitar case too, by the way!” Itou hurried to clarify.
“Hmm… that’s it? There are other possible hiding places.”
“What, like inside their clothes?” I suggested humorously. However, no one laughed, and Yua looked serious. “No, I didn’t actually—”
“Well, I don’t want to ask anyone here to strip, but it’s definitely an option. For now, I’d like to be able to reason it out before using that last resort.”
Yikes. I knew Yua took her job seriously, and I guess I couldn’t deny the possibility, but still…
“This is ridiculous. Are you sure you really left the ribbon there?” said Hirasaka.
“I… obviously…” mumbled Hitomi, lowering her gaze.
“Then how? What are we missing?”
Hearing this, Yua suddenly laughed. She gave not just one laugh, but a few hearty ones.
“…What’s up with you?” mumbled Sagara.
“Oh, it’s nothing. I just realized that while this crime seems impossible, that’s actually not the case. In fact, there’s only one possible answer; it’s simply a psychological blind spot,” she said, her smile widening and her eyes growing radiant. “I’ll ask again just to be sure—are you sure you checked everyone?”
“Yup. Everyone who was watching the match,” Sagara answered.
“Including the referee?”
Hitomi’s eyes widened. “Excuse me?”
Yua closed in on her. “You heard me. Did any of you check her?”
“What are you even saying?” I asked. “We’re trying to figure out who took the ribbon from Hitomi… do you mean to say that she just misplaced it or something?”
“No, I don’t think she misplaced it at all, is the thing. I think it’s on her right now.”
“…Why would I even do something like that?” mumbled Hitomi. She actually looked quite nervous.
Yua shrugged. “For now, show us your pockets and we shall reveal the truth.”
“Oh, so that’s what you meant,” said Sagara.
Frowning, Hitomi did as she was told, thus revealing—absolutely nothing of note. There was no trace of the ribbon.
Then why did she look a bit worried? Or was it just my imagination?
“Looks like you were wrong, pipsqueak,” said Sagra, wearing an evil smile. “I guess even the great detective fails from time to time.”
Although Yua erased her smile, she didn’t look particularly annoyed or depressed. I could almost hear the gears still turning inside her head.
She suddenly looked around all over us.
“I see… so that’s what this is.”
“…What is it this time?” asked Itou, frowning. “You were wrong, weren’t you?”
“No, I wasn’t wrong. I simply missed another step. But the fact that this ‘theft’ was fake all along remains unchanged,” she declared. “Think about the circumstances… an event arranged to catch everyone’s attention away from the ribbon, which is thus left unattended. This creates the opportunity for it to be stolen.”
“But no one could have stolen it,” said Hitomi.
“I already said that you could.”
“…And you proceeded to discover she doesn’t have it,” noted Hirasaka.
“Yes. Right now, she doesn’t have it. Because she passed it!” Yua declared.
My brows raised. Everyone there pretty much responded the same way. “But how?” I asked. “No, maybe the better question is… to whom?”
“I already said enough, haven’t I? This was a prearranged event—this arm-wrestling event and everything surrounding it.” She pointed at a certain person. “Meaning that it’s you, Sagara Hikaru!”
“Heh. Me?” he replied, raising one arm and shrugging. “You’re free to check my pockets. And I don’t mind stripping for a girl, if you’d like to see.”
Yua apparently decided to ignore his sexual harassment.
“No, you wouldn’t have it in your pockets. I really should’ve noticed your unnatural action, but… In fact, you’ve kept the ribbon in a very peculiar spot.”
“Which is?”
Yua balled her hand into a little fist. “Right there.”
Everyone froze.
Actually, now that she mentioned it, I did notice Sagara throwing a lot of fists throughout this entire case.
Now that everyone focused their gazes on him, Sagara held up his fist, sighed, and slowly opened it.
—Thereby revealing a hair ribbon inside.
“So it really was you!” blurted Itou.
Sagara smiled. “Yeah. You got me good. Great job.”
“Just like I suspected. After taking the ribbon and claiming it was gone, she must have quickly passed it to you at some opportunity, thus preserving the trick.”
Glancing at Hitomi, the accusations were correct: she didn’t look shocked by any of this, but just came over and took the ribbon.
“I, uh, apologize for this, Shiomi-san,” she said.
“Don’t blame her, it was all my own idea,” Sagara hurried to say.
It really was a shocking revelation—but now that I really thought about it, maybe the signs were there all along. From the very beginning it was none other than Sagara himself who insisted this was a theft and swept all of us along with him.
Yua looked much more amused than angry. “I see. But why do all of this? I’m afraid your motive is the only thing lacking here.”
“In a way, it’s his fault,” said Sagara, pointing his thumb at none other than me.
“Mine?” I asked in disbelief.
“Yeah. You’ve been spending a lotta time with this pipsqueak lately… so I wanted to check out how serious things were.”
“I do feel bad for tricking you, but… it was kind of fun,” said Hitomi.
I took a heavy sigh. “Really? All of this, just for that? You’re messed up, man.”
“I’ll take that as a compliment. I just wanted in on some of the fun after you blew me off so often,” Sagara admitted.
“I was also curious if you’d figure it out, I have to admit,” said Hitomi. I thought her eyes looked a bit dark for a moment there, but I might’ve just imagined it. “Again, Shiomi-san, I’m sorry.”
“Oh, don’t be. Why would I mind? I got a snack and a challenge.”
So as long as she got a nice mystery out of it, she would play along? That was definitely some good intel.
“Don’t involve me in that sort of thing ever again,” grumbled Itou, leaving in a huff.
“Well, it was a nice way to spend some time, but I need to get going, too,” Hirasaka admitted and soon left, too.
“Right… I’ll guess that’s it for this one. I hope we didn’t miss another case because of this. Let’s go, Amari-kun,” said Yua and also made her way to the door.
“Yeah, yeah. Uh… see you guys later.”
Both my friend and my childhood friend gave me looks that I couldn’t quite decipher.
“Have fun,” Hitomi said, sounding somewhat forlorn.
Please sign in to leave a comment.