Chapter 8:

Chapter 8: Gluttony

The Heresy of Happiness: The Paladin Branded as the World's Enemy


The smell of beef stew wafts through the dark alley where we are hiding. Bethenah led us straight here from the wagon, through narrow lanes she seemed to know by heart. We slipped, one by one, through an unmarked door at the back of a tavern that, from the outside, looks as abandoned as any other building in this grey city. Inside, it is cold and dim enough to justify its boarded-up windows. The sort of place a passerby would never even notice.

"Anso," Bethenah calls out softly, tapping a specific pattern on the second inner gate.

The man opening the door has broad shoulders and an even broader waist. He wears a flour-stained apron over patched clothes, and his smile is wider than the door he has just opened.

"I thought you lot might have e'en died," he says, pulling Bethenah into a quick hug that she tolerates more than returns. He runs his eyes over the group, letting them settle on me. "You brought more mouths for me to feed, didna ye?"

"A wanted man," Doran replies from behind, gently pushing me through the door. "And a stubborn nun."

Besides myself, I notice that Anso doesn't know Catarina either, and I wonder how long she has been with the rebels.

Anso looks at me for a split second longer, noticing something on my face. Whatever he recognized, he decided not to comment on it. He simply nods and returns to the stove at the back, where a large pot is bubbling over a low flame.

The tavern’s main room is empty. There are no customers, occupied tables, or forgotten mugs. Only Anso, the pot on the fire, and stacked chairs, as if the place had given up on operating long ago.

"Real wheat," Anso announces proudly, stirring the pot. "Not that watery flour the Gratitude Depot's ration oot." The words leave his mouth with scorn. "It's a shame there's nae meat to toss in here, too, aye? Tatties will have to do."

The group spreads out along the long wooden table: Bram already complaining of hunger before even sitting down, Yuri stealing a piece of bread from the uncut loaf on the cutting board, and Sela helping to distribute bowls. She takes them from the cupboard with familiarity, suggesting this isn't the first time they’ve walked through that unmarked door.

I sit in the corner, my back against the wall. The room has two exits: the door we came in through and a window that looks too high up to be practical for an escape. I note this, but let the calculation stop there, without moving on to the next tactical question. For now, I decide to think only about tonight's dinner.

Catarina settles in beside me without asking if she can.

The soup Anso serves is nothing extraordinary. Boiled wheat, some root vegetable, a bit of pork fat that probably cost more than he will admit. But it’s hot, and the first swallow sliding down my throat carries a kind of warmth I didn’t feel in the Paladins’ rations.

I remember the taste of those grains, ground into a gray paste. Everything was measured with exact precision to keep the body functioning, leaving no room for the temptation of gluttony. The Church calls this "dietary discipline", upheld by the control the Gratitude Depots exert over the food. We were taught to give thanks for eating enough to survive, but never enough to feel anything beyond that.

Unlike what I swallowed before, this soup tastes like real food. Which is perhaps what the Holy State of Elyon considers most dangerous.

I eat in silence, listening to the group around me laugh at jokes that I don't care to understand, feeling the weight of the day begin to lift off my shoulders. It's strange, this kind of warmth, sitting at a table among people who have decided, despite everything, that laughing is still worth the risk.

Out there in this world, smiles are a sign of suspicion. In here, no one does it quietly. Doran tells an exaggerated story about stealing from a bishop with his trousers down, and even I know the real version must be far less dramatic. But no one corrects him, because this version suits the table better than the true one would. Sela starts humming softly, and no one asks her to stop or glances over their shoulder to check if anyone heard.

Between spoonfuls, I watch this group of people fill the entire space without self-censorship.

"This soup," Catarina announces, raising the bowl as if to make a toast, "would probably raise the dead. We should use it as a secret weapon against the Congress of Bishops."

"I’d be burned at the stake for heresy afore that," Anso retorts, without looking up from his bowl.

"Just imagine, who would suspect a soup? It’s the perfect disguise," she continues, with a mock seriousness so exaggerated it’s almost convincing.

Catarina’s logic makes absolutely no sense. And that is exactly why I feel laughter rising before I can stop it, bubbling up from a place I hadn’t visited in a long time. She turns toward me for a moment, surprised. Only then does her smile widen a little more in response to mine.

"See?" Catarina says triumphantly. "Even the most serious man at this table agrees with me."

I don't answer. The sound of laughter is still in the air when I realize what I've done.

That sound is interrupted by the sound of fresh knocks on the door.

Three. Pause. Then two more knocks.

Anso is no longer smiling. He stands up and walks toward the door, one hand still clutching the soup ladle as if he had forgotten it was there. The code isn't the same one Bethenah used when we arrived. Her posture shifts even before a scrawny, breathless boy slips into the hall, his eyes too big for his face.

"They've started a patrol," he whispers, as if shouting, or even just speaking loudly, would invite the soldiers inside. "Two blocks away."

The temperature in the entire room shifts in a split second. Bram is already on his feet, tucking the rest of the bread inside his shirt. Sela extinguishes the lamp nearest the window. Yuri quickly stacks the empty bowls, as if hiding them would also conceal the proof that someone there had dared to eat well.

I notice, with a strange tightness in my chest, that no one needed to be told to do any of this. Every gesture is automatic, rehearsed out of fear and repeated so often that it has become choreography.

I feel my own body respond in the same way. I count the exits again and realize I missed a trap door under one of the tables of the kitchen, which must lead to the storage basement. I calculate how long it will take to empty the room using the slowest route. I measure the weight of Bram, who is still limping, against the speed that the escape will require.

Bethenah watches me doing this. She makes no comment. She simply exchanges a quick glance with Anso, confirming something between them without the need for words.

"Everyone to the basement, through the hatch," she orders, already moving. "Anso, put out the fire. If they smell food..."

"Aye, I ken," he cuts in, not offended by her haste.

The group begins to move, quickly but without panic, like people who have rehearsed this kind of exit before.

"Ye go ahead," Anso says as he lifts the trapdoor. "They’re gaun to check hoose by hoose. If I make a bit o' a scene here, I might buy enough time for ye lot to vanish."

My decision emerges before I finish consciously forming it.

"I'll stay and cover you."

Catarina, who was already going down the stairs, hesitates and looks in my direction.

"Are you out of your mind?" she says immediately, making it clear how much she disagrees.

"And do I need your permission?" I respond, and she looks ready to throw hands at me.

"What if they recognize you?"

"This cloak you forced me to wear has served quite well to hide me up until now, don't you think?"

As I try to convince Catarina, Bethenah walks by and shoots me a quick glance. I see no surprise in it, but something more akin to recognition. As if, for the first time since the ambush, she were looking at the vice-captain described in the Paladin’s reports, not just the man she pulled out of a cage.

"No one asked that of you," Catarina says slowly.

"I know."

I choose to stay behind.

Because I’ve decided that these people, who served me soup in an old bowl without asking if I deserved it, are worth the risk I’m about to take.

LisaLisa
icon-reaction-1
m.valeurie
Author: