Chapter 9:

Chapter 9: False Gratitude

The Heresy of Happiness: The Paladin Branded as the World's Enemy


The trapdoor closes with a dull thud, sealing the others in the cellar. Anso douses the fire using a bucket of water, and the acrid smell of damp ash replaces the rich scent of stew. The tavern, so full of life moments ago, is now a tomb of cold stone and shadow.


We are now alone in the dark, the only light coming from the embers of the banked fire.

"Ye're a fool," Anso whispers, not as an insult, but as a simple statement of fact. "They'll hang ye from the highest spire in the city."

"They'll try," I reply, checking the angle of the street through a crack in the boarded-up window.

I stand near the corner of the room, my sword sheathed, but my hand resting on the hilt. It is a familiar posture, one I have held a thousand times while waiting for a target to appear.

The garrison patrol is moving in a predictable pattern, two men on each side of the street, checking doors. Standard procedure for a sweep. Inefficient, but intimidating.

"I saw the way ye held yerself at the table, Sir Paladin. Even sitting, ye were ready." Anso observes, his voice low. He's not asking. He's confirming a suspicion he's held since I walked in. "Then ye know what they'll do if they find ye."

I don't answer. The title hangs in the air between us, a weight I refuse to acknowledge. I adjust the grip on my sword, the worn leather a familiar comfort against my palm. The cut from earlier has stopped bleeding, but the skin still feels tight.

Through the gap between the planks, I see the patrol stop. The two men on the opposite side of the street exchange a signal, and their sweep pattern breaks. They cross straight toward us, one of them already banging the handle of his spear against the door.

"Open up, in the name of the Church of Apex!"

Anso turns pale but moves quickly, tossing his apron under the counter and mussing up his hair with both hands.

"Stay ahint the door," he whispers, already moving to open it before they break it down. "And dinnae come oot, no matter what happens."

I obey, leaning against the wall beside the doorframe, out of sight.

The door opens. I hear Anso yawn, too loudly to be truly convincing.

"Ye feart me," he grumbles, his voice slurred, pretending sleepiness. "I've just woken, what..."

"What's your name?" cuts in a voice I don't recognize.

"Anso. Owner o' this place."

"Come with us. General summons for all adult citizens of the district."

"I already haunded in ma registration last week and..."

"Come with us now," the voice repeats, with no patience for a second time. I hear footsteps, then a shuffling, and the sound of a body being shoved rather than guided.

"I'm comin', I'm comin'." Anso raises his voice more than necessary, and I realize he isn't complaining to the soldiers. He's speaking to me. "Ye're just takin' me to the Gratitude Depot, aye? It's only ten minutes frae here, ye dinnae need to drag me like this!"

The door slams shut. The footsteps recede, the sound of Anso being dragged between them growing fainter and fainter until they vanish completely toward the square.

I stand hidden, just long enough to make sure no one has come back. I go back to the trapdoor and knock three times, the same pattern Bethenah used to get in.

"Anso has been taken," I say quietly, as soon as the gap opens and her face appears in the darkness below. "It looks like they're conducting interrogations at the Gratitude Depot."

"So let's help..." Doran starts outlining a rescue plan downstairs, but I turn it down.

"No. All of you need to get out of the city now, while the entire patrol is starting to retreat instead of combing the streets. Go to where we left the horses, on the north trail, and wait there."

"And you?" Catarina asks me, distressed.

"I'm going to get Anso back."

Whether it was the serious expression on my face or the tone of my voice, Catarina and the others decide not to argue. Bethenah is the only one who meets my gaze for a second, hardly agreeing with that plan.

"If I don't return by sunrise," I say before she asks, "leave without me."

"Elias!" Catarina protests.

"You can't just stand around waiting on an open trail forever, and I'm not going to risk everyone's lives."

Bethenah nods slowly, the same way someone does when accepting a deal they don't like.

"I'm going to leave first. Wait a little longer before you start getting out of here."

I leave the trapdoor open and hurry out of the tavern before anyone else has a chance to object.

The street is empty when I step out. I pull the hood lower over my face and move through the alleys, my steps silent on the cobblestones.

The Gratitude Depot is a squat stone building, its only decoration the carved sigil of the Church above the door. A line of villagers already forms outside, their faces pale and pinched with hunger. They stand with their heads bowed, their hands clasped in the posture of false gratitude the Church demands.

I hear fragments of a prayer whispered in unison, memorized and repeated so often that it has lost any resemblance to true belief.

"Blessed be the balance that sustains us. Blessed be the hand that holds back."

No one there lifts their eyes as they speak. The rhythm is the same hollow cadence I once recited without thinking. This doesn't sound like they are genuinely grateful, but rather more like well-rehearsed fear.

Four garrison soldiers stand guard, their spears held at a lazy angle. Their lieutenant stands by the gate, his armor polished to a mirror shine. I recognize him as a member of the Paladins. His name is Valerius, two years my junior and trained alongside me. He watches the villagers with the detached disdain of a man who believes he is better than the people he is meant to protect.

I walk toward the line, my pace measured, my head bowed beneath the cloak.

I spot Anso before any soldier notices my approach. He is tied to a post beside the depot entrance, his arms bound behind his back and his head slumped forward. A fresh cut splits his eyebrow, suggesting he put up a fight, stumbled, or both.

He doesn't move enough for me to tell if he's conscious, and there's no way to ask without revealing, right then and there, that I know him.

The rope binding Anso’s wrists is a standard garrison issue, the kind that would loosen fast under a blade. But fourteen paces separate us. At the line's current pace, reaching him unnoticed would take too long. Any sudden move toward him, before I neutralize the guard, is the kind of mistake paid for with someone else's life, not just my own.

I need a bigger distraction. So, I keep moving forward, but outside the line, without looking back at the post. One of the soldiers looks me up and down, noting the worn and simple tunic. He sees no threat, just another beggar.

"Get in line," he calls out, his voice bored.

I keep walking. I do not get in line.

The soldier's boredom turns to irritation. He steps forward, his spear now held at the ready. "I said, get in line."

I stop a few feet from him. "I am not here to beg for rations."

The other soldiers turn their attention to me, their hands tightening on their weapons. Lieutenant Valerius looks over, his eyes narrowing. He recognizes the defiance in my stance, even if he does not yet recognize me.

"Then why are you here?" Valerius asks, his voice cold.

"To show you what gratitude looks like."

I draw my sword.

The next movement is a blur of steel.

LisaLisa
icon-reaction-1
m.valeurie
Author: