Chapter 4:
I Command It While I Sing It
By the time Shelly was two months old, the servants of House Halton had learned three things.
The first was that the Marquis did not tolerate gossip.
The second was that the nursery was no longer an ordinary room.
And the third was that nobody was to discuss the night the windows shattered.
Not even in whispers.
Especially not in whispers.
The orders had been delivered politely enough. Master Orven, the household steward, had gathered the servants in the kitchen before breakfast and explained that the Marquis expected discretion concerning certain private family matters.
No names had been mentioned.
No punishments had been announced.
They had not been necessary.
Everyone knew what he meant.
The servants who had been present on the night of Shelly's birth had been reassigned to different parts of the estate. The maids who remained near the nursery were instructed to report anything unusual immediately.
And whenever Shelly cried, someone came running.
At first, the servants thought it was because the Marquis was worried about the child.
They soon began to suspect otherwise.
---
"Again."
Camy looked up from the wooden letters scattered across the table.
Her tutor, Master Ellard, tapped the page with one long finger.
"The letter A."
Camy sighed.
"I already did that one."
"Then do it again."
"Why?"
"Because you made a mistake."
Camy looked at the page.
She had drawn the letter A perfectly.
At least, she thought she had.
"The line is crooked," Ellard explained.
Camy leaned closer.
It was barely crooked.
Nobody would notice.
Nobody except Master Ellard, apparently.
She picked up her pencil and tried again.
A.
Then another.
A.
Then a third.
A.
By the time the lesson ended, she had drawn the letter so many times that she was convinced it was the most irritating thing ever invented.
When Ellard finally dismissed her, Camy jumped from her chair.
"Can I go to the nursery now?"
Her tutor gathered the papers.
"Ask your mother."
"I did."
"And what did she say?"
"She said I should finish my lesson first."
"Then you have your answer."
Camy frowned.
"You adults always do that."
"Do what?"
"Tell me to ask someone else."
Ellard's mouth twitched.
"Perhaps that is because you ask the same questions repeatedly."
Camy considered arguing.
Instead, she ran out of the room.
She knew where her mother would be.
She had memorized the route to the nursery so thoroughly that she could have walked it blindfolded.
Unfortunately, so had the servants.
She had barely reached the corridor when a maid stepped into her path.
"Lady Camy."
Camy stopped.
The maid smiled nervously.
"Where are you going?"
"The nursery."
"Her Ladyship is resting."
Camy folded her arms.
"Mother is always resting when I want to see Shelly."
"She has many responsibilities."
"So do I."
The maid blinked.
Camy nodded solemnly.
"I have letters."
She marched past before the maid could respond.
Unfortunately, another servant stood outside the nursery door.
This one was older.
Camy knew her name was Mara, and she had been working at the estate for as long as Camy could remember.
Mara bowed.
"Lady Camy, I'm afraid you cannot enter."
Camy stared at her.
"Why?"
"The Marquis's instructions."
"Father isn't here."
"His instructions remain."
Camy looked toward the closed door.
She could hear her mother speaking inside.
Then a small, familiar sound followed.
Shelly.
Camy's expression brightened.
"She's awake!"
She reached for the handle.
Mara gently stepped in front of her.
"Please, my lady."
Camy looked up.
"Did I do something wrong?"
The question caught Mara off guard.
"No, of course not."
"Then why can't I see my sister?"
Mara opened her mouth.
Closed it.
Then looked down the corridor.
"I don't know, my lady."
It was the first honest answer Camy had received all morning.
She stared at Mara for a moment.
Then her shoulders lowered.
"Can you tell her I came?"
Mara's expression softened.
"Of course."
"And tell her I'll come tomorrow."
"I will."
Camy turned and walked away.
She didn't cry.
She was a nobleman's daughter, and she had already learned that crying rarely changed an adult's mind.
But as she walked toward the staircase, she glanced back at the nursery door.
She couldn't understand why everyone was acting so strangely.
Shelly was her sister.
She was small, and she looked different, and sometimes the servants made odd faces when they thought nobody was watching.
But she was still her sister.
Wasn't that supposed to matter?
---
Inside the nursery, Suzia had heard the entire exchange.
She sat beside the cradle, her hands folded tightly in her lap.
When Mara entered, Suzia looked up.
"Was that Camy?"
"Yes, my lady."
"Why didn't you let her in?"
Mara hesitated.
"The Marquis's instructions."
Suzia's gaze sharpened.
"I see."
She looked toward the door.
"Thank you, Mara. You may go."
The servant bowed and left.
Suzia remained still for several seconds.
Then she rose, lifted Shelly from the cradle, and carried her into the adjoining sitting room.
Halton had ordered that the nursery remain quiet. He had also insisted that only certain servants be allowed inside.
He had not forbidden Suzia from taking her daughter elsewhere.
Not yet.
Shelly rested against her shoulder, warm and drowsy.
Suzia looked down at her.
"Your sister wanted to see you."
Shelly made a small sound.
"I know. I heard her."
She carried the baby toward the window.
Outside, the gardens were beginning to wake beneath the morning sun. Gardeners moved between the flowerbeds, trimming hedges and gathering fallen branches. Beyond the gardens stood the estate walls, and beyond those walls lay the village road.
A world Shelly would one day have to face.
Suzia turned away from the window.
She was tired of being afraid in her own home.
Tired of watching her husband enter a room and immediately look at their daughter as though he expected something terrible to happen.
And most of all, she was tired of pretending that everything was normal.
She had not forgotten the night of the birth.
She could still remember the sensation of the room trembling around her. The frightened face of the midwife. Halton's expression when he saw Shelly's mouth.
There had been fear in his eyes.
But there had also been recognition.
That was what troubled her.
He had not looked merely surprised.
He had looked as though something he had spent years trying to forget had returned.
Suzia had asked him about it repeatedly.
Every time, he refused to answer.
She looked down at Shelly.
"What are we going to do with your father?"
The baby yawned.
Suzia laughed quietly.
"Yes. I suppose that's a question for another day."
She kissed Shelly's forehead.
Then she made a decision.
She would not allow Halton to turn the nursery into a prison.
Not while Shelly was still too young to understand why the door was always closed.
And not while Camy was still young enough to believe that love should have no conditions.
---
That evening, Suzia went to Halton's study.
She did not send a servant ahead.
She did not ask whether he was busy.
She simply opened the door and entered.
Halton sat behind his desk, reading a report from one of the estate's southern farms.
He looked up.
"Suzia."
"We need to talk."
He placed the report down.
"About what?"
"Your rules."
His expression changed slightly.
"Which rules?"
"The ones concerning our daughter."
Halton leaned back.
"I have already explained my reasons."
"No. You have explained your fears."
She stepped farther into the room.
"Camy was turned away from the nursery this morning."
"She is a child. She needs to focus on her lessons."
"She is five years old, Halton. She wants to see her sister."
"She can see her sister when it is appropriate."
"When will that be?"
"When I decide."
Suzia stared at him.
"Do you hear yourself?"
His jaw tightened.
"Do not start."
"I am not starting anything. I am asking you to look at what you are doing."
Halton stood.
"I am protecting this family."
"From what? A baby?"
"From what that baby might become."
The words escaped him before he could stop them.
Silence fell.
Suzia looked at him.
For the first time, he had said it plainly.
Not the family's reputation.
Not gossip.
Not the servants.
Shelly herself.
Or rather, whatever he believed Shelly might become.
Suzia's voice was quiet when she spoke.
"She is not something waiting to happen. She is a child who needs her parents."
Halton looked away.
"You did not hear what I heard."
"I heard her cry."
"No. You heard a baby cry. I heard something else."
Suzia waited.
He looked at her again.
For one moment, she thought he might finally tell her everything.
Instead, he walked to the window.
"There are things about my family's history that you do not know."
"Then tell me."
"I cannot."
"Cannot, or will not?"
He did not answer.
Suzia felt anger rise inside her.
"You brought me into this family. You promised that I would never have to stand outside your secrets and guess at what they meant."
"This is different."
"Every secret is different when the person keeping it wants an excuse."
Halton turned sharply.
"Enough."
Suzia did not retreat.
"No. You listen to me. I will not let you teach Camy to be ashamed of her sister."
"I am not teaching her that."
"Then stop keeping her away."
He stared at her.
Suzia held his gaze.
At last, Halton looked toward the desk.
"She may visit the nursery."
Suzia blinked.
"What?"
"Camy. She may visit the nursery."
"Whenever she wishes?"
"During the day. With supervision."
Suzia almost laughed at the qualification.
But she knew better than to push him too far.
Not tonight.
"Thank you," she said.
Halton returned to his desk.
The conversation was over.
Suzia turned to leave.
At the door, she stopped.
"One more thing."
He looked up.
"If you ever decide to tell me what you know about Shelly, I will listen."
She paused.
"But if you continue hiding the truth from everyone, do not expect your silence to protect her forever."
Then she left.
Halton remained at his desk.
For a long time, he did not return to his report.
---
The following morning, Camy came to the nursery carrying a small wooden horse.
She had found it in a box of old toys and decided that Shelly needed it.
Babies, she reasoned, probably enjoyed horses.
She was not entirely sure why.
But the horse had four legs, a tail, and a painted smile, which seemed like enough.
Mara opened the door.
Camy held up her offering.
"I brought Shelly a present."
Mara looked at the toy.
Then at the child.
"You may go in, my lady."
Camy hurried inside.
Suzia sat beside the cradle, reading a book.
When she saw Camy, she smiled.
"Good morning."
"Mother! Father said I can visit!"
"He did."
"Did you ask him?"
Suzia closed the book.
"Something like that."
Camy approached the cradle and carefully placed the wooden horse beside Shelly's blanket.
"Look, Shelly. It's yours."
Shelly slept on.
Camy frowned.
"She's not looking."
"She's asleep."
"Can she still hear me?"
"Perhaps."
Camy leaned closer.
"Then I'll tell her anyway."
She settled beside the cradle and began describing the horse.
She explained its name, which was Star, and how she intended to teach it to run. She explained that she would also teach Shelly to run, although Mother said babies had to learn to walk first.
Camy thought that sounded unnecessarily complicated.
Why couldn't babies simply run?
She had been running for as long as she could remember.
She didn't understand why anyone would choose to do anything else.
Then Shelly stirred.
Her mouth opened.
Camy saw the teeth.
She stopped speaking.
For a moment, the nursery was silent.
Suzia watched her carefully.
Camy's eyes moved from Shelly's mouth to her sleeping face.
Then she reached for the edge of the blanket and gently pulled it higher.
"There," she whispered. "Now she won't get cold."
Suzia looked away.
She did not want Camy to see the tears gathering in her eyes.
Camy returned to her story about Star.
And for the rest of the morning, the nursery was filled with the sound of a little girl talking to her sister.
Neither of them knew how long such mornings would last.
---
That night, after both girls had gone to sleep, Halton summoned Master Orven to his study.
The steward arrived carrying a ledger.
"You sent for me, my lord?"
Halton nodded toward the chair.
"Sit."
Orven sat.
Halton remained standing.
"How long have you served this family?"
"Twenty-three years, my lord."
"And have I ever asked you to do anything that would bring disgrace upon House Halton?"
"No, my lord."
"Good."
Halton walked to the cabinet at the far end of the room.
He did not open it.
Instead, he rested one hand on its surface.
"I need you to arrange something."
Orven waited.
"The nursery will require changes."
"What kind of changes?"
"Soundproofing. Better locks. Heavier curtains."
The steward blinked.
"Soundproofing, my lord?"
"Yes."
"For a nursery?"
Halton turned.
"Do you have a problem with the request?"
"No, my lord."
"Then see to it."
Orven lowered his head.
"Of course."
Halton watched him for a moment.
"And Master Orven?"
"Yes?"
"If anyone asks why the nursery is being altered, you will say that Lady Shelly is unusually sensitive to noise."
The steward nodded.
"Understood."
He rose and collected his ledger.
At the door, he hesitated.
"My lord, may I ask something?"
Halton's eyes narrowed.
"What?"
"Is Lady Shelly unwell?"
For a moment, Halton said nothing.
Then he answered.
"No."
Orven waited.
Halton's expression hardened.
"She is perfectly healthy."
The steward bowed.
"Then I am relieved, my lord."
He left.
Halton closed the door and turned toward the cabinet.
His reflection stared back at him from the dark wood.
He had promised Suzia that he would protect their daughter.
He still intended to keep that promise.
But he had begun to understand that protection would require more than secrecy.
The nursery would need stronger doors.
The servants would need stricter instructions.
And Shelly would need to learn, long before she was old enough to understand why, that certain things must never be allowed to escape her.
Especially her voice.
Halton extinguished the lamps.
In the darkness, he remembered the final line of the old record.
Should the voice return, do not mistake its first command for its greatest.
He had spent his life believing that the past was dead.
Now he was building a room around his daughter to keep it from waking.
And somewhere inside that room, a little girl slept beside a wooden horse her sister had given her.
Shelly did not know the rules being made in her name.
She did not know that the walls around her were about to grow thicker.
She did not know that the people who loved her were already deciding which parts of her the world would be permitted to see.
For now, she knew only warmth.
And the sound of her sister's voice, still lingering in her dreams.
Please sign in to leave a comment.