Vito is an heir to the prominent DeCapio family and is in line to become his brother's Consiglieri. He's engaged to the love of his life, and he's soon to become a father. However, a traitor in the family brings his idyllic life to an abrupt end. Enemies ambush Vito and his beloved Rosa en route to a nice dinner in Palermo. He happily gives his life to protect her long enough for backup to arrive.

A goddess informs him that it is not yet his time to die and brings his soul to another world. His new noble family brands him an "outcast" because he was not born with a magic element. The outcast Silver Oak Guild finds Vito and raises him as one of their own. Vito decides to use his skills as a mafioso to become a great adventurer and help his new family.