mimimosas

mimimosas

Me mimi :)

registered at: May 18, 2024
Achievement

No Achievement


Jul 21, 2025

Oh, what a love letter to the isekai genre this is...

There are so many tropes, I'm getting lost in all the references! But similarly, I feel like the way the information is portrayed here is very haphazard... I can't help wondering if the aforementioned number of references factors in. If anything, it feels like the way the tropes are deployed and installed drives a lot of the worldbuilding, but the connective tissue between the tropes is quite sparse.

The narration jumps quite a lot here as well, but this time, paradoxically and ironically, I feel like scene breaks would've helped. Since we're essentially fast-forwarding through Ace's life, this is meant to be a game, and the memories are apparently quite disjointed (?), presenting them as quick 'episodes' might've given them a little more structure. Maybe it would've helped establish a cadence of sorts? Or maybe not.

There's also a bit of a question on my mind here. Sure, we know who Ace is, but I feel like we're lacking a lot of info about who Haruki is. I think the issue I take is that I'm not entirely sure where Haruki ends and where Ace begins - if at any point. It feels like he's pretty much acting like himself, but also slotting into Ace's life to some extent and the blend is heterogenous enough that it's quite visible.

As for the plot... maybe I'm a tad daft, but I'm a little confused what Ace's stake in all of this is? Did I miss when he said why he was so concerned about the world having discrepancies, or what his goal was to begin with? I remember him saying this is an 'isekai scenario', meaning he's maybe preparing for the worst? But that feels like it's sidelining his character and rallying it behind the whims of plot... And I don't like that! Make the character breathe, dammit! Stupid JRPGs...

Anyway, those were my two cents. Hope they make sense :bee_sweat:

icon-reaction-1
Loading...
icon-reaction-2
Loading...
icon-reaction-3
Loading...
icon-reaction-4
Loading...
icon-reaction-5
Loading...
icon-reaction-6
Loading...
1
Flowers Bloomed by a Poisonous Rose
Chapter:2

Jul 21, 2025

Hello!

Hope you don't mind, but I stumbled across this in my search for non-AI generated covers in this contest and thought I'd offer you some thoughts as a reward for not succumbing to the sea of slop. :D

I felt a little strange reading this. The chronology of this prologue zooms past us quite quickly in the last third, to the point where I was left a bit confused as to whether this was still in the same day, or later down the line. I ended up figuring it out in the end, but the scene breaks (particularly the 2-line one about the pipes breaking) didn't help much with locking me in. They also felt a little too... I suppose a word for it would be 'manga-y'? As in it reads like an on-the-page representation of a manga panel.

In a similar vein, the writing style is quite visibly all over the place. There are bits that read precisely like a light novel and bits that deviate from that. It almost feels like you were trying to purposefully dial back your normal prose in order to make it more palatable. I assume it's for the contest's sake? But I'm not sure if that helped you, as the contrasts are quite stark (compare the paragraphs right after Rose's breakout with the dialogue preceding the pipe being armed).

What I do like, however, is Rose's character. I feel like the inspiration from Arkham Asylum is quite clear, whilst Rose herself is a blend of Harley Quinn and Joker (maybe a bit of Poison Ivy too, with her botanic vocabulary). And, let me tell you, reading her is a de-light. I can't wait to see her knock some sense into some adventurers, since reading that ending, it feels like she'll be playing the role of 'Demon Lord' or 'Villainess' in this story. I'll be looking forward to that :D

Sorry if this was unexpected haha! And obviously, feel free to tell me if you'd like me to stop... Though I'll likely carry on with a couple more chapters too... as a taster treat...

icon-reaction-1
Loading...
icon-reaction-2
Loading...
icon-reaction-3
Loading...
icon-reaction-4
Loading...
icon-reaction-5
Loading...
icon-reaction-6
Loading...
2
Flowers Bloomed by a Poisonous Rose
Chapter:1