Chapter 1:


Esper Successor Athena

It is believed that many species of dinosaurs had horns not to attack and kill their prey, but rather, as a means to escape the shell of their egg while hatching. Scientists tell us that the dinosaurs of the past evolved into birds and that the birds of today use their beaks for the same purpose as a dinosaur’s horn. If the bird does not escape the shell of its egg, the chick will die without ever being born. Over the last ten thousand years—humanity has refused to evolve and soon man will be unable to break through the shell encasing him. If all of humanity was blessed with such ignorance, we'd soon become the dinosaurs of a new generation. A new race would come to dominate this planet and they'd hang our bones on display and use our rich history to entertain their children. That is the fate of those who reject evolution. Bookmark here

-Shagia FrostBookmark here

                                                                   Chapter 1Bookmark here

It was the first time Athena thought of a boy as beautiful. Even as the bus pulled away, her eyes stayed locked on the TV in the shop window until the screen was completely out of her view. His face appeared young and strong but his eyes portrayed such sadness that it made her heart pound in frustration. She didn't understand why, but at that moment she wished she could ask him why he was so sad. Snap. Snap. Bookmark here

"Hellloooo?" Dana waved her hand in front of her friend's face. "You said you had something to show me before you malfunctioned." Bookmark here

Athena shook herself awake and opened the issue of Outsider Minds Magazine resting on her lap. Usually, she wasn't eager to share strange or supernatural stories with Dana but this particular story took place at a local park which made her extra excited. Athena propped the magazine up on her lap and presented it to Dana. The article featured a picture composed mostly of darkness alongside harsh flashes of orange—a photo of Lee Maddox Park at night taken with a cheap disposable camera. Both girls knew the park quite well as did most people in the city. Even in a photo of such unremarkable quality, any resident could point out the stone footbridge that carried over the dark pond in the photo’s background. It was beside that footbridge where Athena saw the mysterious entity. The paragraph of text beneath the photo suggested the silhouette, which lurked over the edge of the pond, was the form of the extinct reptile—a velociraptor. The article was rambly and full of crackpot buzzwords that made even Athena roll her eyes. Still, she found a sort of hopefulness in the photo—finally, a story that wasn’t preaching of our imminent doom—she thought, tightening her grip around the magazine advertising Y2K survival kits on the cover.Bookmark here

“It’s obviously just a toy,” Dana smirked. “It's just like the one your brother had. It’s even doing the same pose from the cardboard box. The photos in these magazines are always doctored."Bookmark here

In her head, Athena traced the outline of the silhouette and compared it to her memory of her brother’s toy. There was no mistaking it; it was a perfect match. Athena looked up and saw Dana, mimicking the raptor's claws with her hands, wearing an ear to ear grin. Their eyes met, and Dana saw Athena's bright Bambi eyes glistening through her autumn-fire bangs. She stopped. Bookmark here

"Wait, you're not actually upset are you?" Dana asked.Bookmark here

Athena wanted to say "no" but she was afraid that if she tried to speak, there'd be a whimper in her voice. It was too late when Dana realized what she'd done. She'd mentioned him. Her smile receded, but before she could apologize the bus stopped.   Bookmark here

“Hey, it’s our stop,” said Dana placing her hand on Athena’s shoulder.
Bookmark here

They stepped down from the bus to the hot concrete sidewalk, which on days like this made the mile-long walk to school feel like walking on coal. Their school uniforms required them to wear black dress shoes, but Dana wore sneakers in the morning and changed at her locker since she already needed them for days she had volleyball practice. Athena didn’t seem bothered by the walk or the heat, only shielding her eyes from the harsh sunlight with one hand as she walked beside her friend. It didn’t take long for Dana’s eyes to adjust, but Athena continued to hide her face beneath her hand and Dana knew why. Bookmark here

"Uh, it's so hot," said Dana. "I'm gonna be all gross by the time we get to school. You're lucky, you never get sweaty and gross like I do."Bookmark here

Athena marched in silence, but as she did Dana noticed the pink and green lanyard tied around the zipper of her bookbag, swinging in rhythm with each listless step.Bookmark here

"Oh wow, I can't believe you still have this." Dana moved closer to Athena, rolling the lanyard between her fingers. "I lost mine forever ago."Bookmark here

Her scent was so overwhelming it stung Athena's eyes. It wasn't the smell of sweat, but the aroma of her perfume. It was an earthy scent like patchouli, a scent Athena found pretty when applied subtly, but this was so profuse amount she could taste it. She jerked her bag away and spurred her pace.Bookmark here

“Your coach is going to know you’re smoking again.” Athena said, a frown visible just below the shadow covering her face.Bookmark here

“What are you talking about? I haven't been smoking!” Dana replied bringing the neck of her shirt to her nose and sniffing it.Bookmark here

“It's super obvious,” Athena said, marching ahead viciously. “Also, I’m not as dumb as you think I am. Remember, you're the one that almost got held back a grade.” Bookmark here

“I never said you were dumb! You're just weird." Dana pointed her finger like a dagger at Athena's turned back.  "I've put up with the fairies and psychic junk because I thought you'd get over it once you'd gotten over things, but its been two years now and nothing has changed. I'm saying this as a friend if you keep reading those magazines and believing those stories everyone is just going to think you're a freak.” Bookmark here

"I'm not a freak," she muttered. "And you're not my friend!"Bookmark here

Wiping her eyes, Athena hurried past Dana towards their school. Dana watched the pastel-colored lanyard bounce erratically as her figure shrunk in the distance. The words twisted her chest and she struggled to tell herself she'd done nothing wrong, but in the end, all she knew for certain was that she really wanted a cigarette. 
Bookmark here

Arriving with time to spare, Athena headed to the restroom so she could wash her face before class. Hiding her tears was unnecessary though, almost everyone in her school knew of her predicament. Even though the event happened before high school and she'd never spoken of it to any of her classmates or teachers, gossip spreads like a virus. Parents tell parents, tell their kids, tell their friends. It didn't help that Dana knew and probably told everyone on the volleyball team at their first practice. Moving to a stall, Athena racked her brain with the question, why was she weird? Bookmark here

Everyone believes in strange things. she thought. There's superstitions, astrology, religion, all kinds of people believe in those things and no one cares, but the stuff I like, that's weird?Bookmark here

It took some roundabout maneuvering through the halls, but for the entire day, Athena had managed to avoid Dana Sterling. There was only one class left that day and the last period was Athena’s favorite class, religious studies with Br. Jose. Athena didn’t care too much about religion, almost no one attending her Catholic school did, but Br. Jose’s class was still everyone’s favorite. That was because Br. Jose hated writing on the chalkboard so his entire class was a lecture over slides on a projector. The lights were out most of the class so as long as you didn’t snore, you could sleep the entire period without the teacher bothering you. As a courtesy to Br. Jose, Athena never slept and pretended to take notes. With only a few minutes left of class, Athena sketched a face in her notebook. It was the handsome face of the boy she'd seen on TV that morning, though her artistic abilities hardly did him justice. Even though she'd only seen his face for a few seconds, she couldn't get his image out of her head. His bright blue eyes saw through her and made her heart race so fast she wished she could run her hands through his wavey blonde hair. Any girl her age would call him a heartthrob and yet, she'd never seen his face before. If he was on TV so early in the morning, it must have been a soap opera, she thought. The best way to identify a soap opera is by the actors in it or by the sets, which get recycled in almost every episode. However, the only person she saw on screen was the boy and when she tried to remember anything about the set, she only saw a black void surrounding him. Br. Jose continued spieling about the influence of the New Testament on Renaissance-era art as he changed slides to a collage of paintings from the 15th century. Athena raised her head, hoping the bell would ring so she could put the awful day behind her.Bookmark here

“There’s a UFO!” Athena shouted. The heads of her classmates sprung from their desks as they looked wildly around the room. “There’s a UFO in that painting behind the lady.”Bookmark here

A few students turned their attention to the painting, but most just looked at Athena groaning or laughing. Br. Jose halted his lecture and stepped out from behind the projector to get a better look at the painting. The image was that of a woman praying over a baby in the arms of a haloed child in a nativity scene. Over the woman’s left shoulder stood a shepherd who looked up towards a dark cloud hovering overhead surrounded by streaks of golden light. Bookmark here

“This painting is called the Madonna with Saint Giovannino.” He said, inflating his voice with a mild dose of charisma. “It’s from the 1400s so it’s possible that object is some sort of Christian iconography that’s been lost to time.”Bookmark here

“It’s the mothership coming to take you back to planet Dorkon.” An oafish voice blurted from the darkest corner of the room. Athena recognized the voice as that of Ben Dixon, a pitcher for the JV baseball team, though from his size you'd think his game was football.Bookmark here

“Mr. Dixon I’ve never said this to a student before, but I think you’ll do better in my class if you spend more time sleeping,” said Br. Jose. “As for this picture, there certainly are oddities in the design of whatever this is. UFO stands for Unidentified Flying Object so if you see anything in the sky and can’t tell what it is, then it’s a UFO. So unless Mr. Dixon can tell me exactly what this, Ms. Henderson is correct.”Bookmark here

Athena wore a vindicated smile for a total of two seconds before the halls erupted with the ring of the final bell. The screeching of desks echoed within the room as every kid stood up in unison and bolted for the door. Br. Jose flipped on the lights and continued to lecture about rereading the chapter on renaissance artists, but everyone knew he never assigned written homework. By the time he’d finished talking, the room was empty. Kids poured into the halls from every direction, like ants moving through the narrow tunnels of an anthill. Pushing and squeezing her way through the crowd, she made her way downstairs, joining with another crowd of students as she exited through the front of the building. It was one of the few advantages of being one of the shortest kids in her grade. Outside, in the shade of a tall oak tree, sat two rows of picnic benches where Athena would often find Dana waiting for her after class—the only exceptions being the days she had volleyball practice. Dana’s locker was on the first floor in the hallway closest to the exit, meaning she didn’t have to wade through hordes of wild teenagers just to grab a few books. Athena scanned the area, first around the front door and side exit, then around the edge of the campus. With the school day finished Athena felt relief and standing on the steps of her school alone she felt a little regret about the words chosen earlier that day. Regardless, there was no volleyball practice that day which told Athena that Dana was actively avoiding her. She shrugged off her concerns and made her way to the bus stop.Bookmark here

The walk from the school to the bus stop usually took fifteen minutes, but without having to speed up to meet Dana's pace, it felt twice as long. Only a few minutes into her walk and she was astounded by how well a conversation seemed to improve her stamina. Occasionally, a thought entered her head and she spoke a word or two aloud before realizing there was no one else there, or at least no one else listening. She stopped only half a mile into her trek, stepping out of the way of any passersby by leaning against the brick sill of a storefront. Then, she lowered her bag between her legs and retrieved her issue of Outsider Minds. Picking up where she left off she continued down the block, hoping to keep her mind engaged for the rest of the way even if she was just glancing down at the pictures and headlines every once in a while. She couldn’t read the articles, but at least she looked occupied and it helped her feel less noticeable. Bookmark here

As she reached the end of the block, Athena raised her head from the magazine to check for traffic before crossing. The light was red and the crossing signal—one of the newer ones that counted down how long until the light changed—displayed the walk sign with 10 seconds remaining. Four lanes of traffic meant she could make it if she ran, but as she tucked her magazine under her arm, she noticed three girls strolling across the crosswalk, taking their time to reach the other side. Dressed in the same uniform as her, Athena paused recognizing the girls by their hair and backpacks. The shorter ones were freshmen from the volleyball team and leading the pack with her blonde hair in a messy bun was Dana. The numbers on the signal turned red. 9—8—7… One of the girls raised her hand and flicked a clump of ash off the end of a cigarette before returning it to her mouth. Dana turned her head revealing a long unlit cigarette between her lips. Bookmark here

Athena moved between a metal pole and a trashcan. Peeking out from behind the pole, she watched as Dana struggled to light the cigarette, the flame of her lighter refusing to ignite.Bookmark here

I'm weird? Well you're a liar! Athena thought. Bookmark here

The walk sign’s countdown ended and the light changed, inviting a stream of cars that divided Athena from the group of girls. Athena turned towards the adjacent crosswalk now displaying a ‘walk’ sign, chucked her magazine into the trashcan, and ran to the other side of the street away Dana. Athena’s detour took her in the opposite direction of her bus stop, but she didn’t care. The bus came every half hour until late in the evening. She had plenty of time to explore the area around her school and still get home at a reasonable hour. Besides, the first bus after school was always the most crowded; she’d enjoy a much more leisurely trip—one where she wouldn’t have to worry about her and Dana awkwardly meeting eyes the entire ride. Bookmark here

There was a sense of wonder in seeing unfamiliar buildings, or at the very least, it was exciting enough that she forgot about her aching feet and the hot sun beaming down on her. She moved deeper into the city, drawn in the direction of the store with TVs in the window where she'd seen the boy. Once there, she'd have no way to identify him, but she might at least find out if the TV was still tuned to the same channel. If she knew the channel and the time, she could find the show.  Suddenly, Athena’s eyes caught the glow of sunlight reflecting from a banner of shinning gold letters that hung across a second story awning. The golden letters sprawled across the purple banner read “Church of New Life.” At ground level were two large windows, which any other business would use to advertise products. Instead, they masked the windows with a layer of opaque film that prevented anyone on the streets from seeing inside.  The door of the building was coated in the same film. A laminated sign hung on the outside reading “OPENED: Free PSI evaluation inside.” Bookmark here

Athena didn’t realize there was a Church of New Life so close to her school. She’d never seen one in real life, only heard stories about them. New Life was technically a religion, but most people said they were a cult. They preached about ‘the need for humans to reinvent themselves.’ Their goal was to give their followers the best life possible, but there were rumors about secret meetings and strange documents that only high-ranking members are allowed to know about. According to stories on TV, if you reach a high enough status they reveal secrets about aliens and psychic powers. It sounded absurd, but the movement garnered substantial traction and legions of followers including politicians and movie stars. Even though some of the rumors rivaled the sillier issues of Outsider, Athena didn’t care for the scrutiny, especially having gone to a school that forced her to read the Bible. The Bible was full of stories of miracles, superpowers, and even talking animals, but it was rude to call those stories preposterous, and believing in aliens was crazy and childish. Bookmark here

Athena pressed her face against the window and cupped her hands around her eyes like binoculars trying to see through to the other side, but the thick white film blocked all light and Athena only saw darkness and the insides of her hands. Even though the sign said ‘opened’ Athena didn’t feel welcomed. The lengths they’d gone to in assuring privacy from prying eyes insisted they took their teachings seriously and they’d probably find it condescending if a teenager barged in ogling their scriptures and rituals. Athena felt an immediate connection to the religion and its followers. No one respected their beliefs. Everyone said they were weird and stupid. Bookmark here

Athena decided to place her search for the mystery man on hold and find out what the Church of New Life was really about. Since she was entering a church, she wanted to look mature. Athena centered herself, raised her chin, stuck out her chest, and arched her back to look taller. She took a deep breath and donned her sternest face. Crossing through the doorway of that building was like stepping out of a desert and into a meat locker. Air conditions rumbled overhead, poising the silver strands of hair along her arms like pointed-spears. Her first impression of this holy place of reverence was that it looked more like a bookstore than a church with four rows of three-tier racks forming aisles leading to a counter in the back—register and all. Athena moved forward, her curious eyes leaping from dust jacket to dust jacket as she rubbed her hands from her wrists to her elbows for warmth. She stepped lightly across the hatched carpet as if it were crawling with venomous snakes—her eyes still scouring the book—none of which recalled anything close to the stories and photos she read about in her magazines. Far from the imagery of alchemists, crop circles and occult symbols, they appeared to be self-help books—all prominently utilizing the word ‘life’ in their titles like some overused catchphrase.Bookmark here

“Can I help you find something?” a middle-aged blonde woman asked from behind the counter.Bookmark here

Athena paused for a moment then timidly said, “I was wondering if I can take the evaluation. The one on the sign.”Bookmark here

“Of course, we have the machine right here.” the woman smiled. Bookmark here

Machine? Athena thought. Bookmark here

Athena’s heart sank for a moment imagining the bizarre contraption they had hiding in wait. She saw herself strapped to a gyroscope or tied to a table while men in masks shot lasers into her eyes with machines monitoring her brainwaves like a CT scan mixed with an EKG machine. She looked back at the front door one last time, now desperate to know why they obstruct the view. The woman stepped out from behind the counter and retrieved a suitcase from a storage closet. She lugged the case over to another door on the far left side of the floor concealed behind a wall of posters. It made Athena wonder how many more of these secret rooms they had—eyeing all the posters and shelves that cluttered the place.Bookmark here

They called it the evaluation room, but it felt more like an interrogation room with two seats on opposite sides of a desk that divided the room through the center. The woman hauled the case up onto the desk with both hands, grunting as she dropped it down and invited Athena to take a seat. Athena flinched at the bang of the case but then moved carefully into the seat closest to the door. Bookmark here

Her heart raced, but she dropped her book bag at her side, rested her hands on her lap, and swallowed the saliva in her mouth imagining herself in the visage of a cool calm adult. An adult wouldn’t be afraid and an adult can believe in superstitious things, she reminded herself while she watched the woman fiddle with the briefcase latch. The latch popped opened, the woman let out a breath of relief, and Athena smiled back at her.Bookmark here

“Perfect. Let’s get this show on the road.” the woman said, folding her hands together and breathing heavily through her nose. Bookmark here

She opened the case revealing one of the Church of New Life’s infamous PSI machines: a light blue chassis of similar size and shape to a fax machine with a needle resting on the left side of a gauge, the right side of the gauge displaying the word MAX. Athena knew about the machines, she’d heard stories that they analyzed your dreams and registered your mental fortitude. It was one of the metaphysical devices mocked in the media anytime their name came up. Two gray cables ran from the back of the machine, each branching out into four thinner cables with steel alligator clips soldered to the ends. The woman pushed the machine to the left side of the desk, scraping it across the laminated wood—an agonizing squeal piercing the air until the device rested against a wall at one end of the table. She sat down opposite Athena, and as she did, Athena noticed the poster on the wall above the woman—a spread the size of a movie poster tacked to the wall. Strong cold eyes on a youthful face stared back at Athena—he was tan with black hair, well dressed, and sporting a remarkable physique.Bookmark here

“Who is that?” Athena asked.Bookmark here

“That’s our chairman, Mr. Shagia Frost.” answered the woman, straightening the cables of the machine.Bookmark here

Athena’s glare turned sideways. “I thought he needed a wheelchair?”Bookmark here

 “No, never." the woman replied. "He lives a very active life. It’s all explained in his book Inside and Out: A Perfect Body for a Perfect Life. We have it in stock if you’re interested.”Bookmark here

“Oh, uh…No, thank you.” she replied faking a smile as the woman handed her the steel clips. Bookmark here

Athena secured the cold steel bits to the ends of her fingers, as the woman plugged the machine into a power outlet under the desk. Straightening her back and squaring her shoulders, Athena braced herself for an electrical shock, but the machine remained still and silent. As the woman continued to fiddle with the cables, Athena stared deep into the eyes of the man on the poster. There was no mistaking him. She recalled the first time she’d ever heard of the Church of New Life. It was only a few years earlier when she caught the tail end of a news report about a wheelchair-bound entrepreneur, but he looked different back then; thinner and his slick black hair was a bushy mess. In his TV segment, he explained that he was collecting art from around the world and it was through discovering art from various cultures that he found his own spirituality. Her memories of the TV special concluded as the machine rumbled with a high-pitched buzz.Bookmark here

“It works pretty much like a lie detector,” she explained. “First things first, we want to explore your emotional range and see how much PSI energy you give off. If you can, I want you to close your eyes and try to put yourself in a frustrating situation. You’re talking to someone but he or she doesn’t understand you. There’s a barrier, not one of language, but of understanding. Can you do that?”Bookmark here

Athena nodded.Bookmark here

It was too easy. She closed her eyes and rested her hands on her lap, tightening her grip around an invisible magazine. She could feel her seat rumble up and down, the humming of the PSI machine became the growl of the city bus, and the frigid room became hot and dry.Bookmark here

“Wait, are you actually upset?” the line repeated in her head becoming louder and more damning with each utterance. Bookmark here

“Are you ACTUALLY upset?” it was as if Dana stood there, in the doorway of the room, standing over her again, mocking her, thinking she was an idiot just for wanting things to be better. Her hands balled up on her knees, the steel clips clanking together as they touched.Bookmark here

She thinks she’s SO mature…Bookmark here

“You're just weird!”Bookmark here

Why can’t I be happy?Bookmark here

Then there was silence.Bookmark here

“That’s not good.” The woman said.Bookmark here

Athena’s eyes jolted open and she drew a heavy breath like it was the first she'd ever taken. She saw was the woman inspecting the PSI machine, its obnoxious growl silenced. Bookmark here

“Is it…broken?” Athena asked.Bookmark here

“I think it overloaded.” she almost laughed and flashed a nervous smile. “Let’s try something else.” Bookmark here

The woman unplugged the machine and moved it out of view below the desk. Then, she exited the room returning only a few moments later lugging an identical machine colored a pale green. A glossy finished reflected the fluorescent lights above and it made Athena wonder why they hadn't used this machine first. The woman set up the machine in the same position as the previous one but instead of steel clips, she handed Athena two chrome cylindrical rods. When she grabbed the rods, she expected they'd be heavy but upon grabbing thought it felt more like holding two empty soup cans. Before long, the incessant buzzing resumed and the woman was ready to administer the second test.Bookmark here

“I want to do something different this time,” she said. “Instead of thinking of a frustrating moment, I want you to remember a time where you were happy. Try to recall a memory—one as recent as possible. Okay?”
Bookmark here

Athena closed her eyes again. Staring into the darkness she searched for a memory, but her fixation on that morning's outburst clouded her mind. She thought harder. Then, she remembered the brief moment when she saw that boy, their eyes meeting through the TV screen as if they could actually see one another, but by the time she felt a softness in her chest, the moment was gone. She needed something stronger, a truly positive experience. She delved further back into her memory, but she only needed to go as far back as the start of summer vacation to produce the necessary feeling.Bookmark here

Leo’s room was exactly how he’d left it two years before the accident. His bed unmade, curtains drawn shut, toys strewn about the place, and dresser drawers left hanging opened at uneven levels. The room was dark, but Athena couldn’t risk flipping the lights on or her mother might see her from the hallway. Dancing around the mess of action figures and video game cartridges that littered the floor, she moved towards curtains at the far end of the room. If she could brush the curtains aside she’d have enough light to find what she was looking for.Bookmark here

Crap!Bookmark here

She felt the sharp plastic stab her foot. Exhaling from her nose, she used all her might to suppress an agonizing wail. She rubbed the sole her feet, watching the bedroom door from over her shoulder—cautious of any sign of her mother—becoming still like a statue blending in with the clutter. All clear. Once she was close enough, she pulled the curtains opened halfway so that there was enough light to make out the corner of the room where Leo’s TV sat atop a two level media console. Darkness still shrouded most of the area, but the few surfaces touched by the light revealed layers of dust across furniture, toys, and his bed frame. With a better sense of her surroundings, Athena avoided all the toys making her way over to the TV, the glass screen caked in a thick layer of dust. Athena felt compelled to wipe it clean but knew she’d just be leaving behind evidence for her mother, who on most days guarded the room like a correctional officer. Athena lowered herself to her knees and stuck out her two pointer fingers, hovering one over the power button and the other over the volume down button. With amazing precision—she landed the timing—turning on the TV and lowering the volume before the blaring sound could alert her mother. Bookmark here

The lower shelf of the media stand housed Leo’s most prized possession, his Cozmo96 video game console. Video games frightened Athena’s mother, who viewed them on the same level as street drugs. It took over a year of pleading and coercion, but she eventually compromised and bought them a system so long as they promised not to fight over it. Athena and her brother agreed, but an agreement wasn’t good enough for their mother, and so, their mom would only allow them to play two-player games. For a while, this drastically limited their library of games. However, the two found a loophole in her rigid policy. If one of them wanted a single-player game, they’d lie, always backing each other up assuring their mom it was a multi-player game. This often meant when one of them got a new game; the other would have to watch, sitting beside their sibling hitting random buttons on a controller, pretending to be playing along. It wouldn’t fool other kids, but their mom never knew. Genuine disputes did arise between the two, and to prevent any intervention from mom, the two created a system where one would play the game until they lost a life. Then, the other would take over and they would switch off anytime someone died or after thirty minutes of consecutive playing—whichever came first. Bookmark here

Bookmark here

The only stage left in the game was the final boss, who killed them three times already. When last they left off, it was Athena’s turn to play. As she positioned her thumb on the control stick, she noticed how much smaller it felt, her fingernails digging into the palm of her hand as she gripped the controller. She only had one chance. Without Leo, a loss here meant she could never touch the game again, but likewise, a win meant that after two years she could officially say that she and Leo had beaten the game together. The screen flashed and Athena smiled—shaking with excitement.Bookmark here

You can resume reading from this paragraph.