Sinnocence

Sinnocence

registered at: Mar 08, 2024
Badge

badge-bronze

bronze
Achievement
Thumbs up Level 4
Comments Level 3
Published Novel Level 1
Published Chapter Level 4
Novel Cover Upload Level 3
Time(Daily access) Level 5
Participant - MAL x Honeyfeed Writing Contest 2025

Jun 15, 2025

Are the Lover, Detective, and Father real people "you’ve" killed with doppelganger's? Is the room a literal cell, a dream, or a metaphor for "your" mind? Like stief said, I don't get it. The loop at the end doesn't really provide payoff in the normal sense. And that may, most likely be the point. Really well done unreliable narrator.

This may all just be me and the fact I don't completely get it. I trust you'd take it with a grain of salt: I feel the skip from “you’re trapped” to “you’re the killer” is a huge leap. One-shots do need to be efficient and economical, but I feel the idea behind this story was really difficult to pull as a one shot. The lover's dialogue also made me laugh a bit with all the drama-just because-accusations. I'm not sure if that was intended, I'd like to think it was. And the Father’s constant “child” felt a bit forced like it was trying to form a connection that wasn't there. But I suppose that could be part of the ambiguity. Whether it's even “your” father, in the first place. I also felt like you leaned more into prose over actually moving the plot forward. I don't think that's much of a problem though. It 'is' a one shot.

Despite how difficult this was to pull off, I think this is a really amazing one shot. You’ve hammered home the vibe and tone of a locked-room mystery to perfection. The small cast of characters. The setting being so minimalistic. I can clearly see why you thought a locked-room mystery would work for the contest's prompt. Using second-person as the MC is also a really bold choice. I think I've rarely seen it done as good as this work. I'm just personally glad to see an entry like this that doesn't play safe. :]

icon-reaction-1
Loading...
icon-reaction-2
Loading...
icon-reaction-3
Loading...
icon-reaction-4
Loading...
icon-reaction-5
Loading...
icon-reaction-6
Loading...
2
trace
Chapter:1






Mar 22, 2025

The sisterly bond between Isolde and Gwen is the heart and soul of this chapter. And it hits the most in the last scene. Loved it.

The crisis of inflation is very realistic in this scenario and I'm glad you tackled that.

The worldbuilding is interesting but some of it could use more description. Example:

"She continued to drag Gwendolyn down the icy cobblestone road surrounded by clutter, the aftermath of the riot that followed shortly after the news. It was the morning after the blizzard. A ripple of shock washed through the Weavers, and naturally, it led to fear. That fear quickly evolved to panic, then by noon, the village was overrun by mayhem."

I understand the need to watch the word count but this—society's reaction to the news—feels like an important moment that could've been shown beyond "surrounded by clutter."

Surrounded by clutter is a bit too vague. You're already amazing at descriptions so I just thought to point it out. Even something as simple as the merchant looking over his shoulder every few seconds afraid someone will steal from him can make me feel the aftermath of the news.

Also, this is probably just me but the merchant feels too nice. Like he didn't cheat them *too* much. If he undervalued the necklace, however... And didn't add the extra food, then Gwen's anger too go as far as stealing his book might feel more justified. Again, it's probably just me.^^

There were no typos this chapter. (At least none I noticed.)👌

Really good and emotional chapter overall. ^^

icon-reaction-1
Loading...
icon-reaction-2
Loading...
icon-reaction-3
Loading...
icon-reaction-4
Loading...
icon-reaction-5
Loading...
icon-reaction-6
Loading...
1
Stories across the Five Tribes
Chapter:2