AdventFalls

AdventFalls

Doing it for the love of the game.

Finalist:
- MyAnimeList x Honeyfeed Writing Contest 2025 - Twilight Frontiers : "Mama Bear, Papa Wolf"
- MyAnimeList x Honeyfeed Writing Contest 2026 - NOVELOUS Worlds : "I Hate Dating Shows, So I Joined One to Ruin It!"

registered at: Sep 01, 2025
Roles
  • Author
  • Badge

    badge-bronze

    bronze
    Achievements






    Eilise Frediereke
    The Sleepy Mage who was Forced to Travel
    Chapter:5

    Oct 15, 2026

    I have come from OMEGA WHEEL, summoned to give 'first impression' feedback at the 10% point of this story. Take as much salt with this as you feel is warranted.

    - Killer opening line. No joke, it's a good line. A lot of stories have a hard time immediately grabbing attention within the first chapter. You do it with one sentence.

    - Overall good character voice for Leon. Honestly, good prose overall for the most part.

    - I can respect the choice to spend time pre-tragedy setting things up, especially given the description implies that those things will be important later. I questioned the pacing at first, but chapter 4's kicked on the afterburners. A lot of stories spend at most one chapter - I don't mean that as a negative for them, just something I noticed.

    For constructive criticism...
    - I've mentioned in other bits that one of my pet peeves is single-lined dialogue without associated emoting or action and single-lined exposition, especially if they're in succession. You have SO MUCH of that in this work. I think I counted eight lines of dialogue in chapter 1 that's JUST dialogue without any descriptions. And it's consistent through the other chapters, while the rest of the prose works! You have so much of your word budget left with only 58K used! It's a testament to the relative quality of your work that this stands out so hard.

    There is something here. It's a very compelling start, and nothing that I've harped on can't be fixed in an editing session.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    The Last Wolf of Valemont - Cover
    The Last Wolf of Valemont
    Chapter:4




    Oct 13, 2026

    Hello hello! I have come from the OMEGA WHEEL, to provide some 'first impressions' feedback at the 10% mark of this story. Take anything I say with as much salt as you think is warranted. (I am not a judge.)

    - Alice's 'endearing' flaw stands out. When most protagonists in this prompt default to being clumsy or socially inept, the concept of some Mr. Bean/Inspector Clouseau/Inspector Gadget type figure bumbling around and accidentally undoing the machinations of antagonists is a great idea with a lot of comedic potential!

    - First-person perspective isn't that common from what I've seen in these entries. But I think you're very effective at communicating Alice's voice through the narration.

    - Harl is a good boy. Honestly, he and Alice make for an interesting duo.

    As for constructive criticism...
    - At first blush, there's pacing problems here. With only thirty chapters and a word count just shy of the minimum at 50K, that's a recipe for something that might be a faster pace. But we haven't gotten to any of the stuff in the last sentence of the synopsis. No dragon, we're now on chapter 4 with still searching for the guild (though based on the title of chapter 5, we're about to get there). It's possible that you made a deliberate choice to be meandering to fit with the prospect of 'endless side quests', which while that's commendable does not make a good first impression.

    - A personal pet peeve of mine are lines of dialogue - especially single sentences - that are presented as their own paragraph without any immediately associated action or emoting. There's some of it in chapter 1 and this one. You don't do it consistently, but I'm surprised it's happening given the word count.

    Overall, I like your heroine and there's a strong core here. Some more fleshing out and polishing could make this one to reread.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    The soup WIP
    Scatterbrained Alice: How Could I Forget to Save the Kingdom?!
    Chapter:4

    Oct 10, 2026

    Taking a vacation from my vacation to give you a 'first impressions' feedback, since this is the 10% mark of the story. Take anything I say with as much feedback as you think is warranted.

    - Nora is in the top tier of heroines I've seen in the prompt so far. No qualifiers needed. She's likeable and her flaw of paying so much attention to monster care & behavior that she doesn't appear to have the same intuition for human behavior is an 'endearing' trait. You'd be surprised how rare that can be...

    - Overall good marks for character work.

    - Pudding is cute. 10/10.

    For constructive criticism...
    - If this story has an Achilles' heel, it's the pacing. A lot of stories I've seen that hit or approach the upper word limit of the prompt have an issue where they linger on scenes and take their time. We're on chapter 5 (6 if you count the prologue), and apart from the prologue (which IS effective at setting up core concepts) we appear to only now be getting to introducing Nora's enrollment in the magic academy or its existence at all. For a point of comparison, the first Harry Potter book (which is roughly the same word count) is also about to get to the magic academy by this point - but has also already given Harry his notice of enrollment, had him shop for school supplies, got him on a train, introduced several students who will be relevant at said school, and he's about to arrive at the academy for opening ceremonies. If you designed this story to be a slower burn, again - take this with salt.

    - There are extended segments of single line dialogue or exposition without any emoting or associated actions in the later chapters I saw and it's killing me. Because you don't have it in the prologue or first chapter. It is a personal pet peeve and nothing that you couldn't fix with an editing pass.

    Overall, I think what I've seen IS written well. It just needs to be tightened. For what it's worth, IMO this is one of the strongest entries I've read so far for the prompt. And OMEGA WHEEL made me read a lot.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    0
    The Little Witch Who Loves Slimes Just A Little Too Much - Book Cover
    The Little Witch Who Loves Slimes Just A Little Too Much
    Chapter:5


    Oct 08, 2026

    Hello, hello! I have come at the 10% mark to give some 'first impression' feedback! Please take this with however much salt you feel is appropriate.

    - The core concept is different enough from the more typical 'main character wants to avoid the plot and live a chill life' that I'm here for it.

    - I'd argue comedy is the hardest genre to write, because at least bad drama can be unintentionally funny. The comedy beats of 'the character causes accidents with their own strength' made me chuckle. Praise Gustav, lord of murder.

    - Mary's flaw of 'I do not understand humans' is understandable enough in context that I don't paint her with the 'this person was copying Tsukino Usagi' or 'this person watched Bocchi the Rock' brush. It is at the very least, A flaw that makes life difficult.

    As for constructive criticism...
    - Pacing is hard to form an opinion on. On first impression, it felt glacial at points. But the combination of this being a near max-word count entry and there being chapters with similar names or with 'Part X' implies to me that this might be designed as a slower burn. So take this remark with more salt than otherwise.

    - Formatting likewise I'm unsure what opinion to have. There are line breaks that end and start scenes, which is more than a lot of other stuff I read. But I felt like there were occasionally sections where I would have preferred a hard break.

    Overall, I think there's a lot to like so far. Most of the presentation and the characters, especially. If I have time, I'll be back at the end with more feedback.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    From Empress to Commoner: The Former Demon Queen's Quest for a Peaceful Life Begins with Becoming a Hero
    Chapter:6

    Oct 08, 2026

    Hey there, checking in at the 10% mark to give some first impressions feedback! Please take this with as much salt as you see fit.

    - This is one of the more original ideas I've seen in the EH prompt for Kado '26. That can be a double-edged sword - original =/= good, at times. But the positives here are that when you explore the more original elements like the underground city of Aure, they stand out.

    - Likewise, the tension between the two species feels apparent. I like the main characters of Ui/Lullaby and Cro. They've got a good dynamic going on. So by this time, we do have some idea of what the stakes are.

    I do have some constructive criticism.
    - I had difficulties with the pacing. You have a word count of about 72.4K and a chapter count of 62. It took 7 chapters to reach the 10% mark, and you do establish stakes and characters in that time. But it feels like you take a while to get there. It's possible that this story is constructed to be a slower burn, in which case... well, I did say take it with salt.

    -I'm not a fan of extended single-line dialogue formatting, where an entire paragraph/section is a single sentence of dialogue without any emotion or associated action. That's more prominent in the later chapters I've read up to this point. It's aggravating to see here because I saw it done better in earlier chapters.

    Overall, I like the idea and I see some potential. There's some polish stuff that I think another editing pass can fix. But I totally get why this is getting the flowers (hur hur) that others are giving it. If I've got time, I'll give more feedback at the end.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Flowers on the Battlefield
    Chapter:7