Mo

Mo

registered at: Aug 04, 2023
Badge

badge-bronze

bronze
Achievement
Thumbs up Level 5
Comments Level 4
Novel Cover Upload Level 1
Time(Daily access) Level 1

Aug 29, 2023

"We'll never know all the good a simple smile can be capable of doing."  Yet, alongside the healthy relationship it once again emphasizes , this chapter highlights how to use "the smile" and its benefits, according to Agreste.

Three cases stand out: smiling in the face of adversity, smiling in the face of anger and smiling to comfort.

Smiling in the face of anger, as illustrated by his altercation with the man at the theater entrance. Agreste's first reaction was to get angry too. After all, who wouldn't get angry at someone who hurts the person they love? He could have chosen to continue holding the man by the collar, staring at him and even insulting him, or fighting... but our mc made a completely different choice: he smiled. His breath slows, his heart softens, as does his gaze, and he simply bows, apologizing and offering his help. Then, with a glance, he tells him to stop.

Smiling in the face of adversity is what our mc is trying to get Anabelle to understand. 

First of all, I think adversity should be understood in a broader sense, encompassing fears, doubts, etc., anything that might generate a certain anxiety. 

Here, Anabelle is uncomfortable with the idea of performing in front of a large audience - which is understandable, given that this is something new for her- Once again, you've captured Anabelle's state of mind plagued by negative thoughts really well, by putting her in the shadows, and then putting her on the sunlight when she decided to smile  after the curtain ( self imposed ceiling) has been drawn by Agreste. Faced with these observing eyes, our mc didn't lose his smile, he even revealed his true identity - an incredible thing when you know what it means to him. Yet this decision didn't seem to faze the spectators, who returned to their occupations so soon afterwards.

The audience's reaction, and Agreste's mention of the  undines who are simply too quick to pay attention to their surroundings, echoes social relationships/interactions. We often tend to think that everyone is looking at us and judging us in some way when they're not, a bit like being in a room full of people and thinking that all their spotlights are on us when they're not: they're on themselves, each being absorbed in their own life to judge that of others (in theory). So all we have to do is live as we wish, under the spotlight of our smile, because that's the only one that will truly enlighten us.  This also underlines that people hear more than they listen.

Finally, the third scenario is a smile for comfort. 

Agreste uses this smile at the beginning of the chapter to comfort Theresia after the altercation, telling her that it's not her fault and that she doesn't have to apologize, but rather to thank him. This behavior reminds me a bit of Theresia when she didn't pay attention to his apology about the fact that he couldn't marry her.
He then uses it to comfort Anabelle.
Finally, he uses it to comfort himself. I understand better, now, why he was trying to smile when he cut himself again in the kitchen; in a way, apart from not worrying Theresia, it was a way for him to try and combat his adversity: his discomfort.

More generally, smiling was what he always did when faced with tricky situations, such as helping Lihal, fighting his anxiety, """"conquering""" love, dreaming of  "the impossible" (standing by the clouds).

Then, wouldn't smiling be the best way for him to fight his regrets?

Side note 1 : did you use " I am in love with you" and " I love you" on purpose, or it just a matter of prose ?  I've read some articles about these two concepts a couple  weeks ago that highlighted how much they were different. To sum up a bit 
=> being in love is a more emotional reaction/ thinking about someone all the time/ wanting the whole of them. It is not a stable state like it can fade or grow depending of how we choose to handle it. 
=> to love is more a choice, emotions are stable/ we care more about the other than we think/ needing someone/ needed + wanted someone 
For some reason, Agreste reminds me of the "being in love meaning" because he wants the whole of Theresia ( selfishly). Being in love is his reaction to the feeling "love" which is full of new different emotions for him. The unstable state may refer to the guilt and pain hi is feeling, his regrets toward marriage/ engagement his "love for theresia" which are driving him to a crossroads ( how to handle this feeling of love ) . He believed that having Theresia by his side was enough to be happy, but the previous chapters highlighted well that it wasn't enough, he wasn't happy as a whole. Also, he never said " I love you" to Theresia but only " I'm in love with you". On the other hand, what is bothering me is that "loving" her was his "choice" so it can be said that he loves her, but on the other hand, he did not conquered love entirely 🤔
Theresia saying both " I love you" and "  I am in love with you" means that she loves him "fully" then ? 
I was wondering this for a while, and now seeing Theresia telling him that the feeling in her heart is different before saying she is in love with him "for the first time" just intrigued me even more. Maybe Agreste believes Theresia told him that many times, while she was just saying "I love you", because he simply can't understand well the meaning of love/being in love.
Side note 2 : Agreste radiates

icon-reaction-1
Loading...
icon-reaction-2
Loading...
icon-reaction-3
Loading...
icon-reaction-4
Loading...
icon-reaction-5
Loading...
icon-reaction-6
Loading...
1
Your Heart has Meaning
Your Heart has Meaning.
Chapter:31

Aug 28, 2023

Is it possible not to regret anything in life? Regretting one's mistakes, or regretting non-actions, failures, things left unsaid or dreams unfulfilled: regret is always a negative notion, a form of disappointment at having failed one day in the past. We all regret having been hurtful to someone, or not having shown enough affection to someone else.

For Agreste, the Pandora's box of regrets is the word "marriage".

Why marriage, when on the one hand he'd give anything to spend the rest of his life with Theresia, the woman he loves, but above all, when he's happy with her ? Well, quite simply, because he's not happy as "a whole".

To understand this new notion of "as a whole", we need to go back to the flashback in which Nagahiro asks him to marry her. In this flashback, there were two clear principles: to "change one's heart" to say I love you, and to "change oneself" to get married. To conquer the word "love", Agreste had to change his heart by accepting both the love he had for Theresia and the love she had for him (although this chapter leads me to believe that he hasn't conquered the word love in its entirety, since he doesn't love himself => in a way he has conquered the word love, but not its meaning, hence the fact that his heart is still sore). To conquer the word marriage, he'll have to "change" (in a more general sense). To do so, he'll have to face up to his regrets, which are nothing other than the union - the  marriage- of his guilt and the pain of losing a loved one.

This guilt and pain are basically like two magnets - the past and the future - between which ( the present moment ) our mc is trapped  but happy nonetheless, because here his heart doesn't suffer. To use the metaphor of the "bridge of life", it's as if the sun only shines where he is, and the rest is plunged into darkness - the negative emotions.

But is this really what it means to be happy, to be at peace?

Then maybe being happy as whole could mean being happy with "his past, present and future"=> finding the meaning of his heart through time ?

More generally, I think conquering marriage also means mourning Nagahiro and accepting that the choice to leave was her, in a way. What I mean is that, just as Agreste chose to take his own life so as not to suffer anymore, perhaps committing suicide was also Nagahiro's choice so as not to suffer anymore, too. It's a bit like Agreste and his parents, in the sense that Agreste's choice to tell Nagahiro he couldn't love her was his own, but the choice to hate him, to let that choice dictate her life, was one among many for Nagahiro. In a way Theresia's reaction, who tried to understand Agreste instead of being mad, was one choice Nagahiro could have made.

I have to qualify what I'm saying, though: in his previous life, Agreste hadn't yet conquered the word "love", and Nagahiro's question went much deeper than that.  But in another sense, I feel that in both contexts, it wasn't a question of will, but more of ability: "you cannot love me?/I cannot marry you", which shows that it's not that Agreste doesn't want to, but that he can't at the moment.

Beyond the choice to "change", it's above all what this implies for our mc that's important. Should he change completely and forget his past, keep a part of it or simply stay as he is? Is Nagahiro a part of his past that he wants to keep with him? If so, how can he "keep her" without suffering ?  These are a handful of thoughts among the hundreds that now run through the mind of our mc.

icon-reaction-1
Loading...
icon-reaction-2
Loading...
icon-reaction-3
Loading...
icon-reaction-4
Loading...
icon-reaction-5
Loading...
icon-reaction-6
Loading...
1
Your Heart has Meaning
Your Heart has Meaning.
Chapter:30

Aug 27, 2023

Since Solis told him that unburdening or not himself of his guilt is his choice, Agreste has once again fallen prey to a storm of self-questioning.

To combat this "storm", the first choice he makes, in my opinion, is simply to stop thinking about it. He "clears his mind", by concentrating on what he's doing, which is cooking.  But then, he gets hurt.
- The wound is a wonderful parallel to the cut he made himself in the theater (and, by extension, in the stomach to kill himself). What I really appreciate, among other things in your writting, is that you reuse "significant" events to approach them in a new way, a bit like the change of perspective that Agreste undergoes during his journey.
- I don't think the realization he is having here is a "real "realization"/"change of perspective" like the one he had in the theater, in the sense that here, this injury simply puts into words his state of mind, something he already knew deep down: he feels horrible. I think this is the first time he  really put into words how he feels.
- His thoughts: In the theater, his thoughts were sharp as knives in a way -  they were very precise thoughts he had + memories of physical/psychological pain etc... Here, his thoughts are just clouds, an uncertain, dull mist symbolizing the confusion reigning in his mind.

However, his reaction to this wound, regarding Theresia, is as it was in the theater: he tries as best he can to wear the mask of a smile on his face. And this,  is the second choice he makes to fight the "storm".

This mask of a smile is not just a mask he shows Theresia so that she doesn't worry about him,  but above all a mask he shows himself to say/convince himself that he's all right. After all, isn't this the mask he's always worn to hide his discomfort ? ( That's why I'm thinking that, indeed, the fact that he says he feels horrible may be a " real realization" too because in a way he's taking off the mask he was wearing with regard to himself.)

 
The third choice our mc will make is to force himself to say "I deserve it", but deserving what?
- part of me tells me that it may refer to this bath, the kindness Theresia shows him , but more generally the "Kindness". Which makes sense, given the discussion he's had with Solis and all the consequences it implies. The fact that he forces himself to say it aloud and hesitantly is then a first step towards his choice to move foward. Then,  the steamy ceiling from which it's impossible to escape could also refer to the cloud of thoughts in his mind => he realizes that he won't be able to run away from it and that the only possible choice for him is to confront it in some way, and that starts with telling himself that he deserves Kindness.
- another part of me, which I'm sure is over-interpreting, tells me that perhaps "I deserve it" should be understood in a more pejorative meaning like  deserving his "unhappiness", his guilt => a bit as if he was making up his mind in some way.

In any case, a new goal has entered our mc's mind : "to find peace". He already found part of that peace with Theresia.The other half he'll only find it with himself.

So, in a way , when he has found it in its entirety, he will be able to contemplate a beauty he has long refused to see: the beauty of life, quite simply.

Side note 1 : Under this willow swaying in the wind, in this little piece of land in the middle of this misty land, Agreste is going to expand Theresia's sky a little more -as Nagahiro had expanded his-, by talking to her about the seasons. And, although he had refused to show Theresia the snow previously if I remember well, he finally decides to show her this beauty she doesn't know.
Side note 2 on "forcing": this method is a bit double-edged. It's often said that you don't lose a habit, you just replace it with another. So, if Agreste forces himself to say he deserves kindness (if  deserve = meliorative meaning), he's gradually replacing the habit he used to have of feeling guilty, or at least of letting his guilt rule his life=> getting better and taking control of his emotions in a way. But on the other hand, as the previous chapters have pointed out, we can't "force" ourselves to feel such and such emotions, because they simply won't be sincere. So wouldn't forcing himself ultimately make him feel just as bad as before, or reinforce his guilt? Loving Theresia and receiving her love are things he chose because he wanted to. Here, "being master of one's emotions/feelings" is still a very new concept for him, and as he's still confuse... ah idk how to explain it clearly, but to sum up for me "forcing oneself" and "choosing" are totally different in terms of sincerity so if he forces himself to say he deserves it in a way it won't be sincere because he won't have chosen it. But then maybe this step is simply a part of his choice 🤔
Side note 3: there's also the entry of a new term in Agreste's lexicon => try . He's trying to find peace, trying to be well, trying to "hold Theresia's hand" in every possible ways
Side note 4: the different ways of holding hands reminds me a little of the different ways of loving someone
Side note 5 : As she heals his wound by wrapping it in a bandage, Theresia heals Agreste's body (a "human" wound) by wrapping her arms and blanket around it.

icon-reaction-1
Loading...
icon-reaction-2
Loading...
icon-reaction-3
Loading...
icon-reaction-4
Loading...
icon-reaction-5
Loading...
icon-reaction-6
Loading...
1
Your Heart has Meaning
Your Heart has Meaning.
Chapter:29

Aug 26, 2023

Contemplating Theresia in her work is once again a way for our mc to focus on the person he loves so much. "Contemplating" is a fine word to describe Agreste, absorbed by Theresia at the peak of her art, leaning on his arm. Agreste, for whom, among other things, nothing else matters except watching his beloved deposit her thoughts in the ink of her pen, the fine folds surrounding her eyes : watching the Playwrite in action. In a way, hasn't he too found someone - not something - he loves so much he's not paying mind to the world around him ?

One of the most important thing here is that, for the first time, their "professional masks" will merge towards a "common goal": to show the stars to the people of Aethine (I think the term "goal" isn't exactly what I had in mind, but it's the only one my sleepy brain could think of).

As for this "common goal", several thoughts come came to my mind:
- think of this "goal" as a kind of bell that would ring over their respective goals: Theresia giving "something for people to see" ( Playwrite mask) + "moving forward through writing ( Theresia ) / Agreste: beam the world in happiness ( Baron of Lilac ) + helping Theresia shine ( Agreste)- wanting the world selfishly. So this "goal" would be like a means for each of them to fulfill their objectives
- since it is a merge of their masks and their objectives, basically it becomes an objective for them "as a whole".
- the very fact of showing the stars to Aethine: given all the symbolism it holds, it could only be the best joint project for them of them. Also, to put it in parallel with the theme of the perception of beauty, I have more the impression that here Agreste isn't doing this to show "the" beauty as he knows it - as was partly the case when he showed Theresia the stars - but more to show "a" beauty, which is the hearts of Aethine's people ( as Solis mentioned). 

And what better way to do this than to ask Solis for help.

( middle side note: it's been several chapters that I've noticed he's only called him solis once, the rest of the time to apostrophize him, he uses moon metaphors 🤔 it makes sense somehow because in this city where the "night" is a part of the day he's a bit like the moon and the sun at the same time ? or solis without a mask is the moon? Or maybe it's just a matter of perception/ or it is just me over-interpreting again ? 🤔 It intrigues me. )

Their discussion not only seals the collaboration between our three giants, it also brings Agreste's self-perception and guilt into question.

He describes the latter as "binding". And this qualification is in opposition to "feeling". What I mean is that, as the flashback in which Nagahiro confessed to him underlined - nobody can force us to feel any emotion, except ourselves. The change in his perception of his parents illustrates this, because as you said, it was Agreste's choice to perceive as a slight as it was his choice to forgive them. This is what Solis underlines, saying that guilt is inherent in everyone, and that it's not saving the hearts of the undines that will make him stop feeling this guilt in a way,  but rather his choice.

Agreste has always believed/chosen to believe that it was by "giving" to others - beam the world in hapiness/show the stars/help the inhabitants - that he would feel completely better, when in fact he doesn't, because guilt is an emotion he still hasn't chosen to stop feeling. More generally, in an attempt to lighten the burden of guilt, he made his heart a place for others, not for himself.

He's also always seen his heart as a place where emotions sit somewhat in spite of himself, and that he can't control them/ have any "choice" over them. What Solis refutes, among other things, by telling him that it's only he who can say whether he can feel such and such emotions => being the harbor of his own feelings (in a way, that's what he's managed to do by choosing to accept "love").

Finally, this discussion puts into words a human behavior that is simply that of being hard on oneself and devaluing oneself. To use the metaphor of the library, only we know all the books it contains, and only we choose the impact that certain books will have more than others, which can sometimes lead to discrepancies between our perception of ourselves and the one others have of us. In Agreste's case, he still has a very pejorative view of himself, a view of someone not good enough to deserve kindness => more generally, he focuses more on his faults than on his qualities. These qualities are not lacking, and are shared by Theresia, who has a good image of him. Solis, too, has a good image of him, at least enough to tell him he deserves all the kindness in the world. And this meliorative vision of him is the one that everyone who has read his poems, or those he has helped ( idk about Cassea ) has of him.
More generally, other people's perception of us is not necessarily the same as our own. ( a bit like the perception of beauty )

Finally, "The worst enemy is oneself, But I don't kill him, because I love him." ( Charles de Leusse ) sums up well, I think, this new stage in Agreste's ascent: choosing to love himself to not """"""kill""""" himself, as he had done in the past.

icon-reaction-1
Loading...
icon-reaction-2
Loading...
icon-reaction-3
Loading...
icon-reaction-4
Loading...
icon-reaction-5
Loading...
icon-reaction-6
Loading...
1
Your Heart has Meaning
Your Heart has Meaning.
Chapter:28


Aug 25, 2023

This chapter is the antithesis of the evening Nagahiro died. Yet there is the same storm, the same silence and the same pain of failure.

The same silence that Agreste felt when Nagahiro visited her for the last time is now the silence that fills the streets of Aethine, where the sun never sets, in which he rushes down. A simple silence that not even the noise of machinery can disturb. So what's this storm rumbling through the city? Quite simply, our mc's heart which is now a storm. A storm where failure torns like thunder, the salt curtain emerging from his eyes. A cacophony of emotions disturbing the sweet melody of love that reigned there until now. It's raining on his heart.
In a flash, the anxiety engraved in his bones resurfaces, his vision of the world darkens: starlight no longer illuminates him, the world is only darkness, Theresia's home has lost all its warmth. The latter, curled up in her blankets, is as if enclosed in a silken ceiling.

Just as the Baron of Lilac had gone to meet Nagahiro that evening, Agreste "went foward" to meet Theresia. Just as his heart missed its fourth beat in his previous life, it misses it again here. Agreste can only wonder if this feeling of deja vu he knows so well, of hurting others by choices he may have made, is synonymous with yet another failure. A failure leading to the loss of someone he loves.

With all these similarities, how is this event the antithesis of what happened in his previous life? Well, it's the end of the storm.

In his previous life, the storm had left the skies to only rage in Agreste's heart.

Here, after the rain comes the good weather. The storm hovering over our MC's heart lifts as soon as Theresia lays her hands on his cheeks and reassures him. Like a ray of sunlight breaking through a ceiling of clouds, a ray of well-being warms Agreste's heart.

Theresia's heart beams in happiness, as you so eloquently pointed out before, she no longer needs to deal with her admiration for two different entities since they are the same person. Now she can fully love Agreste as a whole.

This walk through the city will allow Agreste to bring to Theresia's attention a part of his past that was  in the shadow of his library. In a way, the mud on his shoes symbolizes the regrets of the past, or at least the things he couldn't, or didn't choose to, confront before he died,

Showing Theresia this book is a way of telling her about his concerns, in this case who he really is, but above all what Agreste really means to him. In a way, this makes me think that "Your heart has meaning" may also refer to Agreste's journey to love himself, to give meaning to his own heart.

Finally, for Agreste, showing this book to Theresia is also a way to tell her how much she means to him, how wonderful she makes this foggy world, but above all tell her that she makes him belong to this world. For Theresia, reading this book allows her to learn a little more about the man she loves so much, but above all to love him a little more as a whole.

With her, he no longer needs a mask; he can simply Agreste.

Finally, the fact that the earth is visible from Crell means, among other things, that it was also visible in Agreste's sky, and I can't help thinking that, deep down, Crell was a star among the sky he admired so much on earth. The fact that he's standing beside Theresia could mean that he's done much more than stand by the clouds, he's literally standing in the stars beside the most beautiful of them all.

In a way, his death was just the beginning of his ascent.

This chapter really moved me. Is it due to the fact of seeing them confess their concerns to each other, the importance/ symbolism of each of their words, this pure love or simply the beauty of the prose itself ? I don't really know but I think it has a special place within my heart now. Once again, and as always, I can only praise your work ^^

icon-reaction-1
Loading...
icon-reaction-2
Loading...
icon-reaction-3
Loading...
icon-reaction-4
Loading...
icon-reaction-5
Loading...
icon-reaction-6
Loading...
1
Your Heart has Meaning
Your Heart has Meaning.
Chapter:27

Aug 25, 2023

Alongside its adorable atmosphere, this chapter brilliantly illustrates the flowering of the seed planted in the previous chapter or more generally the " choice's thematic"

It begins with the choice to  change his perception of Theresia's home. Previously, our Agreste had a rather pejorative view of it, or at least chose to interpret elements as such. For example, the silence, its impersonal side, which made it seem less like a real home. In retrospect, I think this meant that he wasn't really "at ease" in Theresia's world -home-, because of the doubts he was struggling with at the time and the choice he made to personify them in the apartment. In other words, the choice of description reflected his state of mind.

From now on, he chooses a more detached vision, a  "dont mind" logic : he relativizes. He could very well have chosen to interpret the mess as something really negative. But he sees it simply as a clash of spirits, and puts himself in Theresia's pov to say that it is not a big deal.

The spider's web metaphor then sums up the change in his perception of their relationship.
- At the beginning of his ascension/when he met Theresia he "perceived" it as a trap where his heart -the tiny bug - was trapped in the spider's web of his feelings/regrets/guilt.  It was a trap where he wanted to escape
- Now, by choosing to change his perspective, this "trap" becomes a bed of silk where the spider is simply the beautiful Theresia who, with her love and actions, "imprisons" him in her cocoon. It's a trap he now wants to stay in.

Another interesting thing to note is the description.

So, I don't know if it's just me over-interpreting your choice  to not describe with precision an environment you've described in the past to avoid repetition, but I really have this impression that Agreste is much less absorbed by the description of his environment => he no longer rambles/has chosen not to ramble. Since its a feeling, idk what words to put on it so Ill just share this "few" thoughts :
- it could be link to the fog that lifts in his mind when he's with Theresia and the fact that he's focused on her and on no one else/ on the present moment => he's no longer lost in a cloud of thoughts
- refers to the fact that when we're disconnected from the present moment, we often tend to attach particular importance to our environment, to its details => we're spectators of our own lives (observatory reference) rather than actors, as it were. So here, Agreste's focus on his feelings/on the details of Theresia's clothes means he's an actor in her life.
- " I had no poetic ramblings to speak of"/ "I couldn't help but describe its wonder in my own mind"

Then comes the moment when he dresses Theresia, which, beyond being an "intimate" moment, underlines :
- trait physiques en commun ;  hair color and the twinning emotions they feel
-" the material link between them": Agreste's hidden garter for Theresia and a ribbon on Agreste's wrist

Then comes the encounter with Kitsch

First of all, there's a bit of a parallel with Lihal and her army of servants, although the objectives are different here: to welcome "warmly" Agreste and Theresia.

But the most important thing is the clash of spirits between Agreste's spirit and the spirit of the Baron of Lilac this encounter brings
- Agreste: he doesn't even know which mask he's wearing, and to tell the truth, that's not what's "tormenting" him most. Indeed, his priority is to know whether he should keep these two "entities" separate or not, not because their objectives are dissonant - a slight nuance compared to the beginning - but simply with regard to Theresia, because he doesn't want to hurt her. This brings a new nuance to the theme of choice, which is their weight or, more simply, their consequence on others (in a way, this is a direct application of the awareness he had of his suicide in his previous life).
- Theresia: for her, Agreste is Agreste
- Kistch: for him, Agreste is the Baron of lilac. So I think the fact that he called Agreste that in Theresia's presence is really a sign of inattention. It was his choice to perceive him that way, as he explained at Lihal. On a more general note, it makes me think that, in reality, no matter what masks we present to others, in the end it's they who will choose to see us with one mask rather than another, or without one.

But now, with this declaration, the masks have come off for Agreste: Theresia now knows his "true" identity. All that remains now is to find out which mask she will choose to see Agreste as, or whether lf she will simply see him now as a whole.

Personally, I don't think the "sudden chock gaze" in her eyes was anything to signify aversion or hurt - if Agreste perceived it that way, it's surely because he was already a little "apprehensive" - On the contrary, this revelation is more a way for her to put into words, to explain the feeling she's been holding for a long time in her heart, but also perhaps the unwavering trust she placed in Agreste. From her body language, she looks more relieved than upset.

In the end, I don't think she minded it too much, if at all.

Side note 1: the mess in Theresia's apartment somehow brings it to life
Side note 2 : In each other eyes, Agreste and Theresia are a beauty that never fade. Agreste as an eternal blooming flower/ Theresia as an endless perfection
- also Theresia's compliment: I think it's one of the first real ones she's ever told him
Side note 3: again, it was well thought out to symbolize Theresia's trust in Agreste by using "Azurite", the stone of confidence, to describe the color of her eyes,
Side note 4: I think this revelation was necessary for Agreste to finally be as a whole to finalize his ascent
Side note 5 : good morning ^^

icon-reaction-1
Loading...
icon-reaction-2
Loading...
icon-reaction-3
Loading...
icon-reaction-4
Loading...
icon-reaction-5
Loading...
icon-reaction-6
Loading...
1
Your Heart has Meaning
Your Heart has Meaning.
Chapter:26


Aug 23, 2023

"There are times when the wildest dreams seem achievable, provided you dare to try." ( Bernard Weber ). It's human nature to impose limits on oneself, to devalue oneself, to look for excuses when a goal comes to mind, especially when that goal seems completly new. For Agreste, his dream is to touch the sky, his own limits: he's too small, has no wings. On the one hand, this reflects his recklessness and naivety as a child, where money, betrayal and other means to achieve it are absent. On the other hand, it gives us a new perspective on the notion of ceiling. Let me explain.

In fact, what this flashback tells us, among other things, is that we're all under the sky, but we're the ones who sometimes lock ourselves under a ceiling. Here, we can understand the sky as simply representing dreams, but also as the notion of freedom where anything is possible. In the flashback, Agreste isn't locked up, he's outside, in a field of grass in the breeze => he's free - free to dream - yet it's he who locks himself up in an ceiling, listing his faults.
I also got the impression that Agreste was a bit like a bird when he was dreaming. Among other things, a bird is synonymous with freedom - its ability to fly wherever it wants - but also with dreams and achieving goals. In a way, by limiting himself to his physical defects, Agreste has "put himself in a cage".

More generally, we're all free, but we're the ones who make ourselves prisoners.

This notion of freedom is also extended as the freedom to make choices, whether they are possible or not, but above all to know how to live with and assume them.

I just find this incredible because this flashback ultimately depicts Agreste's journey.

First of all, we understand that his goal is to free himself from the cage/ ceiling/ limits he has imposed on himself ( because of his past ) +  to be able to make choices for himself, whether they are possible or not. Loving himself, loving other and being loved are just a few examples. But we also find these choices when he drags Theresia into his fall at the theater, but also in his free fall from the building. In theory, as he pointed out, they were going to end up crushed to the ground - having no wings or superpowers to catch themselves - . And yet he made the choice to take her down with him without asking himself whether or not it was possible for Solis to save them.

And this whole process of freedom involves the extension of his sky, as evoked by his mother.

Simple coincidence or twist of fate, it turns out that our mc is on the verge of realizing his childhood dream of standing among the clouds.

It's a continuation of his ascent and the expansion of his sky, which is now at its most complete stage, at its apogee, with Theresia on his side. In a way, she was what he was missing to be "complet". Together, they climb beyond the fog, that ceiling above Atheine, they go beyond the limits. Together, they contemplated the beauty of the sky and the clouds.

Just as Theresia had shown her part of her library by sharing with him this place that only she knows, her favorite spot in Atheine, it was now Agreste's turn to show her part of his by sharing the realization of his childhood dream - once again, Theresia trusted him.

And here they are a few moments later, standing amidst the clouds.

And what could be better than a lilac-colored cloud on its first interaction with the sky? This can be understood in different ways, depending on the symbolism of the flower to which one is attached.
- remembrance: he reconnects with the past in some way, more specifically with his parents. Already, the flashback was one of the first memories in which he appears happy alongside them, and from which we get a fairly positive description of them supporting their sons and encouraging him to pursue his goal.
- joy and beauty: our mc's feelings about this wonderful landscape
- maturity: the extension of his sky's mind 
- love: he is here with his beloved Theresia
- youth: a childhood dream = touching sky
- and simply Lilac as Baron of Lilac => maybe this is a sign that he's as a whole now or that he also achieve his dream as the baron => beam the world in happiness

Side note 1: the parallelism between Mulhacén and the tall buildings of Athein trying to touch the sky in their own way. In a way, this city is full of peoples who haven't stopped dreaming, who haven't let themselves be confined under the ceiling  Solis "imposed" on them (I also think that they imposed this roof on themselves, too, by being eager for conflict/ ressources ). But dreaming of what? Of peace? Of war?  Or simply their respective dreams 🤔
Side note 2 : this flashback takes up the notion of making the impossible (dreams) possible (through choices).
Side note 3: From Theresia's pov, this building could symbolize the trials and hard work she's had to accomplish to reach her goals/dreams. More generally, her own ascent.
Side note 4 : Here, Agreste is completely happy, laughing to tears, daring and trusting himself.
Side note 5: "touching the sky" often refers to the impossibility of achieving a goal, a bit like a utopia. Seeing Agreste achieve it materially implies that anything is possible...
Praising side note again for this  chapter, I really liked the moral that follows from it and the beautiful way you've approached it. It was, as always, very pleasant to read ^^

icon-reaction-1
Loading...
icon-reaction-2
Loading...
icon-reaction-3
Loading...
icon-reaction-4
Loading...
icon-reaction-5
Loading...
icon-reaction-6
Loading...
1
Your Heart has Meaning
Your Heart has Meaning.
Chapter:25


Aug 21, 2023

Like in the chess game, Lihal draws up her army to protect herself from the new "Agreste attack", drawing up an army of cadaveric servants in the darkness of the residence => an army of desolation that life has left behind.

In a way, this staging is merely an allegory for Lihal's life with the thorn mask: a manichean life made up of black (the darkness of the residence, her gaze, the tone of her voice) and white (her clothes + more generally the fact that no emotions color the palette of her feelings: she's a blank canvas surrounded by thorns) where red - synonymous with the "blood shed" by those who approach her thorns - is the only nuance.

From her attitude to her callousness , everything about Lihal is reminiscent of the black rose: a symbol of thorn feelings  and turmoil. Indeed, here, this army is not only there to protect her, but also to protect others from being hurt by her wall of thorns. So, scaring Agreste is, for her, a blessing in disguise: she'll once again lose someone who was there to help her, but he won't have to suffer as she does, and he won't have to go near her wall of thorns. Nevertheless, if the black rose has a negative symbolism, it also symbolizes a message of hope and renewal: in a way, it's just an impression, but I think that the warning messages from the servants were in a way cries from Lihal's heart, which between words are begging Agreste to stay.

When the darkness is there, the dawn is never far away. And that "dawn" is none other than our dear mc. Undeterred by this threat, Agreste even laughs about it, creating a discrepancy between Lihal's seriousness and his derision ( again we're finding the same comedic undertone  as when he was climbing the ladder in the previous chapter :) )

In reality, when carefully observed in the light, the black rose is made up of an infinite number of shades of purple and pink. It's these shades that Agreste's words will bring to Lihal's attention. A warm, colorful world now appears to her=> full of emotions, a world without thorns where she can be herself: a ray of sunshine.

And what better color than yellow, synonymous with joy, cheerfulness, sweetness and freshness, to symbolize this young girl who beams in hapiness, dancing in the dark. The stepmother - the source of darkness - now frightened away, the wall of thorns now fallen, the sun's rays can now only fully penetrate this dwelling so this freshly bloomed rose never tarnishes.

Side note 1: the white color also refers to the fact that she is "neutral"
Side note 2: with her yellow dress and luminous aura, Lihal also reminds me of a yellow rose, a symbol of joy and cheerfulness.
Side note 3 : when Agreste said " Open you eyes" I think a "r" is missing ^^

icon-reaction-1
Loading...
icon-reaction-2
Loading...
icon-reaction-3
Loading...
icon-reaction-4
Loading...
icon-reaction-5
Loading...
icon-reaction-6
Loading...
1
Your Heart has Meaning
Your Heart has Meaning.
Chapter:24


Aug 20, 2023

In the soothing calm of the theater, under a new starry sky, his eyes riveted on the most beautiful of them all, Agreste finally moves forward, beginning his ascent to the stars. This movement is ultimately the pivotal point of this chapter, in which our mc simply moves forward, again and again towards Theresia: he advances into the room, climbs the ladder, comes closer to kiss her. For the first time, it's no longer she who comes to him, but he who comes to her. In a way, the fact that he refuses to let her come to him by climbing down the scaffolding/ refuse her to kiss him reflects this idea.
What better way to represent Agreste moving forward than by climbing this damaged, reluctant ladder. A ladder whose splinters wound him just as past regrets and guilt have wounded his heart. Nevertheless, this pain won't be what stops our mc who has decided not to look back... also the pain is worth it, his star is waiting for him at the top, his star is only a few rungs away.
Unfortunately, just as he's about to touch his dream with his fingertips, the ladder breaks, the ball and chain of the past are too heavy, and his free fall begins.
Just as she supports him in real life, Theresia catches our MC. She catches him again and again, no matter how far he falls. It's a nice way of showing that she'll always be there for him. Finally, he takes her with him in his fall: he drags her along - for the first time he trusts himself, he trusts himself not to hurt her. It's just a huge symbolic gesture, given his state of mind when he arrived at Crell. It's also worth noting that Agreste's fall is, in a way, the image of the fall of his heart when Nagahiro asked him to love her in return, the difference being that Agreste (and therefore his heart) didn't fall into a dark, bottomless abyss, but into a cradle of light and warmth, into the arms of the one he loves . Then Theresia confesses her feelings to him, too. Despite their respective flaws and the things they don't say, they've learned to love each other.
Then comes the moment when they become one ( OMG ). This kiss fills Agreste with something he's never known before, a calm without regret, remorse or apprehension.
Under this clear, starry night, where their feelings are pure and sincere and free of fog, happiness penetrates the gates of his heart, where love has taken root. From now on, Agreste loves and is loved. He can now fully contemplates stars and even touch one of them

Side note 1: Dullen stars => altered emotions in each of them, doubt etc... the fact that Theresia repaints it could symbolize the fact that each of them has taken stock of their respective emotions.
Side note 2: perhaps "a confession marked by blossoms" could refer to the fact that some flowers ( such as joy, love and serenity ) finally budded in Agreste's field of emotional flowers as a result of this confession
side note 3 : what a beautiful chapter

icon-reaction-1
Loading...
icon-reaction-2
Loading...
icon-reaction-3
Loading...
icon-reaction-4
Loading...
icon-reaction-5
Loading...
icon-reaction-6
Loading...
1
Your Heart has Meaning
Your Heart has Meaning.
Chapter:23


Aug 19, 2023

"Be careful not to be in my heart before you break it. You risk to hurt yourself...". I think these words sum up the story of Nagahiro and Agreste, the story of two hearts that didn't understand each other. On the one hand, we have the heart of Agreste, for whom love is a bottomless abyss where his heart falls indefinitely without any emotions to cling on to - hence the fact that he even comes to think whether he's not mistaken about the location of his heart, since he feels nothing. But in a way, who can blame him? It's a feeling he's never experienced before, so how can he put words or feelings to it? How can he simply love? On the other, Nagahiro's heart, a heart that beats to the rhythm of the love she feels for our mc, a heart that only asks to be loved in return. Again, what's wrong about it ? Was it selfish of him to ask Agreste to love her back? In the end, the flood of love Agreste had been asking for didn't arrive, and her heart dried up and broke. To give her a reason to beat again, Nagahiro wanted to break Agreste in the same way he had broken her. Somehow I come to understand the choice she made. It's sometimes hard to realize that the person you love doesn't love you back, or simply doesn't love you the way you'd like. Faced with this, some people will move on, others will stay put and others will remain turned towards the past, with the sole aim of making the other suffer as he made them suffer => the case of Nagahiro.
With the fog of alcohol now evaporated, the eternal pain in Agreste's heart resurfaces and the curtains of the past fall in front of his doors => a reluctance is created: his heart repels the flow of love, joy and happiness that Theresia's love transmits to him. This is understandable: on the one hand, love is a new feeling for him, and on the other, the only experiences he's had with it have been synonymous with suffering, destruction and, above all, loss. So what if allowing himself to feel and talk about his love will end up hurting or destroying the one he loves? And so, unconsciously, a reluctance is created between the two of them.
The memory of Agreste and the discussion he has with Cassea introduce a new concept: that of the "bridge of life" and a crucial question: "To change, to evolve as individuals, do we have to break off one or more parts of our bridge, or keep it in its entirety? If so, to what degree ? "
- Theresia: she had no choice: the "past" part of the bridge was broken by Franz Forger to push her forward towards perfection. In doing so, devoid of attachments, she could only cling to the only thing she had: writing so for her writting = moving forward
- Nagahiro: Agreste somehow destroyed her future, so she couldn't move forward and was "forced" to turn to her past => Agreste and destroy it.
- Agreste: He's just standing still : torn between moving forward and the pull of his past - his bridge hasn't been destroyed, at least I don't think so 🤔 only weighed down with regrets etc... and wounds caused by Nagahiro. So the issue for him now will be to choose whether he wants to break the bridge to move on => go towards Theresia/accept her love and love her back or whether he wants to keep it as it is because, after all, it's these wounds that have made him who he is today, and breaking the bridge would mean drawing a line under Nagahiro in a way, a person he cares about => perhaps a part he "would've never want to leave behind" . To determine the meaning of his heart, what will he have to do?

Side note 1: as for the destruction of  Theresia's bridge, something tells me that Cassea was involved. Why? Perhaps out of jealousy - destroying it would have allowed her father to finally lay eyes on her in a way. Also, it would tie in with the fact that, in the play they were contemplating, Cassea was the dragon of destruction.
Side note 2: about Cassea -> I'm divided
- part of me would like to believe that she's sorry she helped destroying Theresia's bridge and is therefore trying to make things right between her and Agreste as best she can
- the other part => Cassea has no regrets, on the contrary, Agreste is her puppet to further destroy Theresia and prevent their father's gaze from resting on her. What I mean is: in order to move forward, Theresia has to write, but Agreste is the one preventing her from doing so by distracting her from her writing => doing everything possible to keep them together would mean preventing Theresia from moving forward and thus destroying her bridge once and forever => this way, the thirst for jealousy burning in Cassea's heart will be quenched (it's a bit like Nagahiro's "destroy the other" logic towards Agreste).
Side note 3: perhaps Theresia is experiencing the same torments as Agreste and is therefore pretending not to remember anything to avoid facing up to her own emotions. The issue she is facing will be kind of " to move forward should I go on Agreste Bridge or keep moving on the writting one ? "

icon-reaction-1
Loading...
icon-reaction-2
Loading...
icon-reaction-3
Loading...
icon-reaction-4
Loading...
icon-reaction-5
Loading...
icon-reaction-6
Loading...
1
Your Heart has Meaning
Your Heart has Meaning.
Chapter:22