Han Quixote

Han Quixote

registered at: Nov 28, 2024
Roles
  • Author
  • Badge

    badge-silver

    silver
    Achievement
    Thumbs up Level 3
    Comments Level 6
    Published Novel Level 2
    Published Chapter Level 5
    Novel Cover Upload Level 3
    Time(Daily access) Level 4

    May 02, 2025

    My head isn't blank this time! I guess this is a sign of my own progress lol. I mean, then again, this chapter was the least insane out of the three chapters so far. Anyway, here comes the rest of the comment.

    At this point I just chuckle every time I see the intro, because I can tell there's like... actual knowledge in there, but at the same time it also feels overkill.

    The introduction to Anita was very well done. It genuinely felt similar to that scene in Fate/Stay Night (when Saber first appears). I am comparing it, but I don't mean that they're "actually" similar. This scene is powerful on its own.

    ... And then Tani goes like "nah I got my first member that's what matters." But even if Tani and the story itself play it off as a joke, it genuinely feels like a mesmerizing moment. The moment flew over his head, but not for me, the reader. Tani will be Tani, I suppose.

    I do like making a lot of comparisons to other works I've experienced, not because the works are inherently similar but rather because I like trying to explain the FEELINGS I get while reading a work. With that in mind, as I was reading this scene, I really did feel like I was rereading STEINS;GATE. The protagonist of that visual novel goes around collecting lab members similarly to how Tani is trying to collect club members.

    ... And honestly, I feel really nostalgic... Wow. This is a really nice feeling, to be at the start of something new and knowing that it will grow (I'm referring to the club itself, though I suppose it can also go for the novel in general).

    Dude, I swear to god I thought Anita was about to start using sign language. I was like no WAY the author is going to pull a stunt like that. And then Anita began speaking in Norwegian (... oh. Midas. I see). The reason I say this is because I assume it'd be quite difficult to write a story where the secondary protagonist genuinely does not speak the same language as everyone else, but... well, I think you're capable of pulling it off.

    (My guess is that someone else is going to join soon so Tani and Anita aren't just doing Duolingo lessons together 24/7. And damn, Tani doesn't need Duolingo--Duolingo needs him)

    And the Principal... haha. Ah, it's funny. I could just imagine a transparent JPEG of Principal Togashi doing a victory hand sign and just floating away behind Tani as he's reading the letter.

    Tani is a great character, by the way. I'm still thinking of him saying "Oh my god!" in the previous chapter. Like I'm imagining he's panicking but he says "oh my god!" with a strange mix of calmness and panic? I guess? Like there's a difference between "OH MY GOD!!!" and "oh my god!"

    I don't know. It's funny. Like he's so calculated but nothing seems to be going right (and it's even better because he did everything right--he just didn't think of literally every other possibility)

    I liked this chapter. Not as insane as the Ms. Shirai incident, but I think this chapter has had the most heart so far. I think it's probably Anita's quiet presence (you can tell she's kinda just like ???? but going along with it because she's nice haha)

    Good! :bee_thumbs:

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    AFG contest cover
    Ambition and the Foreign Girl
    Chapter:3







    May 01, 2025

    Hehe. This is a sweet chapter. The only thing that made me kinda sad (maybe even uncomfortable) was how dismissal Hachi was of Clara. She seems sweet. But Hachi seems to be a decent person, too. Just a bit withdrawn. I mean, one of his first thoughts was wondering if he should feed the cats his extra paninis.

    But yeah I was like "damn Hachi, play along with her dialogue a bit, will ya?" :honey_lol:

    Oh, by the way, what initially drew me in (I've seen this novel floating around for a while now) was because Hachi, in the cover, reminded me of Kotomine Kirei from Fate/Stay Night. Those arms, those lines on his face... his age...

    I'm realizing I might have unconsciously always wanted a good guy Kirei. Maybe that can be Hachi, haha. Not to say that they're that similar--I'm sure Hachi will have his own little charms that sets him apart. I don't mean to offend with the comparison. But I really like Hachi!

    The vibe is very sweet, and I like the special words you use in this chapter (I learned new vocabulary. Till and grout!). You also go into smaller details that make the scene feel alive (like describing the care Hachi puts into making the coffee and choosing to create a "swan" while considering that it could make Clara feel better). And the bits of humor is fun too (thinking he might give the wrong message by giving her a heart).

    There's a few minor things I do want to point out, like the fact that it says "scientist" instead of "scientists" in the opening paragraph.

    And this is a general thing, but there's a time in here where you follow up spoken dialogue with "She asked". I learned a while ago that you actually don't capitalize the pronoun even when you're following up a question.

    Here's an example to show what I mean: "Isn't Blend 1 a good chapter?" she asked.

    So you don't capitalize the "she" in this context. I think it's a bit strange, but I guess that's just how it works. I won't go too much in depth about it because I don't think I can explain the reasoning very well, and I don't want you to keep reading this long comment haha

    But other than that, this was a really sweet chapter. I'd want to walk into Hachi's shop and get something, too... but at the same time, he's quite scary :bee_sweat:

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    So what if the world is ending around me? I just want to make coffee. Is that so much to ask?
    Chapter:1


    Apr 30, 2025

    ...........................................................................
    ^Once again, this is my first reaction. This only happens when I read this novel.

    I am baffled. Again. I, well, hm. I mean maybe it's because I don't read or watch this genre? At all? But it feels like I'd be discrediting your creativity if I blame it all on my own inexperience with the genre.

    I mean... yeah, okay, let's just start the comment. I'll go in order of thought.

    So I do see that each of these chapters start with commentary of Tani's philosophies/views in life. It's a bit hard to read, but it does set a false serious tone each time it appears. Like you're thinking "damn, this guy is so deep", and then you get the rest of the chapter and you go like "okay what the hell happened". So while the opening monologues set a pretty hard contrast to the rest of the chapter each time, it also builds suspense, like "what on Earth is going to happen?"

    You do a very particularly good job in balancing dialogue and building the world. You have the leeway of assuming the reader can imagine the atmosphere on their own, but you don't. This is a good decision, in my opinion. The details of how each club is advertising themselves stuck very well in my head.

    Now, a very minor thing note I want to make here is about Mr. Wakanda. His name is funny because of Black Panther, but other than that, I did think the way Tani got his "support" for the club was quite outrageous. Definitely more outrageous than the toilet blackmail in the first chapter. It pushes believability, but it just bareeeeeely fits in the "I can believe this" spectrum. So yes, nothing wrong with that. But just noticing that you were walking a very thin line hahaha

    And an actual thing I'm confused about: what's a gotokoi? I genuinely can't find any information on what it is.

    Anyway, Mr. Wakanda's existence/role in the story actually matters because Tani's relationship with him serves a complete, COMPLETE foil to Tani's relationship with Ms. Shirai.

    Genuine insanity. Absolute mayhem. I mean, what? What????

    It's hard to explain the system this chapter uses. So let me just draw it out.
    Mr. Wakanda: unbelievable manipulation --> plausible outcome (Tani's poster gets hidden behind other posters)
    Ms. Shirai: believable manipulation --> WHAT THE ACTUAL ***K (Tani, a high schooler, gets rizzed by local 27 year old teacher)

    Holy moly Jesus what??? I mean, do I have to explain further? Do I????

    ... Either way, it works. IT WORKS. I mean, Jesus... Jesus, man. Outrageous.
    But it's also funny because it spends so much time making Tani's manipulation of Ms. Shirai believable (like, I actually found it really clever and interesting how he uses the sweets tactic) and then just FLIPS the table and goes like "alright she got rizzed by Tani and now she's rizzing back"

    CRAZY. And Tani is so unintentionally funny, too. "Oh my God! What if no one comes!?" Reminds my of that one image of Light Yagami slamming his desk and grabbing his head in panic HAHA

    And then there was that earlier suggestion before the big reveal ("Unless... she could do Tani a little 'favor'."). I was like "wow this is phrased really weirdly. But no way, right? Yeah, no way." And then BAM. Mic drop.

    Ahhh. Not my usual cup of tea, but is still sweet nonetheless. You've done an excellent job with this chapter.

    Ahhh. ahhhhhahaha.... Ahhhhh.... Ahhh God the teacher rizzed the student... ahahahaha............. I'm losing my mind........

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    AFG contest cover
    Ambition and the Foreign Girl
    Chapter:2


    Apr 30, 2025

    Holy Jesus this is peak
    I mean, I don't use that word often (I have no idea if I've ever used it at all during my time here at HF) but this is actually PEAK :bee_wheart:

    This is probably going to be a long one. I'm so sorry there's just so much here :bee_sweat:

    But let's start in order before I get ahead of myself haha. This time I'll start with the interesting writing choices you made.
    I first noticed this in the last chapter, but there are segments in dialogue where you simply summarize the exposition instead of writing them as explicit dialogue. I was curious why that was done at first, but now I see that it's an excellent way to save time and also create more diversity in exposition. It can also be attributed to Yalda's own childlike nature (she probably just mentally glosses over her Uncle's exposition, especially if it's something that's considered "mundane" to her).

    Second, the "*crunch crunch*" near the beginning made me laugh, but I think it works to add to your own unique writing style. Your writing is strong enough for a reader to know that you wrote it like that intentionally.

    That's about it for that... now for the actual story.
    First, the mana crisis makes a lot more sense in this chapter. It's not just a life force or "energy"... it's also something that protects the world from becoming "monstrous" or "chaotic". Literally the first thing that comes to mind is Dark Souls's idea of "hollowing". An undead person becomes "hollow" when they don't have a steady supply of "humanity".

    It also does remind me of the "Age of Fire", another concept in Dark Souls, but I don't understand the lore behind Dark Souls too explicitly to make a valid comparison between that concept and this.

    Anyway, it blows my mind that this world has such similarities, because it seems to me that Yalda's limited perspective on the world slightly prevents the reader to understand what exactly is going on. But upon closer reading, it becomes reading how horrible the effects of Low Mana Affliction is. I mean, if our protagonists GENUINELY FAIL to carry out their mission in this story, this world is could genuinely turn into Dark Souls IV. The stakes are actually quite high.

    I mean, I hope you don't take offense to the comparisons. I say you've made it this world distinct enough for it to stand on its own.

    Another thing is that Mr. Goblin here knows something about Yalda's race that she doesn't. I mean it should be pretty obvious that Yalda has an extremely limited perspective on life, given that she's six, but his allusion to a dark past really, REALLY makes it clear that Yalda doesn't know things. And in turn, we don't.

    And the idea of "fake angel"... huh. Wonder if it's because she's mechanical. And I haven't watched Invincible, but it does make me wonder if there's going to be some kind of similar twist later on (if yes, it's probably not to the same extreme extent...? Right...?)

    And the three commandments.... Asimov's Laws.... really makes something clear, huh? Haha

    The finally, the magnificent tree brings everything together. From the cave walls to the halo of symbols and to the hobgoblins living in the geode spheres... this is fantastic. I KNOW this chapter had a lot of time and imagination devoted to it. It's crazy.

    But the chapter works as a whole because of all the little things combined together. This chapter makes the concept of Mana and life really special, which amplify the mythical presence of the tree.

    Everything in this chapter works together so nicely it genuinely just blows my mind.

    Oh, and FYI, the music that I decided to listen to in the middle of reading this chapter was "The Ancient Dragon", from Dark Souls. If you know when that song plays in the game, you'd immediately understand why I chose the song (hint: it plays at a "lake").

    Fantastic, FANTASTIC job. :bee_thumbs:

    (Oh, and I obviously noticed the Minecraft references too haha)

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Face of Eternity : The Journey of a Little Angel (Cover art)
    Face of Eternity : The Journey of a Little Angel
    Chapter:5



    Apr 30, 2025

    To:Orionless

    Anyway, I think these last two chapters are kinda the end of everything. I've spent the last few hours writing about that other scenario I mentioned (the dark and edgy one), but...... I mean, that's all it ended up being, really. Dark and edgy. No real merit. It ended up mostly working off the "shock" value.

    These two chapters are a bit weak in retrospect (trying to distance myself from the protagonist too far probably backfired), but it these two chapters mean much more to me than that other scenario I've been working on. Perhaps these two chapters are weak as "stories", but I do feel like I've gotten something out of my heart.

    I don't feel much of a need to write after this.... which is ironic, seeing what I've written in the first chapter here. "The protagonist always comes back to write", yeah. But I feel like this makes it evident that I don't really have anything "tangible" left. It would be very hard to follow these two chapters up, because they aren't structured like stories. These aren't really stories. I SHAPED them to be like stories because I realized that if I didn't, it would just be an author (me) ranting about this and that. Yeah, maybe underneath it all, it's just a rant. There are no valuable conclusions that are reached here.

    So yeah, these kinda suck. And I don't mean to bring myself down (or make you feel guilty), but like... these aren't really stories. They're more observations than anything. It's like listening to a tour guide explain something at a zoo.

    I mean, this is anticlimactic when you put this next to the fifty chapters I've produced over the last few months. I genuinely, genuinely doubt that I will be able to create another "novel" of that size and heart. Because yeah, I've written my heart out. What's left are the little pieces... and also the dark parts of my heart, which, I really don't see a point in writing about. I don't think it'll help anyone, including myself.

    And even then, I have no idea if that other novel is capable of clicking with others. One of my friends asked me to send them my finished novel, and I was like "hahahahahahaha no sorry". Because I don't actually know if it's good. So even now, I have no idea if ANY of my writing efforts will hold water in the long run. Heart isn't everything.

    So I think all that's left for me, at least for now, is to... yeah yeah, revise that other novel, I agree. But as for what comes AFTER... well, I don't know. I think all that's left for me on this platform is to support some of the writers I've formed connections with (including you) until they reach the end of their works.

    I guess I'm writing this to amend my comment below, because I do see that these two chapters are kinda meh? I mean I personally felt some kind of catharsis by letting it out, but maybe no one else will feel the same way.

    And yeah, as a reminder, this isn't me trying to guilt trip you or anything, it's just a genuine admission that I don't think these chapters work as reading material. So don't feel bad. I don't consider these chapters to be complete garbage but I do see that they're probably not as strong as I thought they would be.

    Either way, I'm just going to spend the next week (there's literally a single week left now) revising my other novel, while I try to support you and a few other writers. And then after the contest is over, I'm probably just going to read the other writers' novels to completion. That's it. I'll probably disappear from the scene once there's no more writers I have left to support.

    Maybe once the contest is fully over, I might come back to create a slightly more better world for my adorable characters to live in, but... I mean, that'd literally just be fan service :honey_lol:

    I'm going to leave these two chapters up as they are because I do feel like even if they're meh as stories, they also do carry my thoughts that I did want to express, so....... yeah.

    I'll pass the writing baton onto you for now. It's all you, buddy :bee_thumbs:

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Blue Monday Cover 2
    Blue Monday
    Chapter:2