Han Quixote

Han Quixote

registered at: Nov 28, 2024
Roles
  • Author
  • Badge

    badge-silver

    silver
    Achievement
    Thumbs up Level 3
    Comments Level 5
    Published Novel Level 2
    Published Chapter Level 4
    Novel Cover Upload Level 3
    Time(Daily access) Level 3



    Apr 10, 2025

    To:lolitroy

    Hm... yes, it is a "Big Crunch scenario". And yes, I do agree--if there was about three weeks left until the universe collapsed in reality, humanity would have died off long ago. Thanks for pointing that out.

    Humanity would probably have die off due to radiation a long time ago, probably millions or billions of years ago, haha. Not even from heat, at that point.

    But I guess what's going on here is that "Atlas" pushed back the original "edge of the universe"--but the process is accelerated because the "force of the sky" continually increased while "Atlas" also had to increase his force upwards. That's where the "infinity" plays a part. Is this realistic? No, absolutely not.

    The thought behind this was that essentially what should have taken countless years to happen is happening at blinding speeds because all that force exerted inwards by the "sky" no longer has an opposing force from within.

    Of course, I think if this was the case, the world probably also end very quickly anyways because... well, if everything is collapsing that quickly, yeah, realistically, everyone would die.

    It's a bit unfortunate that I can't fully justify the idea behind this novel. But... I guess my thought was that this entire novel is more of an "analogy" that I can express my ideas with. So I wasn't overly concerned with the details, but I did try to tingle people's brains a bit. I like science, after all (which makes it slightly embarrassing that I may have misused it).

    But you were sharp enough to see through it, haha 😅 I'm not sure how I should approach this problem. The benefits of this insane plot is that it gives me access to use extreme examples to discuss philosophy... but the downside is that I sometimes just sit down and think like "man, I need to make sense of all these powers and events I made up for the sake of the plot."

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Mr. Atlas Cover 4
    Mr. Atlas
    Chapter:2

    Apr 10, 2025

    Ahaha (insert Will Smith laugh)

    I wonder how I should explain myself or IF I should explain myself. But as a fellow writer, I think I'll just explain a little bit of my thoughts.

    Well, actually, first of all--I agree. This does feel quite anticlimactic. The entirety of the plot (seems) to be reaching its climax, and the characters (especially Abigail) acknowledge this to be a pivotal moment. So if this seems anticlimactic, you would think it’s an issue.

    And I did think about that while writing these chapters--actually, this feeling began all the way back in the "Heart of Steel" chapter. It felt like I didn't build it up enough--or rather, that I've built all this up just to, you know, cause it to result in this. I wouldn't say it's the result of, like... an "okay I give up" moment, but it's more like I kinda just accepted this to be the vibe. And frankly, I don't actually KNOW how to make this more suspenseful. And one of the issues with making it more suspenseful, frankly, is that it doesn't exactly match what I'm going for.

    "It's not the point" is something I've said before, and I want to say it here, too, but I do think it sounds like an excuse--and who knows, maybe even I will miss the point of the story at some point and leave everyone disappointed (including myself). Maybe I'm accidentally tricking myself into just accepting the story for what it is instead of evolving it even further.

    But I did come to accept that the lack of suspenseful mood, to me and what I desire from this story, isn't too big of a deal in the long run. Because... from what I see, the story IS kinda silent. I won't go too much into detail because I do want to see how you view the story in the long run without me telling you "oh you should be thinking ______, because this is actually what I intended."

    And the setting change, too--there's also a specific reason why the setting didn't change. You'll probably be able to understand why in the next few days. It's not really supposed to be a big, big deal, but the setting of this chapter is "subtly" crucial for what's to come. And it's not really an interesting move from my perspective, because it's more like I chose the setting BECAUSE of foresight (I did actually think of changing the setting of this chapter, but then realized it would make something else more difficult later on).

    Btw, HoneyFeed went down twice while I was writing this comment, haha. I hope it’s not my fault 😂

    Still. I encourage you to keep calling out your thoughts like that (like if you think it’s anticlimactic)--it still gives me thoughts to shift the direction ever slightly. Like to lean into something more or to stray away from it. The end result of the next chapter hasn’t changed, but I’ve been thinking about the chapter and how to approach it… and after reading your comment and contemplating, I think I’ll lean away from something and lean more towards something else. I believe it will better fit what I am going for.

    Or maybe I’ll change my mind again, who knows.

    And there’s also an issue with the word count, by the way. I’ve been thinking that I might have to cut down on some chapters in the back if I’m not careful and overly decorate things that won’t contribute to the novel in the long run. Like perhaps I can make these chapters more hype and suspenseful, but I also need to ensure that I say everything I need to in the upcoming chapters. So I might be ignoring things that I feel won’t affect the story in the long run.

    You have no idea how shocked I was when I uploaded these two and realized I was at 44k words LOL it scared the heck out of me. I still have a lot left to say in this novel.

    And I can explain a lot of things here, but I feel like it might take away too much from your experience if I literally explain EVERYTHING I'm thinking, so... haha. I'll just leave it there. But thank you for the feedback--I do think it will push the next chapter in a slightly different direction... just probably not in the way you initially thought? You made me realize what I consider to be the truly important parts of my novel are, I guess.

    Bro this comment almost has enough words to be a chapter of its own LMAO man I rant so much sometimes

    Anyway, I hope my next chapter works out! We'll see! Thanks for your help!

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Mr. Atlas Cover 4
    Mr. Atlas
    Chapter:29



    Apr 10, 2025

    It's funny because for some reason, I always, without fail, understand what Soren is thinking. I acknowledge his decisions to be realistic. Should it be condoned? No. Should anyone act like he does? No. But do I know that this could happen? Yeah. Without a DOUBT. So good job on doing that.

    This is a solid chapter. I don't want to compare it, but I'd say it's more solid than the previous chapter. This is REAL. REALL.

    One sentence that stood out to me and slightly bothered me was when Soren says "was being friends what he really wanted from me?" Maybe it's fine, or maybe there's a reason it caught my attention. Up to you.

    But for the most part, your writing is always solid--there's generally not many awkward sentences. You definitely know prose very well, whether or not you realize it. I have never, EVER had an easier time reading a story. But perhaps there are some demerits to this that I can't articulate just yet... who knows? But know that your sentences are NEVER difficult to understand.

    But this chapter is solid. Very readable, yet also very dense with interesting information. That random incident with Midas... I really doubt that it's not a case of the Chekhov's gun. Haha. I mean, let's not kid ourselves here.

    And Soren has that sigma grindset 😂 but he also possesses all the negative traits that come with it too haha

    Soren is without a doubt my favorite character--not because he's a good person, but because he's always making the same (bad) decisions I made in the past. Not exactly the same (he's worse in his reasoning and probably more handsome than me) but I see the parallels, haha.

    I love the structure of this chapter. There's an incredible mix of introspection and dialogue. It's awesome. Probably my second favorite.

    ... Wait, actually, that brings up an excellent point. I'd say both Chapter 1 and this chapter follow a very similar formula. Both chapters have a good mix of introspective thoughts and dialogue. And by introspective thoughts, I also mean observations of the protagonist of the chapter (ex: back in chapter 1, when Adella describes Midas throughout the story).

    Whoa...? Maybe... Maybe that's what works really well? Huh. Huh... this is a sudden epiphany... :honey_questionable: Interesting. Unfortunately it's probably more difficult to use this formula with characters who intentionally hide their inner thoughts from the audience (this is probably Midas). But for Soren and Adella, it works.

    Just my two cents. And some extra, this time. So three cents.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    2
    Another Twisted Normality
    Chapter:7

    Apr 09, 2025

    To:Orionless

    Yeah, it's funny--when I first began writing this novel, I thought there would be another segment of build up for Victor's character... but I thought about it and I genuinely decided that it was a waste of time. At least, for what I was planning. If you really think about what would have happened between the flight and this scene, it'd just be more scenes of Victor being wishy-washy. And perhaps this would have been fine, if I had something I wanted to say--but there wasn't. For most of my chapters, I always have something that I feel allows the chapter to stand alone... but I don't think that would have happened with additional chapters for Victor. Unless, of course, it was set in the far past.

    But yes. It's implied that he was getting increasingly serious as the time to decide arrived. And like he said--he's out of time to decide.

    And I will probably not use any revisional chapters for now, unless I think of a scene that's really crucial that can positively affect how the current scenes work. But I don't think it's needed--I've set the foundations. So hurray for both our brains and sanity.

    I'm gonna say this, though (because I thought about this while writing, not because you brought it up): it might seem the like active screen time of the protagonists are pretty unbalanced (seeing that the second part of Abigail and Victor's journey was set in their past while Atlas and Co did everything in the present) but I'd say it might be less of a concern in the end when everything is done.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Mr. Atlas Cover 4
    Mr. Atlas
    Chapter:27


    Apr 08, 2025

    To:Orionless

    Nah, it wasn't out of pity. It was genuine shock!

    And damn, it was intentional?!... It makes in retrospect, but it's a strange feeling, knowing my observations weren't just a fluke. Maybe I really am a detective :honey_questionable:

    Wait, word count? Are you planning on going 75k+ words???
    And about the descriptions--I'd say don't stress too hard about it. I'd say it could help with visualization, but as I've said before, the reader's brains generally fill in the scene 99% of the time. But it also means the reading experiences will probably be less consistent.

    But I forgot to mention one more thought I had while reading this chapter. You know the italicized "inner dialogue" that we use? Here's food for thought: it's more natural for some characters to use them frequently, but for other characters, it feels less natural and sometimes makes it questionable.

    Let's use an example from ACC: Adriel is a very comedic protagonist, and he often uses sarcastic jokes internally to "get back" at the people he's talking to. In his case, the frequent use of italics make sense and work.

    I would say that for certain other characters, it could be more ideal to lower the frequency of these italicized inner dialogue and only use them when absolutely necessary. I'd say you nailed this well with Soren.

    I think this is more of a thought I had than "criticism", because I can't really pinpoint anything in this chapter. I probably had this thought because the frequency of the italicized inner dialogue increased near the ending. Interpret this however you want.

    Honestly... I'm always slightly uncomfortable when pointing out specific things in someone else's writing like this, but I just wanted to share my thoughts. It's not about changing your mind--it's more about telling you what I think and observe as one of your readers. You can always disagree or just shrug it off.

    But yeah... just my two cents. I still think this chapter is solid. It sets up what's to come, yet leaves ambiguity to what's actually gonna happen in the following chapters. And Midas himself is quite intentionally leaving his narrations mysterious to the reader LOL

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Another Twisted Normality
    Chapter:6

    Apr 08, 2025

    This is the second time I've read this acknowledgement page. I remember that this was actually posted on a different chapter, hence the strangeness of the comments between chapter 24 and 25.

    You already know I've read your novel when you had that premature conclusion, but I haven't been able to read the new additional chapters (the final two) until today. And because I'm having trouble falling asleep, I decided it would be a good time to finally put this story down instead of lying in my bed staring at my ceiling in the dark.

    Yes, it could be said that your story's immense potential was never fully realized... but it really had its moments. And I know that you have had a busy life, so I won't say more. I won't talk about what could have been done and etc. I'm sure you've already thought about it.

    But I just wanted to acknowledge that I've read the revised ending. And... yeah, I could tell you ran out of time. But you went the distance. That showed me you care... And I'm proud of you for doing that. I wish I could have told you sooner.

    My secret hope is that one day, you'll be able to fully express your ideas, either by revising this story or by creating a whole new story. The 2024 contest is over and the winners have been announced, but... you know, I will forever remember this novel as the first story I read online that made me go against my policy of "not interacting with strangers online." That initial shock I had from your initial concept changed how I viewed this website. You made me recognize that HoneyFeed is full of ideas with potential, which are sometimes realized and sometimes not. I'd say that this novel was a case of both.

    So... you did good, Doremine. What you do later on is entirely up to you, but know that there was gold sprinkled throughout this novel.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    0
    NORA-2 A
    Synthetic Love
    Chapter:25

    Apr 07, 2025

    Haha, alright. Okay. Midas is apparently smarter than me LMAOOOOOOO
    Ahhh. That's hilarious. I'm actually dying right now he explained away everything that confused me from the previous chapter

    You got me man 😂

    Ahhh. I think this is interesting. What an interesting way to tell the story. Here comes my other thoughts.

    I think this story's greatest advantage is the different POVs, and how differently they all perceive the world. There is a singular plot, yes, but in each scene, the reader catches the characters that are off doing their own things, thinking their own things, but the story comes TO them.

    In this chapter, Midas was just chilling in the stairway and thinking about whatever when Adella brings the story TO him. To me, that creates a fascinating way to connect the various chapters together. We're missing parts of the whole picture, but that's what makes it feel ALIVE... like the characters are all co-existing in that same world off doing their own things until the story comes to them somehow. And only when the story comes to them do we actually step in their shoes--so the plot progresses while everyone's off doing their own things.

    I don't know if it's an intended effect, but this is what I got from this chapter. And it's lovely. It's amazing in a different way from chapter 1.

    Now, I'm not certain where the "cursed child" statements are going. But now I know just because I don't fully understand something yet doesn't mean it won't click later HAHA wow

    And as a side note (to fully address everything I thought during the chapter), I do think that while the character's are very well defined and their interactions are clearly written, their surroundings remain foggy. So far I get that they're in a stairwell, but I don't know anything further... like if it's dark or if there's light shining through gently or something. But this doesn't harm the interactions themselves.

    And man... I can't believe how easy it is to tell who is talking with like... non-existent dialogue tags. I get it's in first-person, but it's still impressive. Wow.

    It's a solid chapter. I'm glad you followed through the previous chapter!

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Another Twisted Normality
    Chapter:6