Harmonica Writes

Harmonica Writes

registered at: Apr 19, 2021
MyAnimeList iconMyAnimeList icon
Roles
  • Author
  • Badge

    badge-bronze

    bronze
    Achievement
    Thumbs up Level 5
    Comments Level 6
    Published Novel Level 1
    Published Chapter Level 6
    Novel Cover Upload Level 3
    Time(Daily access) Level 6
    Winners - MAL x Honeyfeed Writing Contest 2021
    Participant - MAL x Honeyfeed Writing Contest 2023










    Jun 19, 2022

    Hey Parademero! Sorry for getting to your story late.

    I really respect and admire some of the stylistic decisions that you took. For one, interspersing song lyrics that you came up with yourself in between paragraphs in the prologue and first chapter was certainly a unique choice. Personally, I found it a bit distracting, but hey, some of the other readers seem to like it as per their comments, so good job I guess.

    Similarly, you also went with a non-diegetic narrator ala the narrator of Kaguya Sama Love is War who is separate from the 3rd person perspective presented in this story. Again, I see what you're trying to get at and it is pretty meta. Perhaps instead of going with

    Narrator:

    You could use a description like,

    The heavenly voice of a man unheard by all proudly declared, "xxx"

    I think that will look more natural in the context of a novel while also serving its intended purpose.

    So these are some of the stuff which I found pretty cool with Anti Couple Squad. A lot of other aspects of storytelling i.e. prose, events, characters, you'll be able to improve with more practise, so don't worry too much about it.

    For this contest, my biggest concern for your story is the prompt. Your story is tagged as comedy and romance, and is thus, under the rom com prompt I believe, but it also takes place in a school which is another prompt. As far as I'm aware, mixing prompts is not allowed. According to the rules on mhwc (dot) myanimelist (dot) net:

    "Avoid mixing and matching genres that target other prompt boards, this may cause your novel not to be eligible for any prompt board. "

    So, now that the first arc is over, you may want to consider having the upcoming chapters take place outside of the school, to avoid potentially getting disqualified. Then again, I'm not a judge or an admin, so I may be wrong. I'd suggest checking with Bubbles or Ana Fowl on Discord to get their opinion on the eligibility of your story.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Boi Mathew Shaw
    ANTI COUPLE SQUAD
    Chapter:6



    Jun 18, 2022

    Red-Black Course reminded me of the first time I cooked steak—red and undercooked on the top, black and burnt on the bottom.

    Okay, but seriously, it's dope. Cool premise, cool setting, cool characters—I really loved stories like this which are localised into entirely one area. While most cyberpunk entries are busy filling out paragraphs of scenery and technology, the events in these 5 chapters alone feel like double compared to a lot of other entries I read.

    Case in point—at this stage in the story, Rex has easily developed more than any other character from any other entry (that I can remember). Even Mitch, who first appeared like a typical bully, kinda redeemed himself in my eyes. It's this commitment to character which I feel is kinda lacking in a lot of other entries. Here, Red-Black Course develops in a way that feels naturally paced (not too fast), but is also impactful in what it's done. The "one more page" syndrome in this story is bursting out of the prison that is this website lol.

    So yes. While other entries are good in terms of setting, or writing, I can confidently say that Red-Black Course is the gold standard when it comes to characters. Sure, I know almost nothing about Rex, Mitch or Zain, but no other cyberpunk entry has made me this invested in its characters as much as Red-Black Course.

    Seriously, Chapter 4: Indomitable Will, has my vote for single best chapter out of any entry. It's the same kind of magic you see when Tanjiro learns how to cut the boulder in Demon Slayer. Is Chapter 4 the most cerebral thing to read? No. Is it the most original or most unique event? No.

    But that spirit of being beaten down and getting back up—something which I feel that every single anime fan is familiar with in at least one point in their lives, is absolutely shining in that chapter. The other prisoners betting against Rex to fail, Zain giving his all, Mitch being shocked, and most importantly, Rex going from sad bully victim to the only person that can stand up to Zain—it's stories like this that reminds me why I fell in love with stories in the first place.

    To other contestants reading this, remember—at the end of the day, you don't need to be a master of the English language, you just need to engage your readers at an emotional level. There are many ways to do it, but characters overcoming challenges is the simplest, most effective way to do it.

    Thank you, Walker, from the bottom of my heart. If there's more moments like Chapter 4 in this story later on, I'd be over the moon. It's inspiring, y'know? For someone like me, who definitely isn't the best at prose or stuff like that, reading an event which feels this raw is something that inspires me to emulate more in my own writing.

    If there's just one concern I have, it'd be that the "Cyberpunk-ness" does not feel as clear. Sure, there's VR and talking machines, but I do wish to see more cyberpunk elements, since that is the prompt after all. Regardless, I'm rooting for your entry. If you keep up this level of storytelling throughout Red-Black Course, then I can confidently say that this is a story—prompt-adhering or not—that deserves to be adapted.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    2
    Red-Black Course
    Chapter:5

    Jun 17, 2022

    One thing that I love about reading entries from contestants who're active in the Discord is that the quality never disappoints. Another score for Harmonica, yeay!

    Okay, serious talk.

    epicene, your name is pretty self-explanatory. The scenes you write are epic. I don't know if it's just me, but the watery nature of the story (tides in the title, starts off on a ship/harbor town), combined with your writing feels smooth like jelly. It's the kind of writing I expect on a novel that I find being heavily promoted in my local bookstore chain. There are absolutely no complaints from me on the writing.

    Another really cool thing that makes Y: The Tides Are In Our Hearts stand out from other entries (besides a fantasy school setting, which I'm biased towards) is the way character introductions and exposition are handled. With every paragraph, every chapter, the world and its inhabitants feel more colourful to me. It really, really feels like the start of a potentially epic journey, the kind with grand adventures, heart-tugging relationships and intrigue. Fantasy at its finest. That's why I love this so much.

    So...my nitpicks aren't so much my personal issues which I found while reading this story. I genuinely enjoyed it, let me make that absolutely clear. But exchanging my hat from a reader to a judge (I'M NOT A JUDGE, this is just hypothetical) of the contest, then there is an issue here.

    The hook.

    6 chapters in (5+1 prologue), and I don't think there's a scene that would make the average LN reader go "OoooooHHHHHH" or "Wow, god damn!". Since the very nature of this contest is targeting that demographic, I feel there needs to be a strong hook, a really attention-grabbing scene of sorts. Something that'll make the reader go "Crap, if this is going to happen later on, I MUST read the whole thing!".

    So here's my suggestion (feel free to ignore, you're the writer and captain of this ship), but I would suggest moving all the chapters including chapter 0 up one chapter and creating a new prologue. Start with a really powerful and engaging hook. It could maybe a climactic scene that takes place in the future, or something gut-wrenching that happened in Miieie or someone else's past. I feel that this would improve your odds of winning the attention of your target audience and the contest significantly.

    Again, personally, I love the way your story is going and what it hopes to achieve. Given that this is a competition that has to appeal not just to me, but the average LN reader, I do hope you can consider addressing the issue I posed. Again, don't feel pressured to do so (I won't blame you). I always believe the writer always has the final call, after all.

    Regardless, you really live up to your name, epicene. Reading your entry makes me feel grateful I'm not competing this year, haha!

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Novel Cover
    Y: The Tides Are In Our Hearts
    Chapter:6