minatika

minatika

~ minatika ~
she/her
I use too many emojis 👍

Offline // Focusing on personal life

I'm currently working with an Agency to publish my writing! ❤️ #FollowingTheDream #NextStopBookstores

registered at: Jun 02, 2023
MyAnimeList iconMyAnimeList icon
Roles
  • Author
  • Artist
  • Badge

    badge-bronze

    bronze
    Achievement
    Thumbs up Level 5
    Comments Level 6
    Published Chapter Level 4
    Artist(Submit fan art) Level 3
    Novel Cover Upload Level 1
    Time(Daily access) Level 3
    Finalist - MAL x Honeyfeed Writing Contest 2023



    Sep 01, 2023

    To:IceDonut

    As always, thank you for the spamming 😌 it is beautiful to read both the parts you likes, and the parts you would have loved to see be made stronger!! I'll reply back here, but not in as long of a format. Just know that I did read the whole thing!!
    (And regarding them having children 😂 that is not something I was going to bring up in the scope of the story. Personally I do not imagine them with kids, but that is my preference. If it would make readers happy to imagine them with children, then I would be fine with that too.)
    Character-writing is one of my favorite things, and it seems that came across well! Jun was altered a little bit in the beginning just to be a little less over-the-top, but he's still himself x) I couldn't completely change his character, because some of his silly head-strong traits that made him annoying, were also what prompted him to move along the plot and pursue the things he loved!
    There were A LOT of story ideas woven into this short plotline, perhaps a few too many, but I don't think any of them got too lost thankfully. There are a few points I'd like to edit (as always) mostly revolving around the World Breakers and the magic. I think I could foreshadow them sooner and fit more explanation in earlier in the narrative, to help tie in some of those "softer magic" concepts that got a bit loose towards the end. ("Soft magic" is not my specialty as a writer, but I couldn't make this story work without it. So I accepted it as a necessary evil.)
    I did approach this considering Isekai from a more "Slice of Life Isekai" variety (so considering anime like: Slime Taoshite 300-nen, Tondemo Skill de Isekai, Kami-tachi ni Hirowareta Otoko, Honzuki no Gekokujou) more than the typical "Adventure Isekai" variety (Re:Zero, Overlord, Escaflowne, etc.) So you are right to say it doesn't follow that usual shonen anime Adventure Isekai plot, and it doesn't end in a giant fight scene xD that was a personal choice. I did debate adding a "Slice of Life" tag to this story, but decided against it since the finale does try to go a bit more magical than that.
    Some of the plot events where Claire used her magic to help were indeed mostly for time (rather than not considering other options.) And I do agree, there are parts that could be streamlined if I had a bit longer to think about it and could come up with a more "simple solution" answer. I'm not really overly attached to any of my plot ideas. I just didn't have the time to debate them: I had to pick a direction and go with it, or the story wouldn't get done 😂 So if later on I have the chance to consider other options for the story, I'd be open to that! :D
    The only thing I'd debate you on is this story not being about romance xD because to me, Jun growing as a character through all the experiences he had throughout the story, IS what romance is about -- not just lovey-dovey experiences and dates, but truly growing and realizing how to "show up" for your own romance. But I realize this is a different perspective than the traditional romance path! And your points are still totally valid.

    But thank you again for your review! I truly do appreciate it, and the critical parts help me consider things in new ways. A lot of what you touched on as critiques were often things that I myself thought about, and often those were parts that were cut or altered for time's sake...and honestly, that makes me very happy to hear. Because it means that I was on target myself knowing where the story *could* be stronger, and if I wanted to revise this later with more time, I would be on the right path!! I am still very proud of it as it is!

    Thank you again Donut-dono 🍩 for your time! If I had more hours in the day I would immediately catch up with your story and return the favor 😆 but know that I will try to give your story an honest review as well here soon!!

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Love Sorceress Cover Art (Purple Edition!)
    With a Love Sorceress I'll Make My Romance Last!
    Chapter:40












    Sep 01, 2023

    To:Naru_Sheny

    Again, thank you so much for reading this story and for all your comments!! I appreciated all the feedback and made some genuine changes to the story that I think helped the narrative become stronger overall, so THANK YOU!!! <3 (And I hope to fully read Fantasia here soon, now that things are calming down~!)

    1. The title theme is back! Claire has return, and so has "With a Love Sorceress" because they're together. It was the perfect chance to use the title, and really bring it together. (I love getting to use the story title as a chapter title xD so I'm very excited to see Fantasia does that too!!)

    2. Ahaha some readers were more Mia/Toren fans, and a lot of people would have been sad (I think) if I didn't show them a little bit. But the focus of this final chapter (and book in general) was definitely Jun/Claire. There were moments where I could have expanded on Toren and Mia more (like you said, maybe showing more of their backstory, or showing the Amamiya/Toru date.) But I wanted to keep the focus on the main characters, and not get too sidetracked on the "secondary couple" which, as you just mentioned, some people weren't that interested in them xD (One of my biggest gripes in 12-episode romance animes is when the author gets too distracted with a secondary couple that they cut back the screentime for the main couple!! So I wanted to make sure I didn't fall into that mistake, while still giving Toren and Mia just enough screentime to feel fulfilling.)

    3. Yep!! Post-credits scene was definitely the vibe! Feel free to borrow it xD I'm certainly not the first person to use that style, so I don't consider it 'borrowing' really at all!!

    4. If I could make you even a little emotional <3 then I feel like I've done my job. As I said in my other comment, Claire and Jun becoming "regular humans" just felt too sad to me...and the idea of them becoming crazy world-hopping, fate-correcting cupids made me so much happier!! (Plus, if you want, you can totally imagine Claire and Jun jumping into other stories and being that "magical force" that brings the characters together xD which I love!)
    As for planned endings -- I started this story with a few endings in mind, and told myself I'd follow where the characters and readers guided me. If readers ended up liking Mia *more* then I was willing to make her the primary love interest (but Claire, well, won over everyone's hearts by a landslide!) With Claire as the intended interest then, my endings were either "Claire and Jun become World Breakers together" or "Jun stays human and Claire becomes human with him", I never wanted to do a 'split' thing where one was immortal and had to watch the other grow old and pass away (I would cry.) So then I decided, World Breakers was just too much fun to pass up x)

    5. Thank you for being along for the journey!!! "The wholesome romance aspect of this cannot be denied." -- let me just say, HECK YEAH!! I'm so glad you feel this way!!!! (And I did change that one point of criticism, so I hope it flows a little better now! 👍) Welcome to the "Claire best Girl" party. She's here for us all in our hearts ❤️ I did change Jun just a little bit in the beginning. Emphasizing the Dream aspect made his actions make SO much more sense, and it helped the narrative flow better. And I just changed a few lines of his dialogue from:
    "How could this happen?" Jun yelled.
    to
    "How could this happen?" Jun asked sadly.
    Which helped calm him down a bit. He's still a big baka xD but not one that's so angry and yelling.
    (Toren going beast mode will have to be saved for another novel. Though I admit, I'd love to see that too!!!)

    6. Ahaha I hope my story will do well! I've got Hime x Hime in my category, and that's a BIG contender! But as always, I wish everyone the best, and will congratulate all the authors for putting themselves out there, bravely posting online, and putting in the time and effort to write a story. That's no small feat. So really, I only have respect for everyone here!!

    Thank you so much again!!! :D (omg I didn't go over the comment word limit? Amazing!)

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Love Sorceress Cover Art (Purple Edition!)
    With a Love Sorceress I'll Make My Romance Last!
    Chapter:40