Han Quixote

Han Quixote

registered at: Nov 28, 2024
Roles
  • Author
  • Badge

    badge-silver

    silver
    Achievement
    Thumbs up Level 3
    Comments Level 5
    Published Novel Level 2
    Published Chapter Level 4
    Novel Cover Upload Level 3
    Time(Daily access) Level 3

    Apr 26, 2025

    To:Orionless

    I actually was going to add a certain dialogue in this final chapter where the god says something like "you'll be able to know who you were before you lost your memories" if he transcends humanity, but I thought it'd be a bit unnecessary dialogue. Like Atlas was slightly tempted by the possibility of recreating the world, but Atlas at this point has come to terms with his new identity that he would not care about who he was LOL

    I think that's the point, in the end. The first chapter of the story is titled "the nameless man", while the epilogue is titled "the mortal man". Like he creates his identity throughout the story and then is acceptant of who he became by the end of the story.

    Atlas COULD have been anyone. The only real requirement of being him is a really strong desire to protect humanity (because how else would you have lasted that long). Which... when I think about it, is actually quite a restrictive condition.

    I would say that someone like Abigail (someone who is eventually described as "insane" by Victor) fits that restrictive condition. I think Atlas and Abigail are both insane in their own ways haha (funnily enough, it's Abigail who first called Atlas insane).

    When I REALLY think about it, the story is basically about two "insane" idealists who try to reconnect two siblings they encounter (Atlas brings Julian and Mary together, Abigail brings Victor and Alice together). And then the two insane idealists go die alone in the name of their ideals and to protect the siblings from afar :honey_lol:

    It wasn't intentional... or maybe it kinda was, but I didn't explicitly think that.

    But yeah, the reason I don't bring up Atlas's old identity is because he would not care :honey_lol: he laments about it multiple times until the end of part 2, then decides he will just live as Atlas and hang out with the Everharts. And he remembers the most important part of himself anyways, so completely stopped caring after that.

    But I AM going to begin revision of the story until the end of the contest, so I miiiiight sprinkle little subtle details of Atlas's habits that can give hints at who he was before he became Atlas (like I don't know, maybe he ends up reading most of Julian's unread books, which implies he was a scholar. Something like that).

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Mr. Atlas Cover 4
    Mr. Atlas
    Chapter:50


    Apr 26, 2025

    To:Orionless

    It's funny because all three of these chapters featured last minute changes.
    Abigail Kovacs specifically had a lot more varied endings (in one version, she dies after being heartbroken by the boy's death, resulting in her ideals being shattered and wishing she was with the Truman siblings. In the original vision, she goes off to hallucinated heaven lol).

    I think the most defining change was Victor's ending, though. He was supposed to fall asleep feeling "saved", but I felt like something was wrong. And then I realized in that ending, Alice is basically being a complete saint without getting any rewards. So I did a 180 in his character and made him finally overcome his fears--not because he wasn't afraid anymore, but because there was something that mattered to him more than avoiding suffering/death. In my head, this revelation holds the three chapters together quite strongly. It was also probably the most emotionally charged, with Idealism II coming in as a second.

    I think Atlas's chapter generally works because of the two chapters--it's an affirmation of Abigail's ideals (of pursuing the ideal, not achieving it), and it's also supposed by the fact that Victor ACTUALLY manages to change himself in the last minute. I think in my head, the story actually comes down to Victor's last minute actions. It's kind of implied (not too heavily) that Atlas wants everyone to try and "spiritually save themselves" by the end of their lives--ergo, die in a way that they are proud of. And it's also Abigail's conversation with Victor (on how death doesn't mean you can't be saved) that initially pushed him over the edge holding up the sky once more.

    As for the Everharts, I think the main reason I held back on writing them for the finale is because I did want to leave it a bit ambiguous. They're regular people, unlike Victor and Abigail who basically had their destinies written out--their ends can sway towards Abigail's ending or Victor's ending. I also didn't want to give the Everharts a proper "good ending" because it would overlap with Victor's ending, but I obviously didn't want to give them a bad ending either LOL

    But it was a bit strange to leave them out of the finale, so Atlas's chapter is also a way to wrap up the Everhart sibling's story indirectly. The god's existence itself is a testament to our Julian's character, while it's Mary Everhart's existence that has come to define Atlas's view on humanity (and of course, the god's existence is attributed to Mary. In a way, they were both born from Mary's decisions).

    And I think the point of Mary isn't really about a triumphant victory, either. It's not that she's suddenly this person who really, really loves life. It's more like she has gained the quiet strength to live one day at a time without giving up on her life prematurely because she believes that things can get better.

    Oh, and Atlas's original ending was supposed to begin with his death and be followed by a narrator's explanation of his motivations and etc, but I figured that would kill the vibe, haha. So you got this instead.

    Anyway, thanks for coming this far. I'm truly thankful for your presence in this story.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Mr. Atlas Cover 4
    Mr. Atlas
    Chapter:50

    Apr 26, 2025

    So I've gotten pretty much used to the style now and have said enough about that, so I'm confident that this comment will be a lot shorter than the previous ones. (Maybe?)

    One interesting thing I noticed is that Yalda's incorrect pronunciation of the "Nalnara Gate" leads to her Uncle explaining what a Manona crest is. In my head, I found it very clever to use this as an opportunity to allow her uncle to provide exposition while also playing it off as a joke (banana crest). I don't know if it was intentional, but I found it an interesting way to approach exposition.

    Okay, the highlight of this chapter for me was definitely the description of Elysium and Paradina. So if I'm correct, Elysium is basically Earth flipped inside out, and Paradina is a moon that is at the center of all that. The CLOSEST thing I've seen to Elysium in fiction actually comes from Gundam's space colonies, but there it's a cylinder rather than a sphere. Absolute INSANITY :honey_lol: what kind of a world is this?! (obviously this is a compliment). When I realized what Elysium seemed to look like, I immediately played the song "The Girl on a Space Colony" on Spotify, haha

    And oh. The comparison of Manona crest to flint and steel... I eventually ended up hearing Jack Black's voice in my head :bee_sweat:

    Anyway, extremely a minor error (?) I've caught: Paradina is not capitalized at some point. I only accidentally noticed it after reading and going back and forth while typing this comment.

    Oh, and interesting thing: there's a point where you typed " kinda' " in the second segment of this chapter. I thought it was an error until I realized that people do say kinda' with the apostrophe at the end. So I'm learning new things here. Also learning new vocabulary, including "spire" lol

    Ehhh I guess my comment is still fairly long, but it's probably because the world-buildings is never-ending in this story LOL (this is probably a good thing)

    Good chapter :honey_dealwithit: and absolutely insane world-building

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Face of Eternity : The Journey of a Little Angel (Cover art)
    Face of Eternity : The Journey of a Little Angel
    Chapter:4


    Apr 24, 2025

    I did not realize the uncle was the bee (construct) at the end of chapter 2 :bee_nani: but it makes sense. Their entire living area seems to be bee themed. Kinda fitting, seeing that you posted this on HoneyFeed. And then he also has a humanoid form, which makes sense (if Yalda's uncle was a literal bee, I really wonder what her family tree would have looked like).

    This world feels like a "kit bash" of all kinds of things. I did NOT expect the periodic table to show up in this chapter :bee_sweat: but I think it actually works out pretty well. I think the most notable thing in this chapter is the part where they visually follow the scent of sulfur. It felt like it was inspired by those video game mechanics (ex: detective vision from Arkham Asylum, but I really doubt you took inspiration from THAT specific game).

    Once again, everything is descriptive. What really stood out to me was the description of the lobby ("large diamond shape projection..."). It genuinely shocked me that you described it when other authors might have just glossed over it. Maybe the details are a result of you literally building your own world from the ground up? Either way, what a pro :honey_nice:

    The greatest advantage of having all these details is that it does help the reader slow themselves down instead of reading through everything in the matter of seconds. So when Yalda (and her Uncle) goes on the quest to locate the origin of the scent, it genuinely did feel like it was taking time to find it. If there was less description, I think it would have felt like they just walked and turned for a few seconds then found it.

    I'm repeating myself, but it's interesting how the story is very good at pacing the reader (maybe it's because I know I'd miss out on a lot of what's going on if I blazed through it). Time passes as it should (ex: chunks of conversations process faster in my head while getting from "place X" to "distant place Y" takes longer to process).

    There is a little side note. Not that it's a big deal, but I wonder if there's an explanation between the relationship between mana (the energy that powers life in this world) and regular food. I know you're probably capable of explaining it even if you don't have a prepared explanation, but I'm just kinda curious if you had an explanation ready for that.

    Oh, and Yalda seems ridiculously overpowered as a character. I genuinely wonder what kind of (sentient) evil lurks in this story that would actually manage to threaten her :bee_sweat:

    Anyway, it was another creative chapter. :bee_thumbs:

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Face of Eternity : The Journey of a Little Angel (Cover art)
    Face of Eternity : The Journey of a Little Angel
    Chapter:3





    Apr 23, 2025

    I think the difference between the other "farewell chapters" (which there are three, four including this one, but I don't really count this as a farewell chapter) is that the other three farewells progressed the characters' story in some direction. Abigail left to return Victor, Atlas left to carry the sky, and Abigail & Victor separated to go their own ways to do what they need to do.

    The difference with those three and this chapter is that Julian and Mary... don't have anything left to do. Yes, they're leaving the apartment and they have to return to their parents, but they don't have an ambitious "mission" or "purpose" like the other three. This is the rest of their life now. There are no more (positive) changes left to their characters. Their journey of growth is over. All that waits is death. The only thing they have left to do is stay together and spend time together.

    It's not supposed to be dark, but this chapter was supposed to indicate that this is it for their characters. Their characters no longer will progress the story further, so they are literally exiting the story. Mary tells the three of them "good luck" because the rest of the story is literally up to them. The three phantoms exit the rooftop with their own purpose ahead of them; the two Everharts exit the rooftop simply because they have nothing else left to do on the rooftop.

    I mean, maybe it feels redundant, but these two genuinely have nothing left to contribute to the story. It's not that they're useless--they simply have given everything they could, while the other three still have things left to give.

    So while this chapter could be considered to be the Everharts' farewells to the remaining three, it's also their farewell to the story itself. This is their exit.

    They're not like "yippie" because obviously the world is ending, but I still consider this as a "good ending" for them. It's slightly melancholic, but it's also "okay" because they at least have each other. The original vision was to have them hold hands and walk off into the sunset (metaphorically), but I felt that it would be less believable than their reactions here.

    So this chapter might FEEL redundant--I did think about your point--but at the same time, all the farewells are a bit necessary to progress/finish the story.

    I think the word you might be looking for is repetitive (the word redundant is closer to "unnecessary"), which I do agree with, now that I'm looking back. I did do my best to make each farewell different, though.

    But yeah, that all said, all that's left is to resolve the other loose ends. Thanks for coming with me all this way :honey_thanks:

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Mr. Atlas Cover 4
    Mr. Atlas
    Chapter:47