Han Quixote

Han Quixote

registered at: Nov 28, 2024
Roles
  • Author
  • Badge

    badge-silver

    silver
    Achievement
    Thumbs up Level 3
    Comments Level 6
    Published Novel Level 2
    Published Chapter Level 5
    Novel Cover Upload Level 3
    Time(Daily access) Level 4






    May 25, 2025

    Okay, I'm not gonna lie, when I read the name "James", I had a feeling that he wouldn't be a character who would have much prominence over the story. His name has a lot less prominence compared to the rest of the cast... So around the time Napoleon walked up to the king, I had a sense that the King was already dead HAHA

    And THEN I realized the meaning behind the chapter title :honey_lol: it flew over my head.

    Either way, this is a great first chapter. There's a lot, a LOT to unpack here. I think Trojia was excellently built up to be a fascinating character. Her perspectives are fascinating, and though she has long dialogues explaining her own reasonings, the dialogues are constructed in a way that isn't just "hey, she is right and this is what the author thinks".

    And currently, it feels like Trojia's definition of being a villain isn't quite what a regular person defines to be a "villain", so it makes me a bit curious on what she really means to do.

    Now, I do want to mention that there were some things that took time to figure out while reading:
    1. The first two sentences of the story has a "zoom in" effect to King James, which is AWESOME after figuring it out, but I initially interpreted it as the author describing three different kings HAHA
    2. I didn't realize Niomyo was not a princess until Drey was introduced. There are hints of her being a "mere" escort to Trojia (ex: mention of her wearing light armor), but I don't think it was mentioned explicitly what Niomyo's role was in the story. Trojia was mentioned to be a princess by Niomyo by Trojia (which was a good way to not rub the fact all over the reader's face), but the role of Niomyo only had a few hints here and there. A part of me does think that I just suck at reading, but I do want to leave this note because it did happen while I was reading. Because this is a foreign world where the "old" clashes with the "new" (Ex: an elevator is being constructed), I do think some things need explicit clarification. A princess wearing armor could definitely be possible in this world, so explicitly mentioning Niomyo's status (but not necessarily in an "overkill" way) could be beneficial.

    Now, I do want to mention that I think this chapter would benefit from polish. For example, there's a sentence in here that lacks a proper punctuation at the end ("yet another long flight of stairs"). And I think a few parts of the story could benefit from better grammar (ah yes, grammar... the one thing I dislike talking about... which is also unfortunately the thing that I always end up noticing).

    And this was probably written before you realized that a lot of dialogues that end with dialogue tags (ex: "Hi," she said) end with commas instead of a period, so I want to point that out, too.

    Getting that all aside, I want to clarify that this is a very strong chapter with a strong premise. Trojia is already a fascinating character, and the general cast of characters promise to create unique interactions between her and the rest of the world... and of course, the other protagonist, Ubica, hasn't even been introduced yet. I do have a feeling that Ubica will serve as an excellent foil to Trojia. I mean, Trojia already stands out without the Utica as a foil, so imagine what will happen when the contrast is revealed...

    My personal hope for this chapter, though it is entirely up to you, that this chapter is polished and formalized. Other than that, excellent.

    And as a side note, this is one of those chapters where a reader could benefit from re-reading. This is a good thing, because this means that a reader can go back and pick up new details if they want to learn more about the world. So in gaming terms, this chapter has replayability, haha.

    :bee_wheart: I like this chapter. It's very long, but it allows the scene to play out from beginning to end without cuts. And the imagery is on point (though my brain sometimes has a hard time following along due to my own inexperience).

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    2
    Dantega
    Chapter:1








    May 21, 2025

    To:Deck of Cards

    I do want to clarify, though, that the two "different perspectives" probably made things easier for me, mainly because I didn't have to fill in certain mundane details of character "x" getting to destination "y". A story entirely focusing on Atlas or Victor would probably have required me to fill in the gaps and probably would have lead to unnecessary scenes (or perhaps I would have found a way to switch it up, I don't know). Essentially, the biggest benefit of the switches is that it allowed me to not write a scene for every little thing while also continuing to move the passage of time forward.

    I think the example I can give right now is the passage of time from 0.3 & 2.1, where in 0.3 we leave Atlas with his realization and then we switch to Julian's perspective in a completely different scene in 2.1. I think that without Victor and Abigail's perspective filling in the passage of time between the two chapters, I probably would have been forced to write a scene where Julian continues to talk with Atlas and then leaves for whatever reason. So it's kind of a "trick", I think, to skip scenes that are unnecessary.

    And... what? You wrote a story with 600k words? I mean, surely there's something you could salvage from it. Maybe if you cut down the cast and focus on efficiency, you can manage to conclude it? I mean, surely... Surely, right? That seems a bit sad to me. Then again, we humans have limited time, so perhaps there are things you find more worthwhile.

    But yeah, All the Light We Cannot See. I think it by FAR has the strongest opening to a book I've read in my entire life. It's so unique... And it's about WW2. A German boy who becomes a soldier and a Jewish girl who is hiding from the persecution. They eventually collide, of course. I never got to the point though LOL

    ... Damn, I really need to finish that book.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Mr. Atlas Cover 4
    Mr. Atlas
    Chapter:15

    May 20, 2025

    This is the sanest chapter I've read on this story. It's very mellow (despite there still being little things like steam coming out of Anita's ears when she's frustrated. Which, I think, is a good thing, because it helps sustain the tone of the overall story despite the chapter itself being mellow).

    I do like the message being told here, though it's a bit painful to think about it. Tani's mentality as a teacher is... well, like many school teachers out in real life.

    Their method of teaching is generally not adapted to each of their students, but it's very clear that people like Anita excel if they are allowed to learn in their own way. But it's not really on the teachers to blame... There are just so many people under their tutelage at their same time to the point it's impossible for them to adapt to all of their students, to bring them all to their fullest potential. The system does what it can.

    If Anita was enrolled in an actual graded curriculum by a school teacher with the same teaching style as Tani... well, if I was her, I'd just return to Norway. It's her senior year, man. Why would you go through that on your senior year...

    I don't know how I keep managing to pull these things out of a comedy novel, but I think this is why this novel functions well for me. The comedy isn't "just comedy", and there are ideas that readers can extract and apply without it being rubbed all over their faces by you, the author.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    AFG contest cover
    Ambition and the Foreign Girl
    Chapter:6