Steward McOy

Steward McOy

Hobbyist writer, attempting to improve. Criticism welcome.

registered at: Jun 26, 2021
Roles
  • Author
  • Badge

    badge-bronze

    bronze
    Achievements




    Aug 23, 2026

    Since you asked for comments about English, here are a few things I noticed. They're all small things. There weren't major issues when it came to English.

    First, you had a few run-on sentences. You did a good job varying your sentence lengths, but at the cost of writing some really long sentences that are difficult to follow. I'm not saying all long sentences are difficult to follow, but longer sentences are more difficult for readers to parse, so you need to make sure they're extra clear.

    The first line of the third paragraph is a good example. A semicolon is used in place of a contraction, in this case, "and". It's easier to see the problem if you replace that semicolon with "and": "The sound of the air is deafening, and my cheeks probably look funny—they wobble as I fall down faster and faster, and the ground is ever so closer, and now I can see the forest as the trees, each one fighting, however slowly, for its share of sunlight."

    You can kind of see the rhythm problem here. AND my cheeks probably look funny, AND the ground is closer, AND I can see the forest as the trees. Lots of different thoughts all strung together with a repetitive "and".

    In this one sentence alone, you're trying to convey seven different ideas:

    1. The sound of the air is deafening
    2. The MC's cheeks wobbble as they fall
    3. The wobbling makes the cheeks look funny
    4. The MC is falling faster and faster
    5. The ground is getting closer
    6. The MC can now see the forest as the trees
    7. The trees are competing with each other for sunlight

    There's no hard rule about how many ideas a sentence can contain in English. Your sentence is grammatically correct, but run-on sentences don't sound natural in English.

    For most sentences, what you want to do is make sure that the sentence contains one MAIN idea, and that the other clauses contain ideas that relate to that main idea. Occasionally you want to vary this a bit so your sentences don't get repetitive. It's OK for sentences to occasionally have two equally-important ideas, but you should be careful to make sure that both are easily understood by the reader.

    If I were to rewrite the first sentence of paragraph three where each sentence has one main idea, it would be: "The sound of the air is deafening. My cheeks probably look funny—they wobble as I fall. I'm falling down faster and faster, the ground ever so closer. Now I can see the forest as the trees, each one fighting, however slowly, for its share of sunlight."

    This breaks a single sentence with seven ideas into a sentence with one idea, followed by three sentences with two ideas. That's still a little repetitive. So let's combine one of the main ideas into another sentence. "The sound of the air is deafening. My cheeks probably look funny—they wobble as I fall faster and faster. The ground is ever so closer. Now I can see the forest as the trees, each one fighting, however slowly, for its share of sunlight."

    Now we have sentences with one idea, three ideas, one idea, two ideas. Less repetitive, and you have a bit of a rhythm going. You could rewrite the sentences to flow better with this new grouping, but I wanted to keep the language as close to your original as possible for the example.

    One thing I would recommend though, is you don't need an em-dash in that sentence. It's not wrong, but it doesn't add much. However, there are other sentences where they are used incorrectly.

    All three em-dashes in the library scene would be better written as periods. Generally, you only want to use dashes to replace commas or parentheses, not periods. But when you use an em-dash, to replace a comma, it always adds extra emphasis on what comes after it. You don't need that extra emphasis for the butterfly sentence. A comma would work better here.

    Perhaps that last one wouldn't stick out so much if you weren't overusing em-dashes. Although not a English grammar issue, the em-dashes in the second paragraph make the ideas in that paragraph difficult to follow. You have to reintroduce the kings as "they" in the last clause, but it's unclear at first whether "they" refers to the kings or the wings. And the sentence doesn't make sense if you remove the parenthetical: "And to think that every king did that, they did that and chose the ground, but why?"

    The "did that" repetition is unnecessary. You could write it as "And to think every king did that and chose the ground, but why?" However, the "but why" is a bit ambiguous. You could make it more understandable with a second sentence. "And to think every king did that. Why did they choose to live on the ground?"

    You have a similar problem with semicolons. The first semicolon use is correct, but the other two in the chapter are not. Semicolons are supposed to join independent clauses, replacing the usual conjunction. But there's no obvious conjunction the second and third semicolons would replace. Again, with the sentence about the wings, I think you're trying to fit too many main ideas into a single sentence.

    As for the semicolon in the sentence about the books, the clause that follows the semicolon isn't independent. It has a subject but not a predicate. Semicolons can only be used in front of independent clauses.

    Finally, there were just a couple word choices that don't sound natural in English. "Mopping" is an action that requires cleaning. I'd probably use something like "swiping" or "dragging." Also, instead of saying "losing my face", "losing face" sounds more natural in English. It's just a quirk of how that term is used in English.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Dare-dive
    Of Wings and Kings
    Chapter:1