IceDonut

IceDonut

25 | him/his | European

Writing since 2016 to find the fine line between the bittersweet beauty of sorrow and the feeling of deep human connection, creating worlds that provide shelter from reality, but also embrace its way of being.
I occasionally write comments/critiques that could be short stories on their own, so sorry for all the flooded comment sections ๐Ÿ˜…
Read into my current novel "Celluloid", if you are interested!

registered at: Sep 08, 2021
MyAnimeList iconMyAnimeList icon
Roles
  • Author
  • Artist
  • Badge

    badge-bronze

    bronze
    Achievement
    Thumbs up Level 5
    Comments Level 6
    Bookmark Level 1
    Published Novel Level 1
    Published Chapter Level 4
    Artist(Submit fan art) Level 1
    Novel Cover Upload Level 3
    Time(Daily access) Level 6
    Participant - MAL x Honeyfeed Writing Contest 2022
    Participant - MAL x Honeyfeed Writing Contest 2023







    Jul 21, 2022

    To:Katsuhito

    Yeah, the (or rather my) honesty might be a bit hard to swallow, but I'd rather receive harsh or very fussy feedback than to miss a part that had slipped my attention. And since I can't expect something I don't deliver myself, I'll gladly deliver ๐Ÿ˜…

    Yeah, I could tell the feeling was eating away at her, but only for certain specific moments like this one, where Hana shows Yukio the cold shoulder (probably without wanting to). I mean you might talk yourself into living in the moment to some degree, but that does not change the facts.
    My best friend in middle school moved away about two years after we first met. He also did not have the courage to tell me that he would move, because he did not know how to tell me. I heard it through a few classmates and I sure as well felt a bit let down by him. But he did not act like we were going to be best buds forever until someday the realization would hit me like a train. He did not play with my feelings, you know.
    Hana however acts like this and yes, she feels guilty for it at the same time. I can understand why she did not tell Yukio that she will move and that she did not tell him about the past events!
    But she became his girlfriend while knowing that she would break up with him after a short time! You can enjoy the present as much as you want, but either keep keep your hands away from him, fell really miserable and try to actively avoid him while failing or put the things to the table and let him decide on his own. Everything apart from that would be insulting towards Yukio.

    I'm sure you will relativize it by: "I could not resist against my feelings", "I've felt so bad while feeling so happy with you" and "Sorry, sorry, sorry!"
    But this would be an inner fight that does not just show in some lines Hana drops during a few talks. Her actions would differ. One day she would try to avoid Yukio and behave cold and repellent. On others she would act like nothing has changed and then suddenly be lost in thought, behave atypical for her cheerful self and so much else. This is not a small abuse of confidence, this is a really big thing and such an inner fight should be on her mind whenever Yukio enters her line of sight.

    But that is just my opinion ๐Ÿ˜…
    I made similar mistakes on previous stories and maybe I am very sensitive for that. Afterall it is your decision if you think that makes sense. ๐Ÿ˜Š

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    New Blue Memory Cover
    Blue Memory
    Chapter:21


    Jul 21, 2022

    Well ... that escalated quickly ๐Ÿ˜…

    It seems like Hana didn't know just since yesterday that she'd move to New York. The english lessons and books stood in her room since their first date (maybe a bit earlier, but that is the earliest foreshadowing moment I remember). I can not remember Hana really struggling with her feelings towards Yukio. She said that she was scared of the future and doing things that she didn't want to. This was obviously the event she was scared off. And yeah, it was Yukio who told her to live in the present - to forget about this damocles sword hovering above her, but in my eyes that does not give her the permission to make this decision for him. It surely is not an easy thing to say - that one moves to a city far away. Nontheless it is easier to say than to kiss someone. It would be okay if she told him about her move in the night they first kissed; if she gave Yukio the choice to decide himself if he would still be okay with enjoying the last days together. Instead she didn't say anything and he (of course) fell for her head over heels, picturing their future together, not knowing that it would soon come to an end.
    Maybe Yukio would be okay with falling in love for this short time. He would have approached the situation with a different mindset, but this here feels more like a terrible and deliberate betrayal from Hana.
    So much about how it feels ... But I understand why you did this. So let's talk about the technical details: This thing was surely conceptualized as a big plot twist to rip the love story apart and a) build it back up again to make this last uprise hit hader or b) to end on a more realistic note where both go on their own ways in life and have grown stronger than before. Constructing a story like this is completely fine, but you should rather do it deliberately and without being "unfair" to your reader's expectations. Yes, plottwists like this are allowed to hit hard but there is a difference between a cannon ball and a belly flop to stay with water synonyms ๐Ÿ˜
    Sure it might give too much away if Hana would have told him directly that there was something up, but she like COMPLETELY ignored the fact and knew how much she would hurt Yukio. It might be okay if she got carried away by her emotions and then started retreating from him to protect him from the hurt. Since she didn't do that, she feels calculating, cold and really bitchy ... and I don't think that this characterization of her was intended and all of this was rather meant as a hard hit into a wall.

    But that said I really like the Miyazaki approach to portray love not just as two characters findind together, but also as people growing together and leaving each others life's afterwards. But the character's intentions and personalities should always win over the plot. If you can't convey the plot while keeping the character's integrity intact, then the plot has to be changed. ๐Ÿ˜Š

    That said, I'm still interested in how the story unfolds further. And if there really is no way at all for them to stay together.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    New Blue Memory Cover
    Blue Memory
    Chapter:21