Dec 22, 2021
Hmmmmmmmmmmm.
I kinda feel bad commenting on these, I think I come across as harsh๐
๐
but here we are.
Can I ask why everyone is so young?๐
Like it's one thing having it be just the Captain but now the Captain's of the other ships too? Like why, is it just cause - Anime?
And tf was that meeting๐, these are officers with equal rank rigth? They don't just get to bully the new girl surely?
Don't get me wrong I'm all for officers bickering, it can be a great opportunity for natural exposition and character beats but this felt like something out of a highschool' drama between the cheerleader squad members.
Finally is it not a bit strange that the super Ai neither sent a representative or pre-planed the cities?
Like it's bad enough a girl who's barely old enough to have a collage degree is in charge of a spaceship but now she also gets to decide how the city of innocent civilians is run? What qualifications & experience can she possibly have for all this๐
๐
.
I get the impression with a lot of this your going for a Macross or Gundam style thing but in those shows the crew is young out of necessity and they act out of desperation.
It's really hurting your world-building alot that you aren't thinking the cause and effect of things through.
In my own work I find thinking logically about something is far more fun and engaging - Now obviously we all have different styles, but what I mean is that a reader can detect when you haven't really put enough though into something.
You could easily fix the captain's thing by having Emeralds be a rugid older person with the rank of 'Head-Captain' or 'Admiral', characterising them as someone stuck in their ways compared to the youthful next generation.
And the civilian thing, though it'll be a neat idea to see how each ship develops, is just a bit much for the old suspension of disbelief.
I hope that all doesn't sound too harsh, feel free to critic my book for revenge๐๐๐๐