Steward McOy

Steward McOy

Hobbyist writer, attempting to improve. Criticism welcome.

registered at: Jun 26, 2021
Roles
  • Author
  • Badge

    badge-silver

    silver
    Achievement
    Thumbs up Level 5
    Comments Level 6
    Published Novel Level 4
    Published Chapter Level 6
    Novel Cover Upload Level 3
    Community Level 1
    Time(Daily access) Level 6
    Participant - MAL x Honeyfeed Writing Contest 2022
    Participant - MAL x Honeyfeed Writing Contest 2023

    Jan 04, 2025

    To:Pope Evaristus

    Thanks so much for reading to the end and for you comments!

    You're not the only person to comment that you thought it was gonna be a more upbeat adventure. Maybe the cover gives the wrong impression. Maybe the start of the story gives the wrong impression.

    I also got feedback from a couple people that "incel" and "bfct" seemed to come out of nowhere, and that's something I really didn't explain well at all in the story. In one revision of my outline, I had a scene before the first guard duty where Sprout helps tutor Oliver on powerspear techniques. It introduced the powerspear a bit better and showed off Sprout's prowess with the weapon, giving an earlier indication of her sharp reflexes and making Ares's ability to evade her more impressive later on. But I ultimately pulled it out and returned to an earlier draft for the first chapter because it was tied in with other ideas that didn't fit in with the prompt, and I couldn't figure out what to replace them with. Thinking about it now, opening on Sprout in the library browsing imageboard archives and then realizing she's late for training could have worked well.

    But it also would have delayed the jump into action. There's a tradeoff there. While I think it personally would have made the story a bit better to spend more time in the village at the start, I worried about how that would be judged in the context of this contest, which really seems to want stories to get into their main genre very quickly. Regardless of the deadlines, there's still a word budget: The stories can't be too long. (There has only ever been 1 winner longer than 60k words, and that was in the first year when the word limit was higher.) Considering there's other areas I wanted to expand on, it's hard to say what the right tradeoff is. Maybe the only real way to figure it out is to write it all out as much as I want to and then make decisions on what to cut.

    That's an interesting idea bout only having one companion though. It probably does fit better into the constraints of the contest, but it makes setting up some of the interpersonal conflicts and commentary on humanity more difficult. It might also lessen the impact of the deaths. But maybe that's not as important as limiting the scope for the contest. That's gonna give me a lot to think about. Thanks.

    And once more, thanks for reading and commenting!

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    0
    Cover
    Neko Nuke Nightmare
    Chapter:21



    Usagi Days (Space Orcs Destroyed the Earth So Let's Deliver Packages in a Pink Kei-Car)
    Chapter:23


    Jan 03, 2025

    To:otkrlj

    Wow, thanks so much for powering through it like that. My notifications were on fire when I woke up this morning.

    Part of me wonders if I'm just not cut out for this contest. By my count, there are a total of 88 days between the announcement and the deadline this time. If I were to go for 50k words, that would be 568 words a day, but I estimate I didn't have writing time at all for about half of the days, so iet's call it 1000 words a day.

    Depending on who you ask, 1000 words/day is reasonable, but it's just not doable for me, especially not at the quality I want and not the way I agonize over every word. Due to the time constraints, this isn't the first draft, but it's still obviously not what I want from a final draft. I only hit 50k words in 2022 because I already had the book written and tried to clumsily shoehorn it into the prompt.

    And since Hivemind is trying to sign writers, it makes sense that they would want people who can write faster than I can. And there are certainly some people cranking out words for this contest. I'm jealous. Though I suppose there are probably a few who had a work done or nearly done and happened to fit the prompt.

    In 2023, I tried to have a few entries already partially written so I could get a head start, but none of them fit the prompt at all. So I didn't try that this year but I should have, since I had multiple ideas that would have fit. Still kinda kicking myself for not going with one of the simpler ones. Maybe the only contest winning move for me is to go for a simpler story so it doesn't feel cramped in 25k-35k words.

    Anyway, sorry for the long rant. Thank you for the feedback and the kind words. I'm glad you found it snappy and fun to read. Thanks for reading!

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    0
    Cover
    Neko Nuke Nightmare
    Chapter:21





    Jan 02, 2025

    To:Hype

    Thank you so much for reading to the end and leaving feedback! I'm really very glad you had fun reading it.

    In general, I actually agree with you about wishing more stories didn't go high stakes. I've complained about this to my friends before. "Why do we always have to save the world and kill gods in JRPGs? Why can't we, I don't know, embark on a long journey to return home from enemy territory?"

    But in this case, I chose the nuke for two reasons:

    First, I needed a reason for Sprout to go from 0 to 60 when it came to killing for the cause. For all her faults, Sprout is very intelligent. She immediately imagines the worst-case scenarios and realizes she has to subjugate herself to the cause. But that also creates a blind spot where she sees herself as doing everything she can, so she doesn't notice when she slacks. It also emphasizes that for all her faults, Sprout and the others aren't to blame for the situation, giving some weight to Ares's arguments. I wanted to show that contrast between her and Ares. They're both genetically-engineered killers who are the best at what they do, but what separated them was intelligence. Ares couldn't understand just how bad nuclear war would be. If the stakes were lower, Ares would have had a point about sitting back and letting the humans kill each other.

    Second, I'm an old anime fan, and there's a lot of nuclear angst in old anime. It's less prevalent here, but in a lot of my writing I like to commentate on anime tropes and their consequences when real-life otaku take them too seriously. I held myself back a lot in this story, but I couldn't help myself with that high school karaoke chapter.

    And, I guess, it also enabled the alliterative book title.

    As for being repetitive, thank you. I'm glad it didn't come across to the reader. When writing, I still feel repetitive. A lot of nodding, shrugging, smiling, turning to look at, etc. Breaking up dialogue is quite the challenge for me, because to me, the dialogue is the interesting part. When I get near the end of a book, every time I write a "She nodded" or similar, I feel like I've written it hundreds of times.

    Anyway, thank you again so much for reading!

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Cover
    Neko Nuke Nightmare
    Chapter:21