Steward McOy

Steward McOy

Hobbyist writer, attempting to improve. Criticism welcome.

registered at: Jun 26, 2021
Roles
  • Author
  • Badge

    badge-silver

    silver
    Achievement
    Thumbs up Level 5
    Comments Level 6
    Published Novel Level 4
    Published Chapter Level 6
    Novel Cover Upload Level 3
    Community Level 1
    Time(Daily access) Level 6
    Participant - MAL x Honeyfeed Writing Contest 2022
    Participant - MAL x Honeyfeed Writing Contest 2023

    Nov 16, 2023

    Some days, some nights…

    Man, but the Boondocks though. It may not be anime, but what a thing. A thing with its own sad production history. At least McGruder didn't work himself to death, and I hope nothing like that ever happens.

    And on that note, I hope you're taking care of yourself. It's a rough world out there.

    I don't feel like there's quite as much to comment on in this chapter, not that it makes it worse or anything. Having a slower chapter like this. It's still got a weighty theme, and it's got some important character development, but maybe it felt a bit lighter than usual.

    I do dig scenes where characters discuss anime. Obviously I do, and Whisper of the Heart is a perfect fit for this story.

    I wish we could have more of that kind of thing in published light novels. Literature has such a rich history of intertextuality, but Japan's got different laws about that kind of thing, and even in the West, the rise of making everything into an IP franchise can make it tough. Published stories have to be oblique in their references to anime. Light novel contests have rules against it.

    (There's a small typo in this chapter. "Kicking and scream.")

    What I can say is that the quote that opened the chapter made me tense up, but the way the chapter ended was nice and uplifting. As always, I really enjoyed reading this, and I look forward to the next one, whenever you post it. Really, take care of yourself first and foremost.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Just East of Eden Title Page
    Just East of Eden
    Chapter:21













    Nov 06, 2023

    "Oh come on, that's a stretch. Emitting mustard gas can't possibly be a—No, wait. I see it." - My thought process while reading this chapter

    "Sometimes a girl ripping sick clouds is just a girl ripping sick clouds." - Sigmund Freud, probably.

    You know, I never made the connection between Masako's troubled smoking and Lucille's troubled vaping and drug use. (And Shun's smoking? I really did take it at face value that it's a good way for an author to break up dialogue with action tags.) I just never identified it as a theme, or a tendency, and thought of it as a coincidence.

    I guess, in a way, I always felt Lucille's fantasies of living in slide-of-life anime Japan would clash too hard with the unwholesome reality of her drug use, but real Japan's got unwholesome social problems too, in the form of smoking, drinking, gambling, etc. Maybe she'd have to lean on different vices, but she'd still have the same underlying disease.

    So I've never read Boundary Scramble or Destiny Marine. Maybe I should one of these days, but if the description of Boundary Scramble's principal here is accurate, it appears to fit right in with Lucille's Eva fandom.

    OK, I've been beating around it too much, but I simply loved the conclusions Lucille came to on her vision quest. I don't think everyone picks up writing because they're lonely, or write as therapy, but certainly many do. Even so, she's got the right attitude. Writing is fucking kickass. There doesn't have to be a single reason for it. It's less destructive than many of the other things she's doing, and if she enjoys it, all the better!

    The pandemic stuff got me though. I can't believe we're like 5 months from the 4-year anniversary. Where did that time go? During the lockdown, it seemed to both stretch on forever because of the dread, but the days also blended into each other so much that, looking back on it, it's hard to say it lasted very long at all.

    Anyway, so as to not leave it on a downer: I loved this chapter.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Just East of Eden Title Page
    Just East of Eden
    Chapter:20

    Nov 06, 2023

    To:Pope Evaristus

    Glad to hear it. I was mainly worried that if I ended up extrapolating based on what you wrote, I could end up making comments that seemed more like a commentary on you, or things in your real life. Kinda like an unwelcome psychoanalysis over the internet.

    And yes, the feels ride was about Fran, mostly. I don't know if I can describe this well enough. In terms of appearance alone, Melissa looks like a healthier, more successful Lucille, right? On the surface, nbd. Fran has a type, this is just her finding someone else who fits the mold.

    But there's also another possibility, that she never quite got over whatever feelings she had for Lucille, even if it was just a small crush. I've suffered through enough lower-upper or upper-middle class dinner parties with new graduates to pick up on two distinct reasons for humbleness in a new career. Either they truly are humble, or they feel trapped on a trajectory, and that trajectory feels hollow.

    It's not too surprising. Sure, they had to study hard to get into a top university, but they had all the resources provided to them, especially if they were legacy admissions. They never got to choose their own path. It was cleared ahead of them by their parents. And now they're seeing the next part of the cycle. They'll work in a soulless job where they make more money and receive more accolades than they deserve, or at least more than people lower in the ladder. But the job doesn't bring them joy, it just brings them money and security, which they'll be expected to use to pave the path for the next generation, like their parents did for them. Even a lot of their interpersonal relationships feel fake, born of economic networking more than genuine feeling.

    And then Fran comes back to East Eden and sees Lucille. Maybe she's not really seeing the real Lucille, but the memory of that car ride where she truly felt alive for the first time, and she wants that feeling back. Maybe not enough to try to pressure Lucille into anything, but to realize she wants to break away from the life Melissa has envisioned for the two of them. And Melissa isn't dumb. She can put enough together to at least figure out that reconnecting with her high school friends/bullies probably played a part in this, especially since Lucille is also Fran's type.

    icon-reaction-1
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-2
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-3
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-4
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-5
    Loading...
    icon-reaction-6
    Loading...
    1
    Just East of Eden Title Page
    Just East of Eden
    Chapter:19