Aug 31, 2022
(So I waited a bit because there was a chance there would be an epilogue so now I’m doing the comment)
For its (in)famy (?) I was drawn into GEP, and I’ll say it right now: I am not disappointed one bit for that. What looks to be a cheap knockoff of the whole “elite school” trope turned out to be something a lot more. The tropes were pushed to their absolute limit to become the satirical wonder it is, but within that satire is another layer of underlying, real problems that I’ve seen for myself in a typical Asian school. The level of symbolism in GEP is unmatched, but perhaps it’s hidden a bit *too* well within your writing. Now, don’t get me wrong, I personally enjoy it a lot, but I feel like a problem that arose from the overly quippy and ridiculous style of writing is that it creates a major division between the readers - they love it or hate it, no in-between. And the fact that its dialogue is never-so-serious only further masks its main themes.
All in all, my opinion about GEP hasn’t changed from the start of my journey through it. Some might say it’s only s COTE-ripoff, some might say it’s too ridiculous to be taken seriously, but if people can go past that and really dig deep into its themes, they’ll find a hidden gem (for a lack of better words, ironic considering GEP’s popularity) of a story that they’d never realized otherwise.